how to get cialis out system neurontin feeling ketoconazole compatibility schnell schwanger durch metformin viagra doza sildenafil vitamin glinide metformin does amoxicillin get you drowsy depakote interaction with seroquel cuanto tiempo dura el efecto de la pastilla cialis cipro delhi belly doxycycline for bacterial prostatitis zyvox tablets to crush can i split my zoloft effect of clomid on cycle length is azithromycin is safe in third trimester of pregnancy danac ondansetron will i lose weight if i stop taking prednisone lipitor price in canada plavix scare is methocarbamol gluten free rasa research clomid lexapro liver health phenergan pediatric iv dose aciclovir 200 mg elter metronidazole entamoeba dogs 450 milligrams wellbutrin can paxil help bipolar yahoo answers buy cheap viagra uk arret zoloft vertiges viagra cialis.hu cialis cpr zoloft and 3rd trimester metoprolol venoso bula erfahrungen mit viagra online best way to buy cialis online viagra availibility in hyderabad order brand viagra online wellbutrin withdraw side affects half life of cyproheptadine tylenol and levothyroxine spironolactone in esld estradiol bajo en fase lutea nexium what is it used for wellbutrin xl 150 efeitos colaterais levitra length of effictiveness my cat ate lisinopril what does zithromax do to chlamydia cialis 5mg cijena que es la medicina ciprofloxacino how long does flagyl take to start working in dogs zoloft made me jittery reasons to take celexa how long stay erect viagra can i use cialis while on prednisone does bactrim come in an ointment aldactone a indicaciones celexa dosage reduction acyclovir cost price lotramine or orlistat levaquin no side effects proscar weightlifting xenical pastillas roche cephalexin oral antibiotic clomiphene citrate hat?sa ciproxin 250 mg cp absence of thyroxine ivermectin for pigs oral mobiclic 119 does lexapro eventually stop working can amitriptyline give you thrush levofloxacino para epididimitis cymbalta 9543 stopping nortriptyline abruptly how quickly do you get pregnant on clomid levothyroxine in usa experiencias uso sildenafil chloromycetin ointment how to apply tamoxifen yellow eyes viagra i zovirax baby chicken pox how long does it take for the one a day cialis to work nexium patent timeline amlodipine besylate time to work como o viagra foi descoberto azithromycin syrup strength how does ketoconazole tablets work side effects i got from doxycycline what are mobic used for natural substitute for cialis what class drug is buspar prednisone tqeovertoz dosage il prezzo del nuovo viagra tetracycline prostate infection metformina clorhidrato xr how long to get used to seroquel 9 conditions lexapro used treat donde comprar tamoxifeno en chile make viagra using fruits cialis actress tennis prednisone and blood donation sinonimo di allegra alcohol mixed with zoloft where to buy clomid in tiajuana amoxil howdotofound reviews uso dello zoloft norweco singulair model 960 teva atorvastatin tablet shape tetracycline vs minocycline for acne can you get ovarian cancer on 50 mg of clomid prednisone claritin d amoxicillin allergie forum acyclovir price p synthroid kosher passover does diflucan work for all yeast infections antibiotique cipro et soleil douleur testicule finasteride allegra anxiety side effects cymbalta ecchymose pros and cons of cipro viagra generic verses the real deal synthroid side effects bruising viagra and doxycycline hyc what is better cialis or baclofen 100 mg combien de temps effet viagra synthroid protonix interactions accutane and birth defects years later oxytetracycline kela doxycycline 4 weeks after how long can a person take zoloft celebrex 200 medicamento how much fors generic lexapro cost at cvs miconazole fluconazole 150 mg bc medical is there a generic for singulair 10mg avocats sp cialis s saaq does ketoconazole treat ringworm wellbutrin risperidone interaction efectos adversos de la metformina en el embarazo cialis non funziona cause highest dosage baclofen ofloxacin microemulsion wellbutrin sr add how long does an allergic reaction to flagyl last when to start lh testing on clomid adalat sony tv 20 november oseltamivir amoxicillin vigora blue ampola de ciprofloxacino order viagra email ciprodex sus se puede quedar embarazada despues de usar misoprostol cialis does the erection go away after you ejactulate how much does generic valacyclovir cost best way to take metformin for pcos mobiclic aeroport floxin otic solution dosage bella view hotel cipro mode of action for ciprofloxacin for eye clomid online canada no prescription girls think viagra is great ciprofloxacin and hair loss ciproxin doctissimo atenolol almus dosage information for nexium can a man take viagra everyday can you take zicam with amoxicillin flagyl deixa a boca amarga dapa tabs indapamide hemihydrate how long do you take flomax girl who took viagra can i take ciproflaxin with sulfatrim abilify ecg weaning off quetiapine stomach lexapro in renal failure clomid 10 mg levitra bertibarots cost atarax tabs. 10 mg viagra shipped worldwide daily dose cialis plus 5 mg metoprolol anemia most effective generic viagra le viagra pour les jeunes celebrex 200mg nhs excellent safe ayurvedic viagra in mumbai what dose of cephalexin for uti cialis ample shampoo nizoral per dermatite seborroica zestril and diarrhea success rates with clomid ovidrel hcg injection abilify 10 mg for bipolar verschil doxycycline amoxicilline pariet and nexium hydroxyzine paxil azathioprine interaction allopurinol allegra d keep you awake viagra with flomax prednisone liquid for cats weaning off lexapro while pregnant paxil dosage for generalized anxiety can you take metronidazole 0.75 twise in a day thyroxine voor honden is levofloxacin 500mg ok for uti comprare viagra online con pagamento alla consegna vardenafil mercadolibre do clomid make your period late sildenafil ejercicio bactrim iv pediatric dosing how can you tell if kamagra is fake sertraline side effects treatment viagra sale accept mastercard amoxicillin and clavulanic acid in canada nolvadex buy india bupropion xl caffeine generic cialis from hong kong amlodipine tablets stability viagra in riga ventolin nebule dosage vardenafil tabletten can you buy viagra over the counter usa jak i kiedy brac clomid new breakouts while on accutane ciprofloxacino interaccion con anticonceptivos nature thyroid vs synthroid dosage is metformin bad for kidneys acyclovir for recurrent hsv does metformin affect thyroid how long will dizziness last on wellbutrin dangers of misusing an albuterol inhaler ciprofloxacin 500 mg para que sirve methocarbamol f?r pferde dosage bactrim aquarium bactrim ds 3 days uti erythromycin ethylsuccinate contraindications how to tell if a young guy uses viagra cost lipitor 10mg when do you start clomid after provera side effects of keflex 500 mg can you drink if taking cephalexin tetracycline capsules bp bupropion active metabolite para que sirve la ciprofloxacino capsulas compare celebrex and vimovo finasteride fake pakistan what is teva hydrochlorothiazide used for abilify postpartum maintaining erection after coming with viagra keflex antibiotic dosage cipla atorvastatin cytotec antiulceroso site serieux pour achat viagra can you take benadryl while taking gabapentin prednisone 20 mg apo informacion sobre medicamento sildenafil efek samping pakai cytotec how long does 500mg metformin last does prednisone affect metabolism kamagra oral jelly bih what schedule is celebrex can i take gabapentin and ibuprofen is 125mg to much viagra compare crestor lipitor plavix for cats dosage paxil unam meloxicam injection dose viagra 100g uk free lexapro trial drug study of aldactone atorvastatin side effects nz if you take viagra strattera talkative allergic to keflex can i take doxycycline diflucan kills good bacteria escitalopram y somnolencia pfizer dhe viagra ne shqiperi es bueno el uso del viagra use of lasix in acute renal failure tadalafil 10mg bula amoxicillin swollen throat can paxil cause hearing loss ciprodex otic suspension and pregnancy mechanism of action of metronidazole gabapentin is a controlled substance anafranil nombre comercial lexapro interactions methadone cialis penggunaannya penicillin instead of amoxicillin which is better ciakis or levitra how long before quetiapine starts to work clopidogrel bisulfate retail cost hotel nestor ayia napa cipro coming off prednisone advice which chemist sells viagra in melbourne ketoconazole 20 efectos topamax 25 mg kamagra apotheke schweiz zovirax ointment oral does accutane cause whiteheads 10 mg cialis 4 days in a row flagyl dosing po lexapro price india i had eye surgery can i use viagra seroquel alternatives for sleep terbinafine tabletten kopen robaxin and opiate withdrawal can septra ds be crushed angular cheilitis treatment lamisil flagyl per gengivite ivermectina mercado libre accutane final results viagra cost comparison metronidazole 500 pch clomid and pain killers viagra lipitor que tan efectivo es el cytotec clomid side effects of early pregnancy symptoms what is the expiring date of cialis hyperhidrosis treatment propranolol para que es el medicamento celebrex amitriptyline for sleep reviews furosemide 250 mg iv for sale in the uk buy proscar uk online des stents plavix mit dostinex schwanger effect of sudden stope ofclopidogrel efek samping aborsi dengan cytotec ciprofloxacina 500 ariston cymbalta maxalt drug interactions topamax prescription drug aripiprazole and quetiapine interaction albuterol aerosol diabetes can one take celebrex 200 with tb treatment medicamento inderal 10mg does mirtazapine 7.5 help with depression norweco singulair aerator cost can i drink red bull with cialis 30 mg of abilify does prednisone cause incontinence in dogs treating chlamydia with doxycycline hyclate price of one cialis at walgreens osu cialis sublinguale buy levothroid tqeovertoz doxycycline hyclate 100 mg inactive ingredients albuterol dose 2 year old cytotec management nizoral 2 pcos plavix after heart attack salmonella treatment azithromycin metformin heat buspar for bruxism costa allegra for sale daily cialis effectiveness in pyronies can furosemide cause an upset stomach in a cat can you take cephalexin with dayquil zoloft improved sleep long before cialis works elavil ibs constipation metronidazole cumulative neurotoxicity grapefruit erectile dysfunction propranolol and nose bleeding can you take 1500 grams of valtrex to prevent cold sore lipitor blood clotting ofloxacin eye drops is used for cual es el mejor generico de viagra taking too much furosemide does cipro delay your period uk xenical lawsuits doxycycline dog dosage lyme bench study benazepril atorvastatin amlodipine traitement intoxication amitriptyline dostinex medicitalia ovulation pain after taking clomid which parmercy available generic viagra in tamli nadu converting celexa to lexapro viagra images nexium 250 cc donde venden cytotec en cuenca ecuador can clomid make you spot tamoxifen legit cymbalta and nervous system levofloxacin muscle weakness alternative medication zyvox mayo clinic paxil withdrawal cymbalta and alcohol symptoms of diflucan allergy pode tomar viagra com antibiotico abilify und potenz type 2 diabetes metformin azithromycin 200mg 5ml dosage calculation when does lipitor become generic drug how long for finasteride to leave the system taking lexapro only during pms ketoconazole to treat hair loss hva skjer hvis jenter tar viagra neurontin gabapentina 300 mg bactrim dosage for travelers diarrhea can i drink alcohol with amoxicillin trihydrate ketoconazole and loperamide viagra image price in indian rupees how cialis take effect cialis 5 mg tedavi venta de cytotec en monterrey sin receta cialis felleskatalogen cipro cure stds cialis how soon does it take effect terbinafine online buy baclofen bipolar disorder how to have cialis prescribed cytotec onset of action allopurinol pakistan itching with azithromycin petsmart doxycycline how to use levothyroxine sodium xenical generico precio venezuela how much amoxicillin for a cat uti wholesale cost albuterol inhalers australia soy protein and synthroid aciclovir ? melhor pomada ou comprimido are kamagra legal how long to take azithromycin to cure acne vulgaris reasons to discontinue metformin lexapro success adderall zyvox price el salvador first time using celexa erythromycin impurity c viagra focus eye how is prednisone used comprar cialis en usa actors in cialis tv commercials allegra during pregnancy safe ampicillin animals costo de priligy levitra ersatz cialis modo de us over the counter hctz 25 lisinopril 20mg tab order femara bertibarots what dose of gabapentin do you take for ic can levaquin be taken with food new paxil users viagra tablet price in lahore can doxycycline cause nausea and diarrhea amoxil medlineplus revatio pfizer precio can clomid cause ohss prednisone interactions with nsaids ciprofloxacin strep throat treatment seroquel and alcohol mix ciclopirox vs lamisil doxycycline alcohol lyme allegra printing beatty street spironolactone for female alopecia nexium reviews weight gain cialis functionality taking spironolactone before bed topiramate pubmed augmentin 10 film tablet levothyroxine face swelling generic lasix eciwlcodkedefe why doesnt my insurance cover propecia does viagra make you hallucinate indocin er why always erectile lasix and viagra what effect does prednisone have on the eyes can a 15 year old take a cialis clomid and menstrual cycle length zyvox and fentanyl patch mixing zoloft and excedrin celexa fda pregnancy category wellbutrin galactorrhea cialis 5 mg ohne rezept escitalopram qualigen xenical usei levothyroxine and wheezing amoxil tablets 250mg magnesium citrate and lexapro 6 cheap propecia como meter las pastillas cytotec isotretinoin colitis adalat class of drug dosage of nexium how make cialis work can you take amoxicillin with loratadine metformin 4 dollar list triamterene hydrochlorothiazide uses prednisone crp levels oral prednisone for arthritis i want twins can clomid tablet help what compare to viagra will cialis help men last in bed pamelor hair loss berapa harga cytotec di farmasi viagra official website com quetiapine definition does lexapro cause pain ce e kamagra does horizon blue cross pay for viagra prescription hydrochlorothiazide hypokalemia when should i stop taking cymbalta

Putting Mattingly in the Proper Perspective

Columns — By Scott Ham on January 5, 2009 10:52 am

Tim Marchman proposes his “theoretical Hall of Fame ballot” and takes the opportunity to slap Don Mattingly.  The offense:

Don Mattingly—No to probably the most overrated ballplayer of my lifetime. When I was growing up you’d have thought he was every bit Lou Gehrig’s equal based strictly on a four-year run that wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time. Even Bill James rated him the 12th best first baseman ever, above the obviously superior likes of Dick Allen, Will Clark, and Keith Hernandez, justifying this absurd ranking with the even more absurd explanation that he was “100% ballplayer, 0% bullshit.” This may or may not have been so, but he wasn’t all that much better than Derrek Lee.

In the spirit of full disclosure, let me start with this:

  • I have a frame in my man room with all of Don Mattingly’s rookie cards in it, including a minor league card distributed by Arby’s.
  • I have a signed baseball by Mattingly, although I didn’t get it in person.
  • I shed a tear at the retiring of his number at Yankee Stadium, which I attended in person.
  • In short, Mattingly was my childhood idol.

However, I do not believe Mattingly is a Hall of Famer.  I wish he was but he isn’t.

Despite that, Marchman’s criticism here is pretty misguided.  His opening comment alone is self-contradictory:

No to probably the most overrated ballplayer of my lifetime. When I was growing up you’d have thought he was every bit Lou Gehrig’s equal based strictly on a four-year run that wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time.

According to what I’ve seen online, Marchman will be 30 this year.  That means during Mattingly’s breakout season in 1984, Marchman was 5 years old.  At the end of the “four-year run,” Marchman was 8.  I’m sure at that age, he was sitting at the bar of the local diner debating baseball history with the old timers.  Maybe later in life, Marchman soaked in the undying love that Yankee fans had for Mattingly, but he wasn’t listening to anyone who was actually looking at his numbers.

As far as Eddie Murray goes, it’s an interesting point, but Marchman doesn’t mention that Murray was five years older than Mattingly.  Mattingly posted the exact same OPS as Murray in 1984 at the age of 23 while Murray was 28.  Murray’s OPS at 23 was 74 points lower than Mattingly’s.  In 1985, still five years younger, Mattingly had an OPS 33 points higher than Murray.  In 1986, Mattingly was 108 points higher than Murray.  Ditto 1987.

So no, Mr. Marchman.  It is incorrect to say Mattingly “wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time.”

Marchman continues:

Even Bill James rated him the 12th best first baseman ever, above the obviously superior likes of Dick Allen, Will Clark, and Keith Hernandez, justifying this absurd ranking with the even more absurd explanation that he was “100% ballplayer, 0% bullshit.” This may or may not have been so, but he wasn’t all that much better than Derrek Lee.

My Baseball Abstract is buried in a house under construction at the moment so I can’t reference the list James put together.  He did publish that version in 2001 which means at best he was referencing up until the 2000 season in his rankings.

At this stage, Mattingly probably isn’t the 12th greatest first baseman who ever played the game.  A lot of the hype that has surrounded Mattingly stemmed from 1984 – 1989 when he put up good to great numbers.  Even with his down years, he still maintained an OPS+ above 100 for 11 of his 13 fulltime seasons.

At the time, that hype was justified.  If you compare Mattingly’s stats to the history of first basemen up until the age of 28, Mattingly places 11th, behind Frank Thomas, Jeff Bagwell, Eddie Murray and Will Clark, but ahead of Fred McGriff, Keith Hernandez, Mark McGwire and, yes, Derrek Lee.

There was much reason to believe that Mattingly could be one of the greats until a back injury shortened and destroyed his career.  That doesn’t create any excuses.  It only leaves us all to wonder what could have been.

Is Mattingly overrated?  In the hearts of non-objective Yankee fans, absolutely.  His value to them went beyond numbers.  But the hype at the time was justified.  It just didn’t last long enough.

Tags: baseball, Bill James, Derrek Lee, Dick Allen, Don Mattingly, Eddie Murray, first baseman, Frank Thomas, Fred McGriff, I shed, Jeff Bagwell, Keith Hernandez, Lou Gehrig, Major League Baseball, Marchman, Mark McGwire, Mattingly, Murray, New York Yankees players, Will Clark, Yankee Stadium

6 Comments

  1. Vinnie S. says:

    Thanks, Scott. Finally, someone that actually remembers Mattingly.

  2. Mike O says:

    Scott I sent the link and posted a little comment of my own.

  3. You're an idiot says:

    Fuck you.

  4. stang7222 says:

    Just compare Mattingly’s numbers to those of first ballot Hall Of Famer Kirby Puckett, who also had an injury shortened career. its the “Hall Of Fame” and if being the biggest name on the biggest team isn’t fame…….

    • Scott Ham says:

      Personally, I don’t think Puckett should have been elected because his numbers don’t compare to other outfielders in the Hall. Making a mistake with Puckett doesn’t justify making one with Mattingly. It just weakens the hall.

      Regarding fame, I don’t think you can apply the name
      that literally. That’s like saying Mel Hall should be in the Hall of Fame because his last name is Hall.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.