can you break bupropion xl in half kamagra over tye counter prozac chemist levaquin 750 mg lawsuit is there a difference bewteen 5 mg and 20mg cialis cialissubstitute price comparison canadian super store viagra how long does provera pills stay in your system cost of singulair chewable tablets at cvs is it safe to take valium with citalopram where to get promethazine codeine online order zanaflex no prescription leflunomide brand names in india metronidazole supplier india voltaren emulgel priceline doxycycline hyclate 50 mg para que sirve finasteride 5 mg para que es solubility carvedilol in supercritical carbon dioxide meloxicam out of pocket price pain specialists in bullhead city az colchicine in amyloidosis how long will clomid stay in my system what does name brand lexapro 10 mg look like purchase lasix no prescription what is sertraline hcl 50 mg used for where to buy viagra in stores in uk naproxen in bangladesh viagra paypal deutschland melatonin lexapro safe buying viagra stockholm como comprar viagra en malaga ventolin side effects in pregnancy buy propecia hair loss pill is sildenafil illegal in bali over the counter allegra azithromycin 500 mg uso where to get viagra in lagos generic viagr and viagra the same did singulair go generic atenolol 50 mg espanol is clindamycin safe to take while breastfeeding prednisone safe short term cardura in females claritin pregnant is it safe kegunaan obat meloxicam 15 mg real generic viagra what is naproxen in the uk walmart brand ibuprofen gluten free sildenafil cuantos mg cost of celexa without insurance safe way buy cialis online comprar kamagra en espa?a ibuprofen 200 mg 16 gsl permethrin in the philippines can you buy voltaren over the counter in the uk 10 mg abilify cost doxycycline cost in india 40 mg strattera pamelor guercmorteo reviews can buy viagra cvs list of brands of metronidazole 500mg tablet cialis kaufen ohne rezept schweiz carvedilol 6.25 mg twice daily propecia before and after real .25 mg propecia effective safe alternative accutane where in fife can i buy viagra bactrim causa diarreia safety of augmentin in pregnancy diflucan 150 mg bula boehringer ingelheim canada flomax escitalopram 10 mg and alcohol safe take citalopram amitriptyline together how to take viagra price venlafaxine er 150 mg pill cost of acyclovir ointment flagyl price canada acetazolamide 250 mg side effects cialis in der t?rkei kaufen cialis 200 milligrams canadian pharmacies is it safe to take dostinex and viagra together wellbutrin sr 300 mg and weight loss ccw reciprocal agreements states medications safe zoloft viagra feminino como usar what happens if you take too much naproxen 500 mg cyclophosphamide dose in mice what does zyprexa 5 mg look like taking 300 mg of wellbutrin meloxicam 22.5 mg when did propecia go generic zovirax tablet price in the philippines what is the best way to get off prednisone cheapest way to get propecia mifepristone misoprostol brand india best time to take avodart and flomax morning or evening usage of premarin cream india flagyl venlafaxine hcl xr 37.5 mg que costo tiene las pastillas cytotec is zocor safe hydroxyzine pam 50 mg anxiety retail price of 100mg viagra norvasc side effects in women weight gain preço nexium 40 mg ofloxacin baownbeuv australia clomipramine price walmart acetaminophen and codeine brand names flagyl in cats dosage street price on propranolol drug bank of losartan potassium can we buye viagra over the counter generic viagra coupon novartis clozaril uk generic synthroid recall propecia side effects in women protonix safety plavix venta generico viagra british viagra online who are the women in the viagra commercials sildenafil 100 mg package insert dutasteride tqeovertoz cost piroxicam 10 mg tablets acetazolamide 1500 mg next day delivery cialis amoxicillin hereisthebestin dosage allegra realty inc safe take mucinex d benadryl benadryl safe to use during pregnancy methotrexate price malaysia how much is clomid in rands nexium copay discount pastillas levonorgestrel 0.75 mg atarax 10 mg in pregnancy para que sirve naproxen 375 mg priligy 30 mg film kapli tablet why take celexa in morning mirtazapine walmart cost finasteride 5mg vs 1 mg griseofulvin effects in vivo is there a generic for allegra d chance of twins with 100 mg of clomid walgreen zyrtec generic zithromax 40 mg 20 mg tadalafil benign prostatic difference between brand name zoloft generic viagra 50 mg or 100 buy viagra cheap no prescription clotrimazole oral tablet 500 mg azithromycin 3000 mg omeprazole 20 mg cap delayed release 10mg cipralex is equivalent to what in sertraline safe to take with a fatty liverescitalopram 300 mg bupropion xl side effects doxycycline hyclate 100 mg and bactrim ds is 30 mg of fluoxetine a lot prednisolone use in rheumatoid arthritis drug bank rosuvastatin calcium salep oxytetracycline does propranolol show up in a drug test tadalafil users review buy no prior viagra cialis levitra liquid augmentin dosage pastillas xenical 120 mg donepezil patent uk amitriptyline in the treatment of migraine cheaper online price wellbutrin xl pro gabapentin for pain in dogs efectos secundarios tenoretic 50 mg is it safe to take topamax for weight loss actos de ejecucion union europea 3800 mg cialis reviews cialis levitra canada dilantin 100 mg overdose lipitor 20 mg price in mercury drug philippines ranitidine in 3rd trimester ondansetron hydrochloride cost should i take wellbutrin in the morning or evening bilder von der costa allegra 25 mg viagra how many rounds u can make hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg shoulder blade pain pain in legs from viagra safest place to buy propecia online what does metronidazole 200 mg treat dosage vermox liquid exelon patch 4.6 mg is viagra available over the counter in jamaica cialis we accept paypal lowest prices prednisone treatment in influenza detrol la buy kamagra online generic seroquel xr 300mg professional viagra cheap provera 10 mg 10 dagar liquid prednisone dosage for dogs by weight how many mg of azithromycin for a two year old outlets viagra in portugal cefixime norman 400 mg cialis generico en mano cleocin 600 mg im levocetirizine montelukast brand name gabapentin is the generic for canadian 5mg daily tadalafil for bph does clomid make you really tired does propecia have a generic norfloxacin health canada flagyl 500 mg tablets spc depo provera for psychiatric in men levitra sicher kaufen viagra order usa lymphoma cancer in dogs prednisone xenical weight loss pills online buy in india does oxycodone hcl 5 mg. have acetaminophen in it buy prednisone medication buy exelon patch 5 cheaper zyban champix migraine specialists in kansas city cost of estradiol 2 mg coumadin effect in renal failure viagra cheap next day delivery onde comprar priligy dapoxetina dosage of piroxicam in dogs himalayan viagra in india can cefdinir cause mucus in stool viagra in germany need prescription atorvastatin 40 mg high intensity metformin 500 mg tablets look like is it safe to take voltaren while breastfeeding doxycycline anti inflammatory effect in copd lamisil in tj zyrtec vs walmart brand viagra for cheap on line 1000 mg depakote alot over nite delivery in usa on viagra best deal for viagra counter low libido lexapro with ritalin doxycycline 100 mg vials for sale rezeptfrei viagra in deutschland apoteka nis kamagra 800 mg ventolin 90 mg how long does 50mg zoloft stay in your system pantoprazole 40 mg composition best pct if you cant get nolvadex cefuroxime sandoz 250 mg ivermectin dosage for treating mange in dogs buying viagra online problems baclofen 10 mg prospect naproxen 700 mg metformin doses in pregnancy cialis ohne zollprobleme kaufen nizoral pastile in sampon prinivil 20 mg tablet where to buy zovirax eye drop.co.za cost of generic diovan chemistry composition of viagra dosis de cialis generico order ventolin whartisthebestin levothyroxine sodium brand names recreational cialis review plavix when is it going generic generic tadalafil germany over the counter antibiotics doxycycline generic viagra distributor in cabo mexico what is the active ingredient in fluoxetine donde comprar misoprostol en buenos aires domperidone tablets over the counter cost of metformin at walmart how much amoxicillin 400 mg can a five year old take cheap viagra online discover card buying viagra in tenerife is permethrin safe for plants generic name for clotrimazole cream prix du cialis à paris voltaren emulgel 100 ml get clomid online exelon auto sales auburn wa cheap zithromax uk viagra in airport security inactive ingredients in prozac elavil mg where can i buy viagra in the uk over the counter diprolene over the counter levitra peyer par paypal prevacid 30 mg over counter is naproxen safe during pregnancy cost for celexa generic what strength is in levitra plus joseph allegra papers about ageing in csmr 1997 amoxicillin 250 mg side effect where can i buy dostinex steroid form 1mg finasteride cost gold viagra found in mumbai famciclovir price australia acyclovir salep indofarma buy ciprofloxacin 500mg for gonorrhea ponstan und ibuprofen zusammen is viagra best taken after meals what is the generic of terbinafine in philippines how often how often can you take zofran 8 mg where can i buy clomid with paypal what does generic tamoxifen look like how many mg of motrin can i take at once will topamax show up in your urine silogin levonorgestrel 0.75 mg efectos lexapro tingling in arms puedo comprar viagra sin receta medica en chile allegra in cold how to dose liquid tamoxifen citrate strattera hair loss in men diovan comprimidos 80 mg viagra rezeptfrei in holland propecia causa sterilit how much is diflucan fluconazole in naija cialis generico senza carta di credito prednisone withdrawal mg new generic drug lipitor allegra via articles in j mol biol by barbara brannetti the best for less kamagra doxycycline 400 mg iv metronidazole solubility in dichloromethane what is best zafirlukast and singulair for 12 year old proscar co uk nabumetone in india best online pharmacy for cialis reviews how much its a viagra in south africa buy nolvadex xt online cialis online indonesia atenolol hereisthebestin uses viagra safe alcohol amoxicillin capsules 0.5 mg generic isotretinoin 20mg azithromycin dosage in pediatric cipro 500mg generic generic cialis howdotofound can bupropion hcl be cut in half order metronidazole whartisthebestin ejaculation disorder celexa is nizoral shampoo available in pakistan over counter pill works like viagra tetracycline hcl drug bank can cialis 20 mg be used daily cialis 100 mg pay with paypal diflucan for yeast in throat motrin generic name classification best moisturizers use accutane can i cut my lisinopril pill in half baclofen in deutschland nolvadex eciwlcodkedefe online counterfeit viagra and hematuria cost of tolterodine tartrate buy amoxicillin paediatric uk how much codeine is in phenergan with codeine syrup clomiphene postmenopausal ramipril 10 mg cap zyd propranolol in ccf best place to buy thyroxine in uk cialis super p force review is amoxicillin liquid gluten free cialis over counter hong kong benadryl dosing in puppies levitra prices in kamloops pharmacies digoxin in chronic liver disease lisinopril coupons for walmart prednisone dosage in toddlers what is the best viagra or cialis viagra 100 mg best price without prescription buy sublingual levitra online 3 cheap generic substitute viagra venlafaxine 150 mg ervaringen is 80 mg overdose nexium glucophage australia reality permethrin amoxil tqeovertoz discount metronidazole for urinary tract infections in dogs ramipril tabletas 5 mg metronidazole 30 mg what is the price of meloxicam prices of albuterol inhaler chloramphenicol concentration in lb main ingredient in flagyl metronidazole 400mg review buying propecia in india is valtrex safe for dogs when is the best time to take flomax where to buy ciprofloxacin in shop houston buy albuterol tab buy propecia pills india american gold viagra 380 mg minocycline cheap how much is lexapro generic brand in manila ph. tomar cialis 20 mg montelukast discount coupon metronidazole dosage canada zoloft prescription mg safe snort oxycodone acetaminophen plavix new update in pakistan prednisone used for fluid in ear cialis as needed vs daily delivery system ibuprofen 600 reviews allopurinol solubility in methanol where to buy in the usa sildenafil for dogs cialis generic v brand prednisone available uk ofloxacin in jaundice bitter taste azithromycin 200 mg oral suspension ondansetron oral 4 mg q code medicamento propranolol de 10 mg price generic wellbutrin xl acyclovir tablet 400 mg stopping depo provera uk 1 mg finasteride every other day flagyl buy 400mg prostatitis doxycycline 100 mg daily for 2 months how much does cialis cost costco canada average cost of zithromax elixir how many mg of viagra. augmentin medsafe asacol hd prices controlled trial of propranolol in thyrotoxicosis bula da amoxilina de 500 mg how long is it safe to stay on prednisone 3000 mg motrin abilify for depression user reviews generic for ciprodex ear drops erfaring viagra online levitra causa dipendenza prilosec generic otc propecia available in australia ciprofloxacino 500 mg oral positive reviews of celexa usaa is a reciprocal interinsurance exchange best female viagra in india eli lilly canada cialis dilatrend carvedilol 50 mg viagra prescription in singapore viagra united states patent expiration can i buy viagra my age 68 use flagyl tablet in diarrhea shops sell viagra in birmingham pastillas cytotec costa rica cefpodoxime clavulanic acid brands nateglinide 60 mg tablet side effects cozaar 100 mg fiyat nizoral stockists ireland side effects of revatio generic buy lasix online dog venlafaxine sleep disorder i was prescribed seroquel 50 mg clomiphene citrate liquid azathioprine in breast milk candesartan 16 mg hexal preis cat costa montelukast de 5 mg when will cialis go down in price can i buy amoxicillin over the counter in hawaii best viagra name in india fosamax and blood in urine medicament losartan 50 mg ivermectin in alpacas candesartan al 8 mg buy misoprostol cytotec online in philippines ibuprofen 200 mg cvs neurontin 100 mg efectos secundarios cipro 500 mg prospekt?s bilgileri seroquel 100mg cheap nolvadex uk forum ivermectin for horses liquid seroquel cvs price female viagra trials australia order bactrim online no prescription with paypal diflucan medicine generic acyclovir tablet 400 mg dosage clomiphene citrate 50 mg in men where to buy tetracycline for acne generic propecia does work cyproheptadine use in infants cialis generico araujo singulair 5 mg kautabletten quetiapine price philippines mercury drug generic lexapro escitalopram pricing viagra in canada propecia online vendita viagra risks in young men clomid clomiphene citrate 50 mg tablets in nigeria amoxil 750 mg dosage directions is walmart going to have the patent on plavix lipitor prescription cost 10 mg oxycodone 325 mg acetaminophen ciprofloxacino 500 mg infeccion muela order cialis jelly amitriptyline 50 mg wikipedia viagra rx sale 100 mg minocycline alcohol safety of transdermal estradiol transgender was ist cataflam 50 mg como usar misoprostol mifepristone voltaren crema si può usare in gravidanza how many acyclovir 800 mg pills for shingles normally zyprexa class action lawsuit in canada buy metronidazole oral femara bertibarots reviews

Putting Mattingly in the Proper Perspective

Columns — By Scott Ham on January 5, 2009 10:52 am

Tim Marchman proposes his “theoretical Hall of Fame ballot” and takes the opportunity to slap Don Mattingly.  The offense:

Don Mattingly—No to probably the most overrated ballplayer of my lifetime. When I was growing up you’d have thought he was every bit Lou Gehrig’s equal based strictly on a four-year run that wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time. Even Bill James rated him the 12th best first baseman ever, above the obviously superior likes of Dick Allen, Will Clark, and Keith Hernandez, justifying this absurd ranking with the even more absurd explanation that he was “100% ballplayer, 0% bullshit.” This may or may not have been so, but he wasn’t all that much better than Derrek Lee.

In the spirit of full disclosure, let me start with this:

  • I have a frame in my man room with all of Don Mattingly’s rookie cards in it, including a minor league card distributed by Arby’s.
  • I have a signed baseball by Mattingly, although I didn’t get it in person.
  • I shed a tear at the retiring of his number at Yankee Stadium, which I attended in person.
  • In short, Mattingly was my childhood idol.

However, I do not believe Mattingly is a Hall of Famer.  I wish he was but he isn’t.

Despite that, Marchman’s criticism here is pretty misguided.  His opening comment alone is self-contradictory:

No to probably the most overrated ballplayer of my lifetime. When I was growing up you’d have thought he was every bit Lou Gehrig’s equal based strictly on a four-year run that wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time.

According to what I’ve seen online, Marchman will be 30 this year.  That means during Mattingly’s breakout season in 1984, Marchman was 5 years old.  At the end of the “four-year run,” Marchman was 8.  I’m sure at that age, he was sitting at the bar of the local diner debating baseball history with the old timers.  Maybe later in life, Marchman soaked in the undying love that Yankee fans had for Mattingly, but he wasn’t listening to anyone who was actually looking at his numbers.

As far as Eddie Murray goes, it’s an interesting point, but Marchman doesn’t mention that Murray was five years older than Mattingly.  Mattingly posted the exact same OPS as Murray in 1984 at the age of 23 while Murray was 28.  Murray’s OPS at 23 was 74 points lower than Mattingly’s.  In 1985, still five years younger, Mattingly had an OPS 33 points higher than Murray.  In 1986, Mattingly was 108 points higher than Murray.  Ditto 1987.

So no, Mr. Marchman.  It is incorrect to say Mattingly “wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time.”

Marchman continues:

Even Bill James rated him the 12th best first baseman ever, above the obviously superior likes of Dick Allen, Will Clark, and Keith Hernandez, justifying this absurd ranking with the even more absurd explanation that he was “100% ballplayer, 0% bullshit.” This may or may not have been so, but he wasn’t all that much better than Derrek Lee.

My Baseball Abstract is buried in a house under construction at the moment so I can’t reference the list James put together.  He did publish that version in 2001 which means at best he was referencing up until the 2000 season in his rankings.

At this stage, Mattingly probably isn’t the 12th greatest first baseman who ever played the game.  A lot of the hype that has surrounded Mattingly stemmed from 1984 – 1989 when he put up good to great numbers.  Even with his down years, he still maintained an OPS+ above 100 for 11 of his 13 fulltime seasons.

At the time, that hype was justified.  If you compare Mattingly’s stats to the history of first basemen up until the age of 28, Mattingly places 11th, behind Frank Thomas, Jeff Bagwell, Eddie Murray and Will Clark, but ahead of Fred McGriff, Keith Hernandez, Mark McGwire and, yes, Derrek Lee.

There was much reason to believe that Mattingly could be one of the greats until a back injury shortened and destroyed his career.  That doesn’t create any excuses.  It only leaves us all to wonder what could have been.

Is Mattingly overrated?  In the hearts of non-objective Yankee fans, absolutely.  His value to them went beyond numbers.  But the hype at the time was justified.  It just didn’t last long enough.

Tags: baseball, Bill James, Derrek Lee, Dick Allen, Don Mattingly, Eddie Murray, first baseman, Frank Thomas, Fred McGriff, I shed, Jeff Bagwell, Keith Hernandez, Lou Gehrig, Major League Baseball, Marchman, Mark McGwire, Mattingly, Murray, New York Yankees players, Will Clark, Yankee Stadium

6 Comments

  1. Vinnie S. says:

    Thanks, Scott. Finally, someone that actually remembers Mattingly.

  2. Mike O says:

    Scott I sent the link and posted a little comment of my own.

  3. You're an idiot says:

    Fuck you.

  4. stang7222 says:

    Just compare Mattingly’s numbers to those of first ballot Hall Of Famer Kirby Puckett, who also had an injury shortened career. its the “Hall Of Fame” and if being the biggest name on the biggest team isn’t fame…….

    • Scott Ham says:

      Personally, I don’t think Puckett should have been elected because his numbers don’t compare to other outfielders in the Hall. Making a mistake with Puckett doesn’t justify making one with Mattingly. It just weakens the hall.

      Regarding fame, I don’t think you can apply the name
      that literally. That’s like saying Mel Hall should be in the Hall of Fame because his last name is Hall.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.