what is the active ingredient in cialis super active zithromax 1000 mg pills for sale no prescription does boots chemist sell fluconazole capsuls uk orlistat buy philippines maxalt rapitab 10 mg pris does lexapro come in 20mg amlodipine atenolol combination brands levitra works really well levitra over the counter in aberdeen what is the cost of liquid zithromax can i buy viagra from mexico voltaren gel price in india cephalexin safe humans is it safe to take 20mg lexapro at 30you weeks pregnant montelukast prices at walmart does metformin make you really tired is it safe to use lamisil on face buy levitra 10 tablets 20mg 32.00 aciclovir 800 mgr hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg and gout nifedipine sr 60 mg where is cialis available in india blood sugar 375 prednisone 50 mg can i buy viagra over the counter at tescos compazine 10 mg tabs viagra spain over counter viagra discount reviews digoxin prices 250mg how many ml of cialis can you take generic equivalent to 50 mcg synthroid dbn gumtree viagra for sale generic name maxolon accessrx viagra review how long will a man taking viagra last in bed is there a generic form for aciphex many mg orlistat alli where can i buy azithromycin in ireland 20 mg of prozac during pregnancy prednisone burst 5 days how many mg each day janta ki adalat costume degisns sertraline for ocd reviews uk ciproxina nombre comercial y generico review benzac ac dulcolax causa dependencia meloxicam material safety data sheet how much price cialis in india kamagra 100 review foods safe eat while coumadin provera biverkningar 10 mg linezolid tablets brands in india atenololo 50 mg costo lamotrigine 75 mg keflex 500 mg treats what is the generic version of propecia quetiapine 25 mg at night adalat nasibov articles virtual reality lens pixel losartan retiene liquidos cialis 5 mg euroclinix nizoral dosage in dogs how much propecia should i take for best results is it safe to take tetracycline while breastfeeding is singulair safe for dogs cost azathioprine dogs relafen oral tablet 750 mg information thuoc dexamethasone 0 5 mg buying viagra on craiglist zyban 150 mg nedir montelukast oral granules 5 mg crushed viagra in wine risperidone liquid canada wo kann ich sicher viagra kaufen where do you buy viagra fro women buy benadryl original buy azithromycin no prescription online alopecia difusa y finasteride canadian viagra trial pack cheapest viagra brand patient reviews on clonidine tadalafil 5 mg effetti collaterali is 50 mg of phenergan ok nifedipine er 24hr 30 mg tab teva internet cialis reviews obat danazol 200 mg indian female viagra names is there a safe viagra calcium amount in lipitor will tizanidine 2 mg get you high cialis online price comparison 800 mg ibuprofen sleepiness legal viagra kaufen ohne rezept cvs zoloft prices gabapentin 300 mg contraindicaciones purple viagra generic best natural alternative to omeprazole is it safe to take cetirizine when breastfeeding viagra in multiple orgasms buy cialis from cana cyclophosphamide in sle nephritis coreg 25 mgs cialis 5 mg uso prolungato should you take glucophage in the morning or at night what does azithromycin treat 250 mg treat why does singulair generic cost so much metformin alternatives uk where to buy kamagra in panaji fabian socialism in america what is dapsone 100 mg used for metoclopramide safe in breastfeeding warfarin genetic testing cost i take 30 mg cialis substitute of viagra in homoepathy cost of lisinopril 10 mg without insurence fluconazole in candidiasis cialis günstig kaufen valsartan brand names in india naproxen buy australia orlistat 60 mg ali ranitidine use in pregnancy indapamide solubility in water ranitidine in rabbits fexofenadine 180 mg hcl can cialis be detected in sperm count viagra price of mg doxycycline 200 mg per day acne image of benazepril 5 mg for pets brand viagra from american pharmecy generic detrol prices amoxicillin in liver disease i need nolvadex in the uk nortriptyline manufacturers india where can you buy viagra in london over the counter is ibuprofen 800 mg good for back pain australia viagra how much trinny and susannah viagra for lips conjugated linoleic acid in milk discount acyclovir atorvastatin generika nebenwirkungen buy generic lisinopril without prescription in canada viagra in bay area is it safe to use out of date ventolin inhaler can i buy clomid at walgreens generic lipitor equivalent acetazolamide in iih when to stop taking prometrium in pregnancy perrigo tretinoin gel reviews prozac safe dosage atorvastatin recall walmart pharmacy bupropion 150 mg coupon withdrawal symptoms of amitriptyline 100 mg ondansetron odt 4 mg for pregnant women aciclovir 400 mg prospecto ciproxin 250 mg dose finasteride causa acne reviews on viagra professional is zanaflex generic is amoxicillin in zithromax is metformin pregnancy safe cardura compresse costo is it legal to purchase viagra from canada clindamycin in canines ibuprofen in rheumatic fever dosage for 600 mg ibuprofen generic med for viagra infant motrin in canada price of viagra medicine in pakistan need to buy albuterol pump propranolol dosage in tachycardia inderal cost walmart is clonidine available in india tadalafil 10mg indian image of model in viagra commercial binimar apt menorca calan forcat reviews cost of methotrexate injection where to buy kamagra usa accidental double dose 20 mg lisinopril forum too much coumadin in system mometasone furoato monoidrato generico prezzo can you take 2 omeprazole 20 mg tritace prevent 10 mg neurontin 600 mg tab what is the name of the generic lexapro macrobid in system amitriptyline hydrochloride india sertraline 50 mg tablets weight gain elavil dergboadre price apteka internetowa orlistat 60 mg capsules price lisinopril oral doxycycline used in pneumonia adalat 10 mg flagyl 500 mg ovulo prednisone side effects pain in arms clopidogrel gsk 75 mg generic prescription hyzaar ingredients in metformin tablets tricor vs. generic atenolol 25 mg oral tablet is it safe to take aleve and benicarhct propecia not effective in men over do u know what the main ingredient is in viagra suppliers of viagra in uae clomid online delivery with happy results doxycycline hyclate 20mg for acne reviews when was generic diovan released vermox 100 mg suspension mebendazole can order viagra chemist street price prozac lansoprazole dr 30 mg capsule side effects maximum dose of cialis in 24 hours v herbal viagra alternative in canada thuoc glucophage 50 mg ofloxacin manufacturers india diflucan 150 mg and pregnancy viagra and valium safe zyprexa available as a generic misoprostol generica blue cross cover cialis canada keflex dosing in kids how to safely come off of paxil ciprofloxacin 500 mg for diverticulitis medroxyprogesterone acetate injection price viagra is generic the same valtrex 500mg cost panadol medsafe seroquel dosing bipolar disorder exelon sales novartis take prometrium in the morning sertraline 150 mg for gad plavix usa propranolol in english flomax 350 mg cosa serve viagra online peru risperidone price cvs aciclovir comprimidos 400 mg bula colchicine medsafe datasheet should you take zoloft in the am or pm canadian 4o mg cialis buying levitra in malaysia ciprobac ciprofloxacino 500 mg irbesartan cost uk augmentin 400 mg suspension seroquel dosage for major depressive disorder cheapest metformin india arrow generics nexium not the same nateglinide reviews side effects cost of 10mg tablets tadalafil boots is dulcolax safe for cats treatment for ibuprofen toxicity in dogs over the counter prevacid for toddlers tadacip 20 price india buy aricept in canada zyprexa uk patent expiration where to purchase amoxicillin in edmonton ab can u cut cialis half 5 mg the lady in the new viagra commercial review article on orlistat tablets.pdf voltaren 75 mg inyectable para que sirve how to take zithromax 250 mg for chlamydia clotrimazole over the counter uk zofran in pediatric dose lexapro side effects in men weight gain buy cipro xr online is erythromycin in the same family as amoxicillin how much ibuprofen is safe to take at a time should take 10 20 mg lexapro zyvox 600 mg iv cpt code ventolin diskus price viagra do you need prescription canada metoclopramide safe for pregnancy estradiol e2 levels in pregnancy 10 mg olanzapine conversion to relprev inj depo provera company name and price side effects of diltiazem er 120 mg salix furosemide 50 mg images allegra x desalex safest online clomid is viagra safe for heart nebenwirkungen clopidogrel zentiva 75 mg average cost of tetracycline maxalt in combinatie met ritalin levaquin side effects in the elderly prednisone 5 mg prices use of coumadin in the elderly elavil howdotofound australia metronidazole giardia in dogs metoprolol 47 5 mg ausschleichen what age people can take viagra in india metronidazole order prednisone long term side effects in cats ic levofloxacin 500 mg tablets side effects flagyl price in south africa does lortab have aspirin in it aricept consumer reviews dulcolax bisacodil 5 mg bula apteka internetowa orlistat 60 mg capsules omeprazole 40 mg inj can we put viagra in drink s monograph in usp and bp of sildenafil citrate propranolol clorhidrato genfar 80 mg panadol c in der schwangerschaft buy minoxidil and propecia off sure purchase flagyl benzoyl metronidazole 60 ml obat untuk apa how much is generic azithromycin viagra can you buy melbourne awp price zyvox paxil 20 mg bula viagra or cialis..which is safer ventolin inhaler generic brand naproxen 400 mg side effects is 20 mg of abilify too much is cataflam safe in pregnancy fosinopril 20 mg side effects generic trade name nitroglycerin obagi tretinoin cream 0.1 best price furosemide use in horses thyroid eye disease prednisone mg daily metformin acne reviews how many mg of paxil should i take lamictal in thailand celebrex tablet india side effects betwen 1000mg asprin and 40 mg nexium seroquel paranoid personality disorder breaking cialis pills in half elavil dosage for depression and anxiety review users lipitor generic article flagyl 500 price keterangan obat generic viagra sublingual how much can you sale buspirone on the street sertraline 50 mg do i take half nexium strange taste in mouth augmentin 625 injection price in india weaning off 100 mg zoloft misoprostol dosage in india celebrex 200mg drug company cost appartamenti in affitto a cipro para que es trazodone 150 mg 100 mg wellbutrin naproxen overdose mg generic prevacid shortage what are the effects of prednisone in women how to take amoxicillin 1000 mg cialis 5mg daily pills in generic much does revia cost clomid price pakistan prozac rezeptfrei in den usa how long does it take ranitidine to work in adults how much are viagra 100 mg levofloxacin 500 mg zc56 real cialis no prescription aciclovir rowcmoadreders for sale comprar cytotec en cochabamba albendazole canada viagra pricews at target dosis cialis 40 mg comprar viagra legalmente finasteride acostumbramiento does voltaren 75 mg help with opiate withdrawals tablete lisinopril 10mg i aspirin 81 mg anastrozole 1 mg film coated tablets can you bring viagra domestic flight uk bactrim prophylaxis in transplant patients viagra na wc v uk is taking finasteride safe prozac 20 mg ek?i sözlük viagra generika von ratiopharm reciprocating engines in houston texas medical viagra generic 100mg naproxen 500 mg with allopurinol brands of telmisartan and metoprolol bactrim dosage canada finasteride in australia medicare doxycycline 400 mg per dag medroxyprogesterone 150 mg vial citalopram 10 mg information vibramycin bertibarots australia como usar cyrux misoprostol para abortar soft cialis from india paroxetine 10 mg tablets side effects kamagra 100 mg en sobres sobredosis prozac 20 mg what does protonix have in it finasteride generic target cialis preise usa estradiol brands india best price on estrace cream what does 1 mg propecia look like viagra rates in bangalore linezolid 600 mg and cystic fibrosis ivermectin for lice in humans allergic reaction amoxicillin 500 mg doxycycline online shop germany carvedilol 25mg viagra 100mg is it safe together kamagra order uk erythromycin liquid storage levitra 20 mg kaç para walmart pharmacy lisinopril cardura xl 8 mg faydalar? answers and questions where to buy cialis generic zocor prices requip in renal failure doxycycline dosage in p i d hercules poirot tragedia en tres actos online prednisone 20 mg vs cortisone shot can i take kamagra to usa cialis 25 mg precio prednisone dose in croup can zoloft cause tightness in chest cialis cot in nz problems with duloxetine generic cheap clomiphene citrate 50 mg how long does 25mg of amitriptyline stay in your system tinidazole baownbeuv australia que contiene la ciprofloxacina 500 mg amlodipine eciwlcodkedefe australia effexor xr social anxiety reviews reducing prednisone dosage in cats purchase diovan over the counter plus cialis nebivolol brands recent website to purchase lasix, mastercard metoprolol in arrhythmia cialis vom hausarzt verschreiben lassen where to buy viagra at cvs levitra 10 mg schmelztabletten vardenafil can you get clomid in uk reciprocity in religion cheap cialis online nz cost of 50 mg plavix amiodarone toxicity in eyes buy betamethasone cream 0.1 order lexapro no rx irbesartan hydrochlorothiazide 150 12.5 mg costo del bactrim f reciprocity for cna in michigan dexamethasone in regional anaesthesia hyzaar generic ingredients guaranteed delivery viagra canada dose of cyclophosphamide in vasculitis celebrex lump in throat safety clindamycin pregnancy metoprolol tablet 100 mg order kamagra online deliver to spain motilium 10 mg side effects tetracycline solubility in acetone diovan hct generic coupon propranolol 120 mg coupons glucophage xr 500 mg ovarios poliquisticos paroxetine sandoz 30 mg topamax reviews for binge eating hctz 12.5 mg lisinopril side effects of 60 mg of celexa buy ciprofloxacin 1g online reviews mobicity nz posso prendere augmentin in gravidanza gabapentin to buy is it safe to take tramadol with promethazine effect of dexamethasone in blood pressure viagra guercmorteo reviews best time to take periactin viagra available in bangalore erythromycin metabolism in liver comprar preservativos con viagra masteron and nolvadex for gyno methocarbamol dergboadre australia walmart levitra cost 10 mg accutane generic brand buy cetirizine hydrochloride oral solution can i buy viagra from boots the chemist valtrex and other prescriptions lexapro cost india canadian pharmacy viagra women orlistat 60mg price india avodart prices usa mucinex safe with zoloft safe take viagra blood pressure medication order tenormin whartisthebestin long term usage of cialis best research peptide tamoxifen for sale priligy howdotofound for sale safe to take viagra with mitro valve prolapse is ordering propecia legal cat costa ciprofloxacin solutie oftalmica metronidazole side effects medsafe is levitra the real thing on line indicazioni ciproxin 500 mg propecia in ireland in pharmacy canada drugs albuterol albuterol for nebulizer cost effexor xr generic coupons funcionan los genericos de cialis pastillas cytotec usar divalproex sodium 500 mg side effects ciallis or viagra. which is safest for elderly when is the best time to insert cytotec can neurontin counteract prozac mometasone furoate spray price amoxicillin tablets 50 mg buy online thyroid disorders weaning off synthroid novo sildenafil review tengo miedo usar cytotec over the counter dapsone xenical donde comprar en peru

Putting Mattingly in the Proper Perspective

Columns — By Scott Ham on January 5, 2009 10:52 am

Tim Marchman proposes his “theoretical Hall of Fame ballot” and takes the opportunity to slap Don Mattingly.  The offense:

Don Mattingly—No to probably the most overrated ballplayer of my lifetime. When I was growing up you’d have thought he was every bit Lou Gehrig’s equal based strictly on a four-year run that wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time. Even Bill James rated him the 12th best first baseman ever, above the obviously superior likes of Dick Allen, Will Clark, and Keith Hernandez, justifying this absurd ranking with the even more absurd explanation that he was “100% ballplayer, 0% bullshit.” This may or may not have been so, but he wasn’t all that much better than Derrek Lee.

In the spirit of full disclosure, let me start with this:

  • I have a frame in my man room with all of Don Mattingly’s rookie cards in it, including a minor league card distributed by Arby’s.
  • I have a signed baseball by Mattingly, although I didn’t get it in person.
  • I shed a tear at the retiring of his number at Yankee Stadium, which I attended in person.
  • In short, Mattingly was my childhood idol.

However, I do not believe Mattingly is a Hall of Famer.  I wish he was but he isn’t.

Despite that, Marchman’s criticism here is pretty misguided.  His opening comment alone is self-contradictory:

No to probably the most overrated ballplayer of my lifetime. When I was growing up you’d have thought he was every bit Lou Gehrig’s equal based strictly on a four-year run that wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time.

According to what I’ve seen online, Marchman will be 30 this year.  That means during Mattingly’s breakout season in 1984, Marchman was 5 years old.  At the end of the “four-year run,” Marchman was 8.  I’m sure at that age, he was sitting at the bar of the local diner debating baseball history with the old timers.  Maybe later in life, Marchman soaked in the undying love that Yankee fans had for Mattingly, but he wasn’t listening to anyone who was actually looking at his numbers.

As far as Eddie Murray goes, it’s an interesting point, but Marchman doesn’t mention that Murray was five years older than Mattingly.  Mattingly posted the exact same OPS as Murray in 1984 at the age of 23 while Murray was 28.  Murray’s OPS at 23 was 74 points lower than Mattingly’s.  In 1985, still five years younger, Mattingly had an OPS 33 points higher than Murray.  In 1986, Mattingly was 108 points higher than Murray.  Ditto 1987.

So no, Mr. Marchman.  It is incorrect to say Mattingly “wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time.”

Marchman continues:

Even Bill James rated him the 12th best first baseman ever, above the obviously superior likes of Dick Allen, Will Clark, and Keith Hernandez, justifying this absurd ranking with the even more absurd explanation that he was “100% ballplayer, 0% bullshit.” This may or may not have been so, but he wasn’t all that much better than Derrek Lee.

My Baseball Abstract is buried in a house under construction at the moment so I can’t reference the list James put together.  He did publish that version in 2001 which means at best he was referencing up until the 2000 season in his rankings.

At this stage, Mattingly probably isn’t the 12th greatest first baseman who ever played the game.  A lot of the hype that has surrounded Mattingly stemmed from 1984 – 1989 when he put up good to great numbers.  Even with his down years, he still maintained an OPS+ above 100 for 11 of his 13 fulltime seasons.

At the time, that hype was justified.  If you compare Mattingly’s stats to the history of first basemen up until the age of 28, Mattingly places 11th, behind Frank Thomas, Jeff Bagwell, Eddie Murray and Will Clark, but ahead of Fred McGriff, Keith Hernandez, Mark McGwire and, yes, Derrek Lee.

There was much reason to believe that Mattingly could be one of the greats until a back injury shortened and destroyed his career.  That doesn’t create any excuses.  It only leaves us all to wonder what could have been.

Is Mattingly overrated?  In the hearts of non-objective Yankee fans, absolutely.  His value to them went beyond numbers.  But the hype at the time was justified.  It just didn’t last long enough.

Tags: baseball, Bill James, Derrek Lee, Dick Allen, Don Mattingly, Eddie Murray, first baseman, Frank Thomas, Fred McGriff, I shed, Jeff Bagwell, Keith Hernandez, Lou Gehrig, Major League Baseball, Marchman, Mark McGwire, Mattingly, Murray, New York Yankees players, Will Clark, Yankee Stadium


  1. Vinnie S. says:

    Thanks, Scott. Finally, someone that actually remembers Mattingly.

  2. Mike O says:

    Scott I sent the link and posted a little comment of my own.

  3. You're an idiot says:

    Fuck you.

  4. stang7222 says:

    Just compare Mattingly’s numbers to those of first ballot Hall Of Famer Kirby Puckett, who also had an injury shortened career. its the “Hall Of Fame” and if being the biggest name on the biggest team isn’t fame…….

    • Scott Ham says:

      Personally, I don’t think Puckett should have been elected because his numbers don’t compare to other outfielders in the Hall. Making a mistake with Puckett doesn’t justify making one with Mattingly. It just weakens the hall.

      Regarding fame, I don’t think you can apply the name
      that literally. That’s like saying Mel Hall should be in the Hall of Fame because his last name is Hall.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.