scalp med vs rogaine adderall xr side effects in adults lasix during pregnancy white spots on skin fungus red under fingernails apple cider vinegar and metformin pro-diem will azo cure uti lithium kidney stones what is mccune albright syndrome shingles on the stomach blood blister from running how to prevent chickenpox from spreading what is an inr thyroid what does it do dark brown discharge iud best ointment for second degree burns anal eaze review weight loss headache does lithium cause acne genital warts natural cure benefits of drinking chamomile tea 4.25*5 diphenhydramine hcl sleep aid gout medication otc diabetic exchange list chart nortriptyline for migraines side effects migraine medication while breastfeeding benzodiazepine withdrawal treatment medication how to get rid of carbuncle infinitealoe skin care cures for leg cramps how to use passion flower how much is too much biotin levo-alpha-acetylmethadol salicylic acid structural formula does aleve have aspirin lack of sleep erectile dysfunction allergy nose spray otc sulfacetamide eye drops what is a pulmonary embolism coq10 adverse effects can you od on steroids throat bleeding from coughing stress headache nausea how to make hand numb tb vaccine how often standard process whole body support totally tan too danbury ct without vitamin k ringworm back of head back bones pain i took it medicine for insomnia dark urine in morning speed stick sport talc discontinued brown discharge one day before period long term use of trazodone what is gonorreah home remedy for itchy anus boots no 7 moisturizer constipation in elderly dementia how long to beat soma bumps on anus cough medicines while pregnant remove impacted cerumen important people in medical history tourette syndrome in kids medical abbreviation qhs obesity not 4 me side effects to birth control implant can you test urine for alcohol claritin 24 hour ingredients why is my back always itchy erosive esophagitis healing time viral strep throat ectopia lentis in marfan syndrome my vagina is too wet is retinal detachment painful l-tartrate what is a broken bone gammagard infusion rate fentanyl patch 100 mcg street price short of breath early pregnancy sign pharmaceutical industry in usa gargle with salt water sore throat signs of aortic aneurysm methadone withdrawal help day 5 of quitting smoking adderall dosage for adults burning nasal passages picato gel side effects lymph nodes pelvic area swollen lymph nodes medical term products with propylene glycol causes of right lower abdominal pain body genix side effects healing deep wounds over the counter treatment for uti pill with m365 how many tablespoons is 30 ml allegra for dogs non prescription flu medicine bladder infection symptoms in kids how do you stop menstrual bleeding coupon for zantac cramps after pooping bicarbonate and potassium relationship probable left ventricular hypertrophy antifungal cream for yeast infections itching in urethra crack ribs from coughing what does epo do banalg hospital strength what is medrol used for moon face steroids photos taking vitamin e orally trastorno de personalidad narcisista cholesterol normal level what causes high glucose levels causes of dry socket strep throat symptoms rash herpes brain symptoms what is in a burn blister lowest dose of effexor polydipsia medical definition sharp facial pain versed medical definition novalog vs humalog can dogs use visine definition of capitate weed resin facts drop foot symptoms t sal shampoo patch for sea sickness toddlers and benadryl zolpidem tartrate drug test ease tooth pain intestinal infection causes enfamil tri vi sol side effects side effects of effient what could coughing up blood mean cold blooded synonym avon black mineral mask what is a ramus definitions com dictionary my eye is swollen and hurts potassium chloride liquid ringing in ears infection how many nyquil pills to die end stage copd emphysema symptoms burning urethra after urination what is the dosage for ibuprofen child head bump [p difference between zyrtec and zyrtec d walking pneumonia symptoms in adults treatment ventral spinothalamic tract iud longer periods signs of staph hair started falling out lower abdomen sharp pain ping pong mechanism list of party drugs blood in the eye from trauma what antibiotics cure gonorrhea why does your back go out bed to wheelchair transfer nausea and low grade fever codeine side effects how much tylenol 3 to overdose que es hidronefrosis left hemisphere stroke acyclovir no prescription sinus pressure symptoms in head hormonal skin discoloration what does low b12 mean tumor necrosis factor inhibitor knock out drug anesthesia medical term what is azurette i had sex with my doctor baby born with bump on head bupropion vs zoloft diabetic ulcers on legs treatment citrucel vs fibercon the cause of prostate cancer cyst on breast pictures prognosis for aids milk of magnesia vs dulcolax can you drink while on prednisone can you die from acute bronchitis define cultured milk consistent bloody nose adderal is meth benefits of taking omega 3 all day pain relief causes of dvt prednisone metallic taste in mouth ms contin 60mg left hand tremor low blood pressure nursing diagnosis ocean potion ingredients yellow pill 36 01 hemorrhoids and mucus discharge best proven weight loss pill what are hives fractura de rodilla generic for opana early signs of hernia red bumps on fingertips muscles around heart big toe problems pictures information on lexapro right neural foraminal stenosis metoclopramide for lactation tylenol and ibuprofen dosage chart best medication for fibromyalgia fatigue no period mirena iud will smoking weed once hurt you can u overdose on suboxone vyvanse sexual side effects pink pill m 30 post menopausal night sweats recovering from seizure mast cell inhibitors b complex plus vitamin c adderall and irritability cranial fluid leak symptoms malaria method of transmission vicodin and oxycodone severe edema causes zymaxid eye drops normal saline flush itchy skin rash on face effects of erectile dysfunction can alcohol withdrawal cause chest pain high tsh thyroid bruising on calves effects of metoprolol cells that build bone are how long is 7 weeks is he on drugs life expectancy with rheumatoid arthritis post nasal drip allergy crossing one eye chest pain bradycardia why does alcohol make you snore yellow eyes medical term sintomas de derrames cerebrales alprazolam 1 mg high uses for hemorrhoid cream soft & dri what is sneezing a symptom of colitis disease symptoms how does pku impact dietary recommendations are bath salts addictive herpes cream for lips 0 with slash salvia divinorum drug aubra birth control colchicine generic name mucus in throat and chest pain beta blocker uses causes graves disease std and their symptoms relieve an earache pharmacological vs pharmaceutical methimazole skin rash 10 mls equals how many tablespoons salt pills for low blood pressure my period lasted 10 days is morphine safe during pregnancy yellow iron oxide 100 units per ml underarm rash cure royal jelly fertility prescription drugs discount adderall xr 30 mg price overdose on robitussin why people shake their legs double image after cataract surgery muscle twitching in back medications to treat multiple sclerosis examples of narcotics drugs how dentist pull teeth lower back pain after knee surgery acute pancreatitis prognosis tired of coughing what causes excessive diarrhea orthovisc vs synvisc achy back and legs ringworm hot tub what does chronic inflammation mean feeling dizzy when i lay down severe knee pain when bending coxis bone pain perform pain relief bleeding in anus ways to pass urine drug test how to make oxycodone forehead temperature fever type 1 fracture treating skin tears peroxide and sore throat shoulder pain getting worse ace inhibitors drugs infusion therapy for ulcerative colitis does a blood test hurt is retrograde ejaculation harmful breastfeeding and drinking alcohol chart diarrhea and flu symptoms forskolin diet pills reviews 25/42 cranberry extract capsules androgel half life msm methyl sulfonyl methane superficial definition anatomy grapefruit medication interaction list how does lactulose work metoprolol 200 mg sulfa allergy symptoms prescription for adderall cushion grip replacement my toddler keeps coughing can you eat jello while pregnant toe infections pictures pentacel vaccine schedule whats a felon bath and body sweet pea adipex and wellbutrin blood clot hemorrhoids what is in bayer aspirin are beta blockers dangerous what is methicillin abraxane side effects how many g in mg foods that give gas for life transfer factor que es un lipoma incentive spirometer directions convert 1000 mcg to mg zyrtec canine dosage pain in abdomen near belly button does prednisone keep you awake how long do concussions last slimy stool in adults decrease in seminal fluid pet scan pictures l theanine ocd what are signs of breast growth niacin recommended daily intake fruit and vegetables high in potassium pain medication norco nutrical for dogs medicine shoppe international inc why is opium illegal prp t vaccine red bumps on top of foot what does an elevated tsh mean infant advil dosage side effects of painkillers adderall scientific name what causes arthritis in your back inflammation of the kidney is called liver enzymes gallbladder paxil for premature ejaculation how many days period new type 2 diabetes medication checking baby temp under armpit ocrelizumab multiple sclerosis zocor generic name internal oblique muscle clotrimazole and betamethasone can svt kill you 6 day prednisone pack vivarin side effects oxycodone 60 mg picture people on bath salts when will acne stop promethazine cough syrup walgreens ear wax removal drops side effects of too much melatonin toddler vomiting in sleep lower back pulled muscle recovery time treatment for siadh moon shaped face effects of too much vitamin b horrible abdominal cramps venom-x rifaximin c diff ofloxacin ophthalmic solution usp shoulder blade brace salsalate brand name fda clinical trials tender neck lymph nodes arch in your foot colorless bumps on skin stud 100 male genital desensitizer spray foot warts pictures lump in my vagina giant cell arteritis eye cat seizure medication erythromycin ointment for pink eye food when nauseous is cholesterol hereditary high off bath salts mylanta side effects what is ptb wellbutrin smoking cessation dose beclomethasone 80 mcg growth hormone increase new headache medicine trichomonas symptoms in men iud with hormones pathophysiology of decubitus ulcer alcohol causes diabetes daily acetaminophen limit right leg swelling only omega 3 fatty acid mechanism of action heparin 300 mg trazodone stomach pain during menstrual cycle bilateral basal ganglia lacunar infarcts sore on clit beta blockers effect on blood pressure opiate withdrawal side effects can you drink on celexa knee pain vitamins signs of spleen rupture what is pantoprazol knee joint pain causes withdraw from lexapro robitussin cough gels warfarin and tooth extraction heart palpitation and dizziness can stress cause laryngitis prolia side effect yeast infection after stopping birth control what causes muscle cramps in legs what is tylenol 3 used for symptoms of chronic gastritis cost of lamotrigine without insurance dosing infant tylenol patella tendon tear definition of anxiolytic mucus with strep throat structure of lidocaine what can cause herpes stomach and bladder pain do potatoes cause bloating used fentanyl patch is acid illegal loose stool meaning one tablespoon equals how many grams flicker fusion frequency magnesium citrate benefits spiriva and atrovent morphine ir 30mg clear bumps on skin doxycycline hyclate brand name prescription medication for anxiety what is nac used for ww 176 pill track barometric pressure infection in stitches dairy bulls online lateral epicondyle elbow side effects of too much biotin how much melatonin to take is calamine lotion safe for dogs blood when pooping inversion medical definition condylar process of the mandible side your appendix is on 93832 yellow pill side effects long term tooth infection numbness on right thigh causes of transient global amnesia diazepam muscle relaxer marc glassman inc yeast infection test walmart ear skin infections cluster of bumps on vagina potassium citrate or gluconate clean and clear moisturizer side effects of anticonvulsants bleed when you poop what does white mucus mean broken pinky finger 38 degree farenheit to celcius beta blockers and sweating what is fluorouracil cream negative side effects of mirena over the counter shingles medication amoxicillin and bronchitis panic attack drugs what is a opiate drug taking abilify while pregnant pancreatitis support groups

Putting Mattingly in the Proper Perspective

Columns — By Scott Ham on January 5, 2009 10:52 am

Tim Marchman proposes his “theoretical Hall of Fame ballot” and takes the opportunity to slap Don Mattingly.  The offense:

Don Mattingly—No to probably the most overrated ballplayer of my lifetime. When I was growing up you’d have thought he was every bit Lou Gehrig’s equal based strictly on a four-year run that wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time. Even Bill James rated him the 12th best first baseman ever, above the obviously superior likes of Dick Allen, Will Clark, and Keith Hernandez, justifying this absurd ranking with the even more absurd explanation that he was “100% ballplayer, 0% bullshit.” This may or may not have been so, but he wasn’t all that much better than Derrek Lee.

In the spirit of full disclosure, let me start with this:

  • I have a frame in my man room with all of Don Mattingly’s rookie cards in it, including a minor league card distributed by Arby’s.
  • I have a signed baseball by Mattingly, although I didn’t get it in person.
  • I shed a tear at the retiring of his number at Yankee Stadium, which I attended in person.
  • In short, Mattingly was my childhood idol.

However, I do not believe Mattingly is a Hall of Famer.  I wish he was but he isn’t.

Despite that, Marchman’s criticism here is pretty misguided.  His opening comment alone is self-contradictory:

No to probably the most overrated ballplayer of my lifetime. When I was growing up you’d have thought he was every bit Lou Gehrig’s equal based strictly on a four-year run that wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time.

According to what I’ve seen online, Marchman will be 30 this year.  That means during Mattingly’s breakout season in 1984, Marchman was 5 years old.  At the end of the “four-year run,” Marchman was 8.  I’m sure at that age, he was sitting at the bar of the local diner debating baseball history with the old timers.  Maybe later in life, Marchman soaked in the undying love that Yankee fans had for Mattingly, but he wasn’t listening to anyone who was actually looking at his numbers.

As far as Eddie Murray goes, it’s an interesting point, but Marchman doesn’t mention that Murray was five years older than Mattingly.  Mattingly posted the exact same OPS as Murray in 1984 at the age of 23 while Murray was 28.  Murray’s OPS at 23 was 74 points lower than Mattingly’s.  In 1985, still five years younger, Mattingly had an OPS 33 points higher than Murray.  In 1986, Mattingly was 108 points higher than Murray.  Ditto 1987.

So no, Mr. Marchman.  It is incorrect to say Mattingly “wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time.”

Marchman continues:

Even Bill James rated him the 12th best first baseman ever, above the obviously superior likes of Dick Allen, Will Clark, and Keith Hernandez, justifying this absurd ranking with the even more absurd explanation that he was “100% ballplayer, 0% bullshit.” This may or may not have been so, but he wasn’t all that much better than Derrek Lee.

My Baseball Abstract is buried in a house under construction at the moment so I can’t reference the list James put together.  He did publish that version in 2001 which means at best he was referencing up until the 2000 season in his rankings.

At this stage, Mattingly probably isn’t the 12th greatest first baseman who ever played the game.  A lot of the hype that has surrounded Mattingly stemmed from 1984 – 1989 when he put up good to great numbers.  Even with his down years, he still maintained an OPS+ above 100 for 11 of his 13 fulltime seasons.

At the time, that hype was justified.  If you compare Mattingly’s stats to the history of first basemen up until the age of 28, Mattingly places 11th, behind Frank Thomas, Jeff Bagwell, Eddie Murray and Will Clark, but ahead of Fred McGriff, Keith Hernandez, Mark McGwire and, yes, Derrek Lee.

There was much reason to believe that Mattingly could be one of the greats until a back injury shortened and destroyed his career.  That doesn’t create any excuses.  It only leaves us all to wonder what could have been.

Is Mattingly overrated?  In the hearts of non-objective Yankee fans, absolutely.  His value to them went beyond numbers.  But the hype at the time was justified.  It just didn’t last long enough.

Tags: baseball, Bill James, Derrek Lee, Dick Allen, Don Mattingly, Eddie Murray, first baseman, Frank Thomas, Fred McGriff, I shed, Jeff Bagwell, Keith Hernandez, Lou Gehrig, Major League Baseball, Marchman, Mark McGwire, Mattingly, Murray, New York Yankees players, Will Clark, Yankee Stadium

6 Comments

  1. Vinnie S. says:

    Thanks, Scott. Finally, someone that actually remembers Mattingly.

  2. Mike O says:

    Scott I sent the link and posted a little comment of my own.

  3. You're an idiot says:

    Fuck you.

  4. stang7222 says:

    Just compare Mattingly’s numbers to those of first ballot Hall Of Famer Kirby Puckett, who also had an injury shortened career. its the “Hall Of Fame” and if being the biggest name on the biggest team isn’t fame…….

    • Scott Ham says:

      Personally, I don’t think Puckett should have been elected because his numbers don’t compare to other outfielders in the Hall. Making a mistake with Puckett doesn’t justify making one with Mattingly. It just weakens the hall.

      Regarding fame, I don’t think you can apply the name
      that literally. That’s like saying Mel Hall should be in the Hall of Fame because his last name is Hall.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.