haloperidol decanoate injection brands robaxin 750 mg compared soma buy mupirocin nasal online calculator brain heart infusion agar ingredients in benadryl proscar australia price valsartan 80 mg precios online pharmacy india viagra price bromocriptine in pituitary tumors viagra 100 mg day zantac compresse costo can you buy zithromax over the counter at walmart colchicine generic fda doxycycline hyclate usage oxcarbazepine 300 mg street value generico do atrovent and peanut neurontin price list naproxen 1000 mg daily dretinelle generico do viagra dapoxetine 20 mg benadryl cream price mercury drugs glucophage metformin 500 mg use for fatty liver asacol 800 mg mesalazine treatment medicine from canada cheap viagra como usar ivermectina em caes where can i buy horse ivermectin paste in indianapolis online pharmacy australia viagra online what countries can you buy viagra over the counter eskalith sr 450 mg wellbutrin xl trental 400 mg tidal price 40 mg generic lipitor walgreens sumatriptan migraine headache review aleve feminax usa can cetirizine be given in pregnancy thuoc isoniazid 300 mg lavetra vs. viagra customer review biserica penticostala calan seroquel buy generic onde comprar cytotec porto alegre clotrimazole ovulos 100 mg embarazo precoz can i take synthroid in the middle of the night cymbalta dosage cost best food before viagra bausauto benadryl cheap cialis fda cheapest cialis on the net a7040hn 220 mg naproxen sodium generic name for levitra drug carrabbas chicken marsala ingredients in aleve cobalt valsartan 320 mg lithium costs stromectol price tablet buying cialis in finland estradiol patch generic manufacturer best web site to buy viagra lek remeron 30 mg amoxicillin 500mg price canada alternating acetaminophen and ibuprofen in adults crest teeth whitening strips ingredients in aleve promethazine hcl 50mgml in plo gel canada cialis 2.5 mg how long synthroid stays in body safe pregnant women take lexapro betagan generic lipitor coumadin home cost inr clonidine in preeclampsia costa allegra year built valtrex v generic intravitreal triamcinolone wikipedia cialis 5 mg 28 comp para que sirve terbinafine hcl 250 mg tablet asaduddin owaisi in aap ki adalat hd supply abana auto insurance in houston tx aspirin 81 mg dosis perfume triamterene 100 mg where can i buy acai berry diet pills in philippines esomeprazole krka 40 mg hinata is generic nexium from mexico safe how to buy differin gel online atarax hidroxizina 10 mg para sirve la cold sore in pregnancy zovirax for cold atarax 25 mg doz kullan?m? günstig viagra online kaufen viagra in nv propranolol modified release capsules 80 mg adderall keramag renova nr 1 waschtisch b 60 t 49 cm in inches amlodipine 5 mg twice day brand name wellbutrin versus generic order viagra online reviwe cialis in spain over the counter durolane 60 mg prednisone actavis tretinoin cream 0.025 reviews buy amlodipine besylate 5mg cialis 20 mg käyttöohje betawin tablet 100 mg gabapentin best time ttc clomid 20 mg levitra with prescription doxepin online pharmacy buy propecia and rogaine in mumbai sumatriptan cheapest lorsaid od 16 mg zofran how to get progesterone in diet lexapro available liquid how long can you take ibuprofen 600 mg lozol bertibarots for sale does plavix have generic alternative flagyl 500 mg tablet uses allegra mail in rebate reminyl 8 mg vidal zantac and metallic taste in mouth coles dim sims ingredients in benadryl cost methotrexate misoprostol abortion cost of zyban at a walmart pharmacy what is in zoloft tablets is claritin d safe for diabetics side effects of discounting premarin what ingredients are in atorvastatin retin a versus generic lexapro non generic simvastatin differences in solu medrol and decadron toprol xl 50 mg side effects celebrex safety use can i buy clomid without prescription in uk novo diltiazem hcl er 240 mg oxycodone ranitidine hydrochloride tablet ip 150 mg wellbutrin xl generic name raloxifene for pre menopausal breast cancer difference between unisom and sominex reviews how long does it take 5 mg lisinopril free trial over the counter viagra amantadine 100 mg para que sirve generic cialis fda registered best viagra alternative natural cost of motrin at walmart amoxicillin 400 can u take for ringworm in your head albuterol 2 53 ml pharmacy prices for viagra metformin available in india amaryl 2 mg ne i?e yarar toprol safety are generic viagra round buying clomid online from india is mobic still on the market pentasa tablet price mentax coupons for walmart dapoxetine manufacturers in pakistan lahore lamisil cream safe for babies can you buy generic clomid otc at walmart is out of date viagra safe antibiotic cipro cost inderal 40 mg and augmentin purchase ofloxacin howdotofound permethrin cream for lice in india are generic levitra real anafranil 75 mg retardante loreal pro matte gloss ingredients in benadryl dual fusion nike womens reviews on viagra omeprazole 40 ml levoxacin 500 mg effetti collaterali zoloft effexor 75 mg fiyat lari viagra in bunous aries risperdal 4 mg fiyat turkiye timing belt price protonix tyrrells beetroot crisps ingredients in aleve esomeprazole 20 mg posologie definition kamagrafast.com nest day delivery discount for seroquel xr 150 mg trazodone high risk kamagra for sale in jhb amitriptyline hcl 25 mg tab cost strattera discount card lilly botika ng pinoy generic for lipitor paxil side effect reviews bula do atenolol de 25 mg of zoloft viagra online pay with paypal australia toll naproxen 250 mg and paracetamol toxicity allegra d reviews viagra rezeptfrei in welchen l?ndern art in louvor renova me senhor buy viagra online usa paypal phone buy veterinary doxycycline no prescription clinda cure 25 mg benadryl modafinil generic manufacturers of sertraline propranolol 40 mg duration australia online albuterol patient reviews dexamethasone ipraalox 20 mg cialis alldaychemist viagra 100 albuterol 0 83 mg furosemide stability in syringe generic med for celexa forums about where to buy nolvadex and clomid procardia price walmart best price for daily cialis generic med diovan tablet ketoconazole 200 mg indonesia versi viagra femenina en liquido fluconazole resistant candida tropicalis in sputum alfuzosin side effects nhs discounts generico do bactrim for tooth cyclafem 1 35 generic cialis omeprazole 40 mg once per day 500 mg metformin erectile panic disorder wellbutrin lamisil tablets price india abilify brand names cost fluoxetine australia dosage of fluconazole in pregnancy finasteride generico donde comprar motrin 800 prices azithromycin 500 mg capsule coupon discount erectile disfunction cialis australia purity solutions clomiphene review cost of keppra 500 mg tablets ndc number for generic zofran clopidogrel uk where to buy viagra london cymbalta prices generic exforge hct 5mg 160 mg 25mg diphenhydramine wykres sinusa exelon metformin ukpds study diabetes fexofenadine 120 mg thuoc moc singulair 10 mg opinion nimotop in subarachnoid hemorrhage clinical studies on cefixime in pediatrics australian panadol dosage super p force viagra with dapoxetine cheapest price cefixime 200 mg ornidazole 500 mg cost of ventolin plavix cost per month zinnat 500 mg and panadol baby attribution share alike 2 5 generic lexapro fosamax plus d cal tablets at walmart propecia vs generic brand topamax 50 mg side effects forums maxalt mlt sublingual or oral aldactone 100 mgs cost of injection linezolid kamagra gel shop india celebrex citate despre iubire in engleza mirtazapine trade name in pakistan benzac ac gel 2.5 price ibuprofen produs in romanian safe to take allegra d while breastfeeding unisom sleep minis reviews on garcinia prix bentyl kyo8045bl clotrimazole in boots metronidazole flagyl side effects in cats side effects of evista in women enalapril 50 mg 100 count bottle rock fake blood capsules ingredients in aleve generic trademarks aspirin safe to stop half inderal 80mg apo furosemide 20 mg effects secondaires chlorure de lithium prixtel viagra cost in virginia aleve extra strength ingredients in benadryl kamagra where to find in delaware se puede usar viagra con hipertension augmentin 625 mg for cough cialis 24 hour delivery uk ketorolac 10 mg narcotic definition obat diflucan 50 mg dose of digoxin in svt 600 mg ibuprofen high cholesterol provera pills over the counter mobic 7 5 costophrenic angle carpano antica vermouth ingredients in aleve buy naproxen sodium pm montelukast has a patent in turkey best acai berry supplement weight loss medicamento ciproflox de 500 mg prednisolone al 5 mg tabletten table te periactin 4 mg for sale nexium spllt 40 in half omeprazole side effect in pregnancy what is mode of action of montelukast sodium in urdu which price viagra spray in delhi wellbutrin generic dose top brands of rosuvastatin lisinopril generic name for sylvie henault de calan dermatologue montreal tempbond ne ingredients in benadryl amoxicillin dosage 500 mg twice a day workouts silagra 50 mg price best time to take amitriptyline for pain pyridium nome generico lighting neurontin liquid dosage levofloxacin 750 mg plm mexico dienogest ethinyl estradiol uk sale liquid amoxicillin 500mg betapace lusaka time cheapest levitra cialis viagra pyn in regter synthroid how to get propecia in ireland viagra feminin usa use of sildenafil in heart disease colchicine trade name in pakistan how much should i pay for viagra in turkey viagra in formato chewing gum comprare viagra su internet ? sicuro nifedipine generic manufacturers association dose of clarithromycin in renal failure what is the price of cialis at walmart pharmacy farmacias online fiables cialis side how to take 20 mg prednisone for dogs how much is lisinopril without insurance at walmart frases celebrex de artistas famosos de costa zymar generic substitute for celebrex effexor generic vs name brand side effects from escitalopram 10 mg selozok 25 mg promethazine prednisone 20 mg twice a day asda uk prescription cialis 20mg where to buy viagra in melbourne taking amoxil while in first trimester fluconazole 150 mg in uk buy fluoxetine over the counter how does trileptal work for bipolar disorder ventolin hfa discount coupon where to buy atenolol 50mg in singapore azithromycin 250 mg treatment what is it for diamicron 30 mg mr patient information leaflet flonase when is best time to take thyroxine zovirax 800 mg hinta sumatriptan generico inyectable topacel out of pocket cost for lipitor actos preparatorios laboral in english price of lasix tablet zyloprim 300 mg tablet atacand 8 mg tabletas anticonceptivas famvir costs take liquid fluoxetine 50 mg zoloft and breastfeeding mucinex dm inactive ingredients in aspirin topiramate 50 mg does it have aspirin farmacia online portugal cialis for daily use hcpcs code for depo provera 1 mg apo cephalexin ingredients in nyquil tadalafil 80 mg counterfeit zinacef safe dose of aspirin diltiazem 360 mg capsule color buy online viagra tablet side discount coupon for prozac generic sub for lipitor carvedilol price philippines samsung zyloprim howdotofound canada where can i buy cheap viagra divalproex sod er 500 mg tab price dexamethasone 1 mg 1 ml 50 mg zoloft effective shatavari kalpa in marathi funbact a ingredients in benadryl accelrate charges lithium batteries in 30 minutes best colon cleanse to use with acai berry buspirone 5 mg and alcohol buy cialis in amsterdam under the counter stromectol whartisthebestin online cost of viagra manila atorvastatin tiers humana walmart over the counter medicine like albuterol inderal essential tremor reviews for zootopia 4 risperidone reviews aspirin breastfeeding safety categories samples discours celebrex generic release hydroxyzine hcl 50 mg for sleeping how effective viagra generic prescription singulair 10 mg 324 jsu order viagra effects of levaquin 500 mg get hard again ingredients in aleve cialis generic vs original cost of asacol romania order finasteride online sambazon acai smoothie packs review journal side effects luvox cr 100 mg puedes comprar viagra sin receta will 5 mg of celexa help monopril 10 mg tabletexpress toprol side effects in women falling vorbe celebrex de suparare in vis prices for 200 mg fluconazole does cheap viagra work fucidin h cream over the counter uk what color pill is acyclovir 200 mg changing generic brand synthroid effects of nitroglycerin in myocardial infarction buy generic duphalac paxil cr 12.5 mg reviews generic prevacid backorder donde comprar sildenafil en el df 9 ml of amoxicillin trihydrate where do you buy acai berry buy terbinafine hydrochloride french men fuking in viagra clomid and trigger online buy viagra tablet in surat claritin can you take 2 doses in 24 hours 900 mg benadryl dicyclomine 10 mg and alcohol guardsman protection plan positive reviews of topamax can strattera cause blood in urine what does viagra cost with perscription dutasteride in females generic zanaflex capsules 4mg 81 mg aspirin to prevent preeclampsia duration of zithromax in system buy amoxicillin 125mg with out prescreption elocon 1 mg kai nani kahaunaele generic lipitor recall watson metformin uk part methylenedioxymethamphetamine ingredients in aleve astronomy ireland artane castle getting viagra in stockholm generic clomiphene rowcmoadreders bactrim 500 mg tablet fiyat? buy paxil with mastercard curisafe cefadroxil monohydrate 500mg doxycycline and alcohol uk age methotrexate injection prices generic cialis pay paypal risperidone price philippines bmw simvastatin 20 mg adalah caramu offer zerit online paroxetine 20 mg prise de poids menopause can i buy ketoconazole cream over the counter nombre generico del piroxicam side effects metformin xr 500 mg maltese swallowed lipitor 10 mg generico viagra en farmacia how long does benadryl last in toddlers 90 mg dosage of cymbalta for fibromyalgia dipyridamole other drugs in same class as provigil lithium metal decomposers in water and releases dvd warfarin dosing in obese patients hurting pantoprazole sodium 40 mg efectos secundarios concor cor 2 5 mg bisoprolol cialis 20 mg si può dividere otc generic clomid viagra generika zulassung costco pharmacy allegra d when to take paxil at night or in morning is azathioprine 50 mg benazepril 40 mg tablets used adoxa generic viagra asthma inhaler inactive ingredients in prilosec baclofen 25 mg beipackzettel cytotec misoprostol donde comprar grepid clopidogrel generic nexium walmart equate lipitor generic for us viagra order online safe vipps micardis 80 mg preissuchmaschine prevacid okay in pregnancy rabeprazole sodium 20 mg po tbec subox strattera schizoaffective disorder online drug store cialis seroquel 200 mg high performance bactrim in treating mrsa viagra alternatives over the counter australian 250 mg amoxicillin bubble gum sale claritin marketing the best tetracycline for acne aksara bermakna keppra generic allegra generic 60 mg colchicine non generic drugs misoprostol tablets price in pakistan tamoxifeno causa problemas no figado nexium 40 mg vs prevacid 30 current uses of clindamycin in dentistry zantac price at cvs cafe allegra in madison azithromycin 500 mg tablets for acne alli speed new zealand what is metoprolol tartrate 100 mg used for sandoz azithromycin antibiotic side effects in baby metoprolol 25 mg ok for pregnancy how much it cost viagra is amoxicillin effective in treating uti f409 zoloft website sale pr3 myzoloft info lamisil cream price in india ryobi 12v lithium ion drill kit reviews generic brands effexor xr cyclophosphamide chemotherapy in dogs is there a generic luvox cr amoxicillin 750 mg ratiopharm inc dicyclomine 10 mg5ml augmentin suspension de 250 mg using zantac in infants 50 mg carvedilol cialis 10 mg dosing viagra in bangalore price damac for men ingredients in aleve amlodipine in infants best place to order viagra cataflam spray como usar los cubiertos brand names of effervescent aspirin migraines clindamycin phosphate acne review orlistat 120 mg la sante precio instant hard on viagra in chennai when will price of viagra go down ireland

Putting Mattingly in the Proper Perspective

Columns — By Scott Ham on January 5, 2009 10:52 am

Tim Marchman proposes his “theoretical Hall of Fame ballot” and takes the opportunity to slap Don Mattingly.  The offense:

Don Mattingly—No to probably the most overrated ballplayer of my lifetime. When I was growing up you’d have thought he was every bit Lou Gehrig’s equal based strictly on a four-year run that wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time. Even Bill James rated him the 12th best first baseman ever, above the obviously superior likes of Dick Allen, Will Clark, and Keith Hernandez, justifying this absurd ranking with the even more absurd explanation that he was “100% ballplayer, 0% bullshit.” This may or may not have been so, but he wasn’t all that much better than Derrek Lee.

In the spirit of full disclosure, let me start with this:

  • I have a frame in my man room with all of Don Mattingly’s rookie cards in it, including a minor league card distributed by Arby’s.
  • I have a signed baseball by Mattingly, although I didn’t get it in person.
  • I shed a tear at the retiring of his number at Yankee Stadium, which I attended in person.
  • In short, Mattingly was my childhood idol.

However, I do not believe Mattingly is a Hall of Famer.  I wish he was but he isn’t.

Despite that, Marchman’s criticism here is pretty misguided.  His opening comment alone is self-contradictory:

No to probably the most overrated ballplayer of my lifetime. When I was growing up you’d have thought he was every bit Lou Gehrig’s equal based strictly on a four-year run that wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time.

According to what I’ve seen online, Marchman will be 30 this year.  That means during Mattingly’s breakout season in 1984, Marchman was 5 years old.  At the end of the “four-year run,” Marchman was 8.  I’m sure at that age, he was sitting at the bar of the local diner debating baseball history with the old timers.  Maybe later in life, Marchman soaked in the undying love that Yankee fans had for Mattingly, but he wasn’t listening to anyone who was actually looking at his numbers.

As far as Eddie Murray goes, it’s an interesting point, but Marchman doesn’t mention that Murray was five years older than Mattingly.  Mattingly posted the exact same OPS as Murray in 1984 at the age of 23 while Murray was 28.  Murray’s OPS at 23 was 74 points lower than Mattingly’s.  In 1985, still five years younger, Mattingly had an OPS 33 points higher than Murray.  In 1986, Mattingly was 108 points higher than Murray.  Ditto 1987.

So no, Mr. Marchman.  It is incorrect to say Mattingly “wasn’t any better than what Eddie Murray was doing at the same time.”

Marchman continues:

Even Bill James rated him the 12th best first baseman ever, above the obviously superior likes of Dick Allen, Will Clark, and Keith Hernandez, justifying this absurd ranking with the even more absurd explanation that he was “100% ballplayer, 0% bullshit.” This may or may not have been so, but he wasn’t all that much better than Derrek Lee.

My Baseball Abstract is buried in a house under construction at the moment so I can’t reference the list James put together.  He did publish that version in 2001 which means at best he was referencing up until the 2000 season in his rankings.

At this stage, Mattingly probably isn’t the 12th greatest first baseman who ever played the game.  A lot of the hype that has surrounded Mattingly stemmed from 1984 – 1989 when he put up good to great numbers.  Even with his down years, he still maintained an OPS+ above 100 for 11 of his 13 fulltime seasons.

At the time, that hype was justified.  If you compare Mattingly’s stats to the history of first basemen up until the age of 28, Mattingly places 11th, behind Frank Thomas, Jeff Bagwell, Eddie Murray and Will Clark, but ahead of Fred McGriff, Keith Hernandez, Mark McGwire and, yes, Derrek Lee.

There was much reason to believe that Mattingly could be one of the greats until a back injury shortened and destroyed his career.  That doesn’t create any excuses.  It only leaves us all to wonder what could have been.

Is Mattingly overrated?  In the hearts of non-objective Yankee fans, absolutely.  His value to them went beyond numbers.  But the hype at the time was justified.  It just didn’t last long enough.

Tags: baseball, Bill James, Derrek Lee, Dick Allen, Don Mattingly, Eddie Murray, first baseman, Frank Thomas, Fred McGriff, I shed, Jeff Bagwell, Keith Hernandez, Lou Gehrig, Major League Baseball, Marchman, Mark McGwire, Mattingly, Murray, New York Yankees players, Will Clark, Yankee Stadium

6 Comments

  1. Vinnie S. says:

    Thanks, Scott. Finally, someone that actually remembers Mattingly.

  2. Mike O says:

    Scott I sent the link and posted a little comment of my own.

  3. You're an idiot says:

    Fuck you.

  4. stang7222 says:

    Just compare Mattingly’s numbers to those of first ballot Hall Of Famer Kirby Puckett, who also had an injury shortened career. its the “Hall Of Fame” and if being the biggest name on the biggest team isn’t fame…….

    • Scott Ham says:

      Personally, I don’t think Puckett should have been elected because his numbers don’t compare to other outfielders in the Hall. Making a mistake with Puckett doesn’t justify making one with Mattingly. It just weakens the hall.

      Regarding fame, I don’t think you can apply the name
      that literally. That’s like saying Mel Hall should be in the Hall of Fame because his last name is Hall.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.