levothyroxine and wine cialis western open natural sources of viagra stiftung warentest cialis find generic drug for lamisil viagra for medical reasons metoprolol succinate sr what is the normal dose of doxycycline doxycycline decreased urination neurontin interactions percocet allegra east footprint fund nexium innhold spironolactone tablet description will cialis over the counter flagyl canada over the counter does wellbutrin cause hyponatremia can i take amoxicillin if im taking atenolol pret pastila diflucan sucralfate and doxycycline amoxicillin dosage for treatment of chlamydia celecoxib use dogs eliza 120 mg orlistat bantning valium mixed with viagra buy metronidazole in us individual pills not in bulk ciprofloxacin bupropion names of best viagra tablets to seduce womens in india levitra hydrochloride tablets plavix and bare metal stents common side effects of lamisil albuterol hypotension what type of drug is cymbalta ethinyl estradiol mestranol side effects of cipro medicine serotonin withdrawal syndrome zoloft zyvox vitamins can strattera be snorted 50mg of clomid order uk escitalopram fatigue clomid while trying to conceive 20 mg lisinopril and uric acid presupuesto para fincar una casa levofloxacin ophthalmic solution 0.5 prices for bupropion viagra costo euro can you take viagra with blood thinners cytotec vs cervidil for induction does synthroid cause weight loss or weight gain que es cialis 5mg teva spironolactone pcos is penicillin or amoxicillin stronger hoodia diet pills launches seasonal promotion is propranolol used for headaches 850 mg metformin ttc xenical resolve mesmo para que sirve el flagyl en jarabe quetiapine and icu delirium glucophage elimination como tomar el aciclovir de 400 mg regular dosage of levitra nolvadex when to use does nolvadex kickstart test production gabapentin colorectal surgery pcos medication spironolactone xenical rapid weight loss atenolol propranolol kamagra ? legale inderal ptsd treatment viagra preiswert how much does montelukast cost 20 mg prednisone dosage poison ivy allegra panvel amlodipine for gout escitalopram lek oryginalny ventolin aerosol baby wellbutrin breastfeeding supply h. pylori clarithromycin amoxicillin fungsi obat nizoral indicaciones terapeuticas de la ciprofloxacina chloramphenicol prednisolone salep apa nexium 120 milligrams erythromycin fixed drug eruption menikini allegra 500c prezzo can abilify stop being effective prednisone compared to hydrocortisone viagra karachi original atorvastatin calcium stability studies paxil cr settlement abilify commercial umbrella voice ofloxacin dosage for adults allopurinol testimonials what time of day should you take celebrex quetiapine and zopiclone can u take aleve with amoxicillin how quickly does prednisone work ulcerative colitis allopurinol dosage uric acid zoloft 3 weeks what is difference between inderal and tenormin why military wont prescribe propecia antibiotic capsule for tooth pain zithromax morning cialis costs too much oxytetracycline long term side effects can pregnant women take acyclovir where in jamaica can i get cheap viagra metronidazole flagyl oral for yeast infections does amitriptyline interact with cymbalta epstein barr valtrex menstrual cycle sildenafil heumann 100mg filmtabletten 24 st?ck propecia effectiveness if used early methylprednisolone and prednisone conversion estrace prescribing info side effects of alcohol and celebrex nexium tyres cipro pre med dosage does propecia work at front of head how long does prednisone take to clear up poison ivy lexapro hard to ejaculate chemical class of azithromycin dutasteride by cipla does vicodin interfere with lexapro amoxicillin reactions in infants comprar viagra zaragoza sertraline hcl 50 mg ingredients nexium sobres posologia health insurance cover viagra tamsulosin xl tablets using cipro for sinus infection lexapro and weight loss side effects cialis et an?vrisme adverse side effects of misoprostol how many days after clomid should i ovulate plavix who makes it what happens if you take two allegra in 24 hours cialis farmacie svizzera zoloft and infertility what happens if you mix zoloft with alcohol latorre fincaraiz forum glucophage 500 mg are kamagra pills kgr 100 legal in uk viagra mi cialis mi eksi montelukast square now round nexium dprice pakistan nexium gunanya steroids clomid side effects galpharm aciclovir viagra vs competitors use of 50 mg prednisone for one day harga lamisil capsule en donde se consigue cytotec bisoprolol erythromycin ciprofloxacin hund erythromycin feeling hungry norvasc dosage amounts levitra and harder erections cipro cosa comprare viagra barata barcelona diferenca entre bupropion xl 150 mg e hcl sr 100 mg is metformin allowed in dubai etodolac viagra increase of libido propecia shelf life of prednisone medication diabeticos podem tomar cialis does clomid cause bad cramps lexapro side effects sore jaw buying viagra 4 pills estradiol para fiv pediatric dosage of atenolol chloramphenicol antibiotic eye for dogs is viagra and niacin safe taken together cialis pharmacy price lepraxo vs paxil for tinnitus tamoxifen endometrial polyps side effects to augmentin duo tamoxifeno cegueira propecia o avodart made in china 20mg cialis can i take 5 hour energy with lexapro dosis misoprostol embarazo clopidogrel 75 mg tablet shelf life can i snort tramadol with buspar lipitor sales graph best generic cialis pills price bupropion combination venlafaxine estrace et insomnie where can i buy tamoxifen in the uk voltaren emulgel ncaa viagra alternative after heart attack comparaison viagra ou cialis bonac gel erythromycin 4 effect of azithromycin tab ip 500 mg how to buy viagra in indian rupees sildenafil emea metoprolol gereguleerde afgifte amoxicillin drug interactions birth control zofran hurtownia when the moment is right will you be ready cialis fluconazole medical advice levothyroxine manufacturers usa doxycycline intestinal pain multiple birth rates with clomid consuming cialis viagra tablety taking clomipramine during pregnancy zithromax tablets for sale viagra cialis comparativa discussione sul cialis septra mg allegra k coupons pfizer viagra hong kong secure site buy on line nexium authorized generic zovirax cream is for viagra india worldwide armour vs synthroid and cytomel what is a lethal dose of phenergan drug in narcotic seroquel test can you take cymbalta with thyroid meds zithromax cause nausea viagra my dick cuanto cuesta el viagra mexico prednisone pot belly pig does prednisone make you sick to your stomach can prednisone make you sicker ofloxacin dosage for kids when not to use metformin is 100 mg of zoloft safe dose of amoxicillin for syphilis gabapentin liquid side effects how many amitriptyline to overdose aciclovir farmacia salcobrand when dose levitra go generic levofloxacin cap sssi does gabapentin work for everyone is azithromycin effective against typhoid adalat sony tv program lopressor and dizziness tramadol and levothyroxine interaction wellbutrin 2ce cialis cumming orlistat lesofat price can i increase the dose of viagra to 300mg yohimbe und tadalafil buspar dose increase how to pass a drug test using lasix side effects after stopping sertraline what does a package of cialis look like splitting wellbutrin xr can i take diclofenac with prednisone prendere il viagra a 20 anni ciprofloxacin 500 mg abz celebrex mobic together does doxycycline 100 mg work for a sinus infection finpecia generic propecia finasteride 1mg canadian drugs lipitor how to taper 30 mg prednisone in 5 days maca root tamoxifen ovary removed vs nolvadex late ovulation clomid egg quality doxycycline how to take for malaria flomax for postoperative urinary retention nolvadex klomen doxycycline clostridium difficile colitis antibiotika amoxicillin alkohol dosage cipro bladder infection finasteride and edema transition dosage lexapro to cymbalta zithromax name in india metformin lactic acidosis moa jak vysadit zoloft cialis achat france can i legally buy viagra in the us taking 150 mg of zoloft augmentin 600 iv cytotec dose labor induction muscle aches after cipro soi tetracycline dexamethasone costco efectos secundarios de montelukast sodico how to increase affect of cialis clomid progesterone iui nexium 40mg indicacao azithromycin side effects hunger wellbutrin and adderall xr for young adults taking seroquel and cymbalta together quoi sert buspirone escitalopram dog damgerous buy viagra 150 mg tetracycline on piercings cosa succede se prendo il cialis much does synthroid cost cvs viagra iquique erectile dysfunction caused by zoloft adalat pih baclofen psychosis missed my metoprolol wellbutrin and lexapro dosage durata effetto levitra 10 mg clopidogrel and ppi nice costa allegra helicopter ou acheter cialis lilly metoprolol caco 2 permeability can you mix buspar and valium allegra hicks elle decor is it ok to take viagra with pot cvs charges for viagra what does medicare pay for cialis bivirkninger ved baclofen po to iv metoprolol makan pil clomid bactrim benzodiazepines can the man take cialis when trying to get pregnant doxycycline petco 875 mg amoxicillin alot duloxetine pricing azithromycin stability in solution flushing and cialis levitra tablet ke salt how much does viagra reduce your blook pressure medicine orlistat capsules buy shimano viagra sti neurontin ms ms risques cytotec xenical gebruik finasteride prostate reviews xenical kimler kullanabilir zithromax 600 pfizer topiramate vyvanse safety of metronidazole cream vs pills when pregnant dostinex quita el hambre nombre generico norvasc azithromycin 1 g on sale strattera good after expiration leinsamen bei tamoxifen can prednisone cause muscle and joint pain albuterol and icp when was cipro fda approved orlistat generic canada metoprolol sinus pause coupons for allegra how long does cialis take to effect se puede combinar cialis con alcohol buy nexium 40 mg tablets would viagra make you last longer singulair 10 prezzo metilprednisolone prednisone dosi equivalenti ventolin dosage copd diet free pill uso de la ivermectina en aves what happens if a person without ed takes viagra compare erythromycin and penicillin amoxicillin mercury plavix dilantin hindi serial adalat watch online is viagra available over the counter amitriptyline addiction site de confiance achat viagra quetiapine thyroid problems amoxicillin take three times a day ventas de cytotec en barquisimeto aripiprazole schizophrenia medications why not eat grapefruit with lipitor cramping on clomid after ovulation get high off augmentin doxiciclina ciproxin is 40 milligrams of cialis too much ivermectina cura la rosacea am i pregnant on clomid what are the signs that a cat needs more furosemide lipitor 4.00 copay card can i take tamoxifen with food does hydrochlorothiazide cause dry cough celexa street use cipro peritoneal dialysis dosing lasix side effects women lasix shortage viagra foods women bactrim bad side effects clomid and 6 dpo aciclovir para quedar embarazada zovirax ointment price in india contraindicaciones de plavix misoprostol searle 1411 cymbalta 30 mg anxiety ketoconazole cream on face escitalopram besser als citalopram can abilify cause gas does azithromycin cancel out birth control pills cephalexin ndc code flagyl metronidazole and breastfeeding valium cymbalta european pharmacopoeia aciclovir celebrex united healthcare when to take zovirax tablets flomax group of companies setraline zoloft for ulcer patient can you take zoloft without eating thyroxine water should you take cialis with l arginine levothyroxine sodium maximum dose cost of viagra for insurance companies generic periactin cyproheptadine doxycycline and bananas can topamax be taken with lunesta hes on viagra donde consigo pastilla cytotec erythromycin eye ointment gonorrhea accutane red face does wellbutrin interfere with sleep zovirax 200mg concomitant levitra and ciallis wellbutrin side effects weight masshealth abilify prior authorization nexium causes fatigue bactrim et allaitement forzest tablet price in india une femme peut elle prendre du viagra price of lamisil cream in sa cialis preis 5 mg cialis 20 generika bupropion blood test notice zoloft 50 aciclovir salbe kind taking finasteride and flomax phenergan promethazine syrup i.p for one year old baby can you drink tea with synthroid cost of iv nexium can you take advil pm with wellbutrin clomid 150 werkt niet olanzapine wafer dosage antidepressants and alcohol overdose bactrim von roche viagra tablets natural is acyclovir better than abreva blood pressure medicine plus viagra funciona siempre el viagra side effects of metronidazole in humans cipro causing uti topiramate zd 16 viagra apres operation prostate albuterol vision side effects how does xenical work best tetracycline ulcerative colitis metronidazole 500mg and birth control facts clomid ovulation on day 14 normal walmart pharmacy price range for vardenafil le viagra temoignage how long does it take for propecia to wear off viagra pfizer advert lowtane accutane levofloxacin lung infection heure prise zyprexa ok to use levitra to masturbat viagra buy in south africa virasorb cold sore cream aciclovir are there any rebates for propecia can i drink alcohol while taking acyclovir 400 mg viagra for melanoma methocarbamol safe for breastfeeding does prednisone dry up poison ivy amoxicillin vs ampicillin for enterococcus fixed drug eruption prednisone allegra mcevedy perfect street food sildenafil sri lanka buy orlistat 60 otc paroxetine temps daction ventolin aspirin kafein cialis daily versus as needed motilium si nexium tingling in legs zoloft kenia cialis nortriptyline reviews ivermectin dog dosage mange clomid effects on men oxytetracycline chien amitriptyline hcl for diarrhea buy warfarin rat poison second set of twins on clomid ciprofloxacin dexamethasone eye drops does doxycycline cure lyme dosage for cialis for 75 year old man cipro muscle aches medicines smilar to viagra can i take meloxicam and hydrocodone together finasteride acne in women sperm ejection time after taking viagra is dialated pupils a side effect from generic zoloftcts can a woman tell if a man has taken cialis levitra purple finger tips long does phenergan last cialis side effects on warfarin orlistat farmacias ahorro lexapro y la libido shelf life for fluconazole 40 mg z trial atorvastatin side effects of thyroxine injections avodart zulassung can i take nexium and tums together valtrex before shingles outbreak tadalafil price in qatar cialis preiswert kaufen kandungan dalam viagra

Analyzing the Posada/Molina Situation

Featured — By Scott Ham on October 9, 2009 11:05 am

When the Yankees take the field tonight against the Twins for game two of the American League Division Series, a backup catcher will be behind the plate.

Jose Molina was tagged the game two catcher even before the Yankees 7-2 win over the Twins in game one of the ALDS, ending season long speculation about starter Jorge Posada’s status with AJ Burnett.

Everyone has said the right thing: this isn’t about individuals, it’s about the team.  If you have watched Jorge Posada play for the last 12 years, you know that the mind and heart are not in sync.

Posada was obviously annoyed at the news, saying “You know what? I just hope we win that game.  That’s all I’ve got to say.”

He’s since lightened his stance.  “I’m not jumping with joy here, but I accept it.  A.J. and Jose are going well. I haven’t caught A.J. in a while.”

The bigger question has been whether this is the right move by Girardi.

It’s not an easy question to answer because there are a few variables here, most notably the inconsistency of AJ Burnett.  Burnett is a notoriously streaky pitcher, able to rattle off periods of dominance and then completely fall off the cliff for weeks at a time.  It’s almost entirely due to Burnett’s control, which can fluctuate wildly not only from start to start but within an inning as well.

Before we try and dissect what’s happening specifically with Burnett, let’s get a look at Posada and Molina’s overall performance over the last four years:

Posada Team ERA rERA
2006 NYY 4.36 4.71
2007 NYY 4.49 4.80
2008 NYY 4.61 5.03
2009 NYY 5.02 5.50
Molina Team ERA rERA
2006 LAA 3.98 4.42
2007 LAA 4.60 4.96
2007 NYY 4.62 4.94
2008 NYY 3.70 3.97
2009 NYY 3.31 3.79

Obviously these are not very good trends for Posada.  2008 is a bit of a wash for Jorge as he spent the few innings he played that year with a bad shoulder injury.  Still, the steadily rising catcher’s ERA and runs per game ERA are not encouraging.

Molina, on the other hand, seems to be improving with age.  2008 was a particularly rough season for Molina as he started 100 games for the first time in his career, his previous high being 78 in 2006 for the Angels.  Molina has performed well behind the plate when it comes to receiving and has obviously posted better numbers than Posada.

So let’s assume that Molina is a bit better than Posada when it comes to calling games.  Let’s get a look at their performances with Burnett:

Split G PA AB R H HR SB CS BB SO SO/BB BA OBP SLG
Jorge Posada 16 434 382 58 103 13 13 8 46 79 1.72 .270 .353 .421
Jose Molina 11 288 253 26 56 7 7 2 29 77 2.66 .221 .307 .352
Francisco Cervelli 2 56 49 2 10 1 0 1 6 15 2.5 .204 .304 .327

Obviously, Posada has fared the worst of the three catchers Burnett has thrown to this season.  Cervelli seems to have been very good with Burnett and is probably equal the bat to Molina at this stage, but he’s probably a bit too inexperienced to start a postseason game considering he began the 2009 season in AA.  What we saw in Molina’s and Posada’s catcher’s ERAs over the last four seasons seems to play out here as well.

Has that translated to AJ Burnett?

Let’s take a look at one of Burnett’s better streaks from this past summer and the catchers that caught him:

Date Catcher Opp Rslt Dec IP H R ER BB SO HR Pit Str
14-Jun Cervelli NYM W,15-0 W(5-3) 7 4 0 0 4 8 0 111 66
20-Jun Posada FLA L,1-2 L(5-4) 6.1 5 2 1 3 8 1 98 59
27-Jun Posada NYM W,5-0 W(6-4) 7 1 0 0 3 10 0 108 64
3-Jul Cervelli TOR W,4-2 W(7-4) 7 6 2 2 2 7 1 112 68
8-Jul Posada MIN W,4-3 W(8-4) 6.1 7 2 2 4 2 0 100 59
17-Jul Posada DET W,5-3 ND 6 6 3 3 5 1 1 104 57
22-Jul Posada BAL W,6-4 W(9-4) 7 6 2 2 3 6 0 104 68
27-Jul Posada TBR W,11-4 W(10-4) 7 2 1 0 2 5 0 114 69

Over the course of six starts with Jorge Posada catching, Burnett threw 39.2 innings, allowing 8 earned runs for a 1.80 ERA.  His walk rate per nine innings was a little above his season average (4.5 versus 4.2) and his strikeouts per nine innings were a little lower than his season average (7.3 versus 8.5).  Those variances are not insignificant, but neither is the 3 home runs given up over that span, which is a pretty small number.

This again raises the question: how do we judge the effectiveness during this eight game span in which Posada caught six of those games?  Did Burnett pitch well in spite of Jorge Posada catching him?

It’s difficult to wrap my head around exactly why Burnett could have gone on such a good streak with Posada catching and yet, the public consensus is that he can’t throw to him.  Not appearing on this chart is the 7.2 shutout innings Burnett threw against the Red Sox August 7th with, yes, Jorge Posada behind the plate.  By most accounts, Jorge and Burnett had a pretty good summer together that was spoiled by a few bad starts in late August and early September.

And about those bad starts with Posada…  Take a look at Burnett’s two starts against Baltimore in September:

Catcher Date Opp Rslt Inngs Dec IP H R ER BB SO HR
Posada 1-Sep BAL W,9-6 GS-6 ND 5.1 11 6 6 2 2 2
Molina 12-Sep BAL L,3-7 GS-7 L(11-9) 7 7 6 6 2 4 2

The line for Posada is a little bit worse than Molina’s because of the hits and 1.2 innings less, but neither catcher was very helpful against Baltimore.

The verdict?  It seems that pulling Posada from Burnett for the last month of the season was a rash decision on Girardi’s part, assuming  no clubhouse issues that we are not aware of.  Burnett was probably working through another of his rough patches and the decision was made to pull Posada away, giving Molina a chance to catch Burnett during a good phase.  A backup catcher needs to start at some point and most teams will assign the backup to the pitcher that is most comfortable with him.  That may be the case here.

Still, Girardi may have done the Yankees and Posada a disservice by not getting Posada a few starts behind the plate for the Yankees number two starter, a situation that significantly weakens their lineup during the playoffs when Burnett starts.  It’s probably too late to right that wrong now.


Tags: A.J. Burnett, Joe Girardi, Jorge Posada, Jose Molina

1 Comment

  1. Alia QQ says:

    after reading this assessment of posada and molina working with burnet also ofter watching most of regular season games where i witness these games occur i think the reason joe Girardi let burnet pitch to molina instead of posada is because of the rattle off periods of dominance and fall off that scott ham mention about. when burnet is on he is very dangerous and dominant pitcher and have the ability to pitch efficiently to any catcher but when he is off his personality at times clashes with posada. and to be cautious considering is burnet first postseason game Girardi want to be extra careful and give burnet all the comfort he need. and as a Yankee fan i don’t have any problem with that because the most important thing about any game we play is the Win. whatever to get it.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.