tamoxifeno portugal wellbutrin stop working nursing implications for allopurinol prednisone pti drug classification of wellbutrin can tetracycline make you lose weight symptoms of pregnancy while on clomid que es lamisil tablets en espanol synthroid eating calcium what are the side effects from taking nexium trazodone prices walgreens spironolactone with proscar nexium or nekium in india seroquel used sleep disorders viagra cialis over the counter mexico can you take advil with nexium precio dostinex sin receta lopressor lactation finasteride 5 mg cause dred shed in women women does paxil alter the efects of cialas how many milligrams of lexapro can you take augmentin dose per 25 kg sildenafil o tadalafil cual es mejor metronidazole liquid shelf life proscar wypadanie wlos?w miglior sito cialis on line obat paten yang berisi amoxicillin can you take unisom while taking zoloft obat suntik lasix recommend kamagra uk supplier paypal ventolin bertibarots reviews cipro medievale does prednisone lower white blood cell count what is a typical dose of cialis coming off zoloft while pregnant medicamentos singulair baby opiniones finasteride wellbutrin strange side effects low dose accutane while on cycle remeron and paxil ventolin toddler side effects ethinyl estradiol menopause drug reactions with azithromycin dapoxetine sildenafil combination in india ciprofloxacin bei adnexitis amoxicillin qid metformin help pcos nortriptyline starting dose manufacturers of metronidazole in india cual es el precio del orlistat ivermectina laboratorio genfar mode of action of tetracycline augmentin sciroppo torrinomedica what is septra suspension used for augmentin compresse gatto para que sirva la pastilla benicar can i take hcg while on zoloft para que sirve el medicamento dutasteride azithromycin take after food infections treated by cipro can i take ambien and gabapentin montelukast kastair medicine how much acyclovir for shingles propecia ft chantix and celexa interaction seroquel and tylenol interaction silagra citrate levofloxacin and osteomyelitis cialis interactions carvedilol metronidazole in gum infection overnight delivery metronidazole and amoxicillin singulair para adenoide cipro comprare casa viagra ajuda ansiedade lozol hereisthebestin dosage misoprostol ductus arteriosus revatio mexico does acyclovir help hpv zovirax acyclovir sale can 20mg cialis be broken in half amlodipine baownbeuv uses discount finasteride propecia m?dicaments keflex restavit and lexapro allergic reaction to bactrim after 7 days actos plus metformin side effects is cialis off the internet any good linezolid with alcohol where is propranolol metabolized atenolol health education tamoxifen for libido can you take imitrex and topamax together levitra gelly amlodipine et insuffisance cardiaque lipitor cost buy augmentin global sales abilify macht aggressiv lamisil para hongos de los pies cialis c apsules flagyl et rch levaquin foods to avoid cheapest wholesale kamagra percentuale di gravidanze con clomid bupropion sr review gabapentin what type of drug tim eric celebrex cloridrato de ciprofloxacino levofloxacino septra eye infection took clomid and still not pregnant kamagra jelly official website kamagra gel duzina dejstva no rx furosemide 40 mg 1000 tablets cymbalta side weight loss ketoconazole bacteria is tamoxifen harmful celebrex 200mg capsules dosage what should i be paying for my cialis prescription buy a small quantity of viagra online how often do u take amoxicillin acyclovir na recepte imdur and levitra prohormony clomid doxycycline analysis is viagra worth it zithromax us pharmacy no prescription reichamox amoxicillin cialis levetra levothyroxine 37.5 mcg what is the success rate of clomid hcg shot and iui what happens when you drink alcohol on flagyl cialis gegen hohen blutdruck synthroid 0.137mg cialis analogue componente de lisinopril metformin feeling sick trimspa diet pills viagra for men in pune allegra sudbury bactrim ds and adderall can levitra assist in prevention of pe azithromycin dang goi bot plavix after aortic valve replacement pra que serve avodart ketoconazole shampoo mechanism of action orlistat comprare online cialis 5 mg yahoo cymbalta cuando empieza a hacer efecto fluconazole usp 35 monograph zofran and flu augmentin hypokalemia cymbalta horrible drug ondansetron odt 4mg tablet what is the cost of tadalafil tablets in india si perdoret kamagra oral jelly twins with clomid dosage ciprofloxacina collirio gabapentin dosage neuralgia propranolol msa porque la metformina adelgaza levitra viagra compared metformin non insulin resistant maximum dose for nexium vibramycin howdotofound for sale neurontin and falls cipro and muscle and joint pain hoe viagra ontdekt cymbalta commercial dog breed what does the medicine flagyl hypogonadism propecia cyproheptadine cats itchy skin dosage deltasone eciwlcodkedefe discount viagra online with best price ciprofloxacino dias tratamiento wirkung von levitra 20mg clomid iui experiences isotretinoin guercmorteo reviews azithromycin over the counter for kids buy lisinopril 5mg levaquin meals zyprexa fda dose ciprofloxacin in pregnancy is it safe ciprofloxacino se puede usar en ni?os weaning off zoloft safely atenolol prati donaduzzi bula proscar prix buy viagra without prescription chennai can amitriptyline effect sperm paroxetine apothecon nexium 40 mg ne icin kullanilir levitra tuzla cuanto cuesta las misoprostol clomid in male hypogonadism montelukast generic 10 mg side effects ciprofloxacino pre?o rj stent clopidogrel fluconazole pregnancy class can i stop lexapro after two weeks aciclovir tempo de acao adrenal gland function and prednisone cara guna cytotec orlistat weight loss reviews india ciproxin prijs prednisone 40 mg and alcohol cipro cure stds wiki doxycycline hydrochloride where can i buy viagra in hong kong cytotec cuantos meses puedo tomar tomo isotretinoina y estoy embarazada metronidazole antibiotik golongan apa diarrhee et flagyl plavix 75mg generico is it safe to take fish oil while on accutane liquid augmentin expiration levitra jual klang can propranolol cause water retention lexapro increased appetite inhalation mit ventolin amoxicillin dosing for toddlers patient assistance program for maxalt buspirone peak plasma safe dosage zoloft during pregnancy chloramphenicol capsules for sinus can bactrim aggravate h. pylori can i take amoxicillin and aleve together reductil diet pills philippines price when your on viagra dark urine taking metronidazole cipro 500 paten how to stop daily cialis to flomax lasix 40 mg dosage dogs baclofen for esophageal spasm lipitor levaxin cialis online fiable cephalexin suspension package insert clomiphene with testosterone gabapentin lasik drug classification for erythromycin periactin ingredients in suspension most effective dosage of acyclovir atenolol tingling head olanzapina zyprexa efeitos secundarios linezolid iv price in turkey which shop can i go to in south africa and buy kamagra il cialis fa male ai reni inderalici 40 precio fluconazole time to work how to get off 40 mg of prednisone side effects canadian pharmacy cialis 2.5 mf buy cialis in usa addictive potential of quetiapine para que sirve ziverone aciclovir spironolactone and birth defects cheapest zovirax form canada zoloft insufficienza renale synthroid dosage .300 viagra laws in the uk stanozolol viagra viagra bagi kesehatan does prednisone weaken immune system kamagra dolor de cabeza comprar viagra en los angeles does glucophage cure pcos prednisone and blood donation does disulfiram work immediately azithromycin pharmacological class lasix para retencion de liquidos tamoxifeno perder grasa le tamoxifene fait grossir does lisinopril cause sleep apnea carvedilol viagra can nexium be given to dogs prednisone toddler sleep otc alternative to viagra levothyroxine neck pain paxil and canker sores tamsulosin interaction with other drugs viagra urban dictionary metformin abz 1000 mg clomid for high fsh buy levitra in dubai plavix 75 mg in france estradiol activity best over the counter equivalent to viagra metoprolol overdose antidote levitra espermatozoides accutane treat scars synthroid expiration date cialis ratiopharn taking mylanta with nexium estrace birth defects flagyl during third trimester nivel normal de estradiol en fase folicular viagra and lung disease gabapentin zuzahlungsfrei celexa forever isotretinoin geschwollene lippen ketoconazole single dose synthroid classification drugs how to synthesise viagra cfids neurontin do we need prescription for propecia bupropion side effects in adults amlodipine 10 mg 209 doxycycline shortage price gouging bupropion hplc assay aripiprazole polymorphic forms accutane day 121 diltiazem cd 300 mg abilify 5 mg engorda viagra make more ejaculation cipro penicillin drug dangers of nexium historia del viagra viagra naturale marocco viagra cuanto sale femara als nakuur do you cum when you are on viagra paroxetine bijwerkingen bijsluiter how long after eating for viagra test prop and proscar costo viagra farmacia in italia does cialis 40 mg work better prescription insurance that covers cialis antidepressant medications and side effects erythromycin as motility agent efficacia del viagra generico endokarditisprophylaxe amoxicillin hydrochlorothiazide pcos singulair dose 30mg long term use of acyclovir cream can you take flu medicine with amoxicillin clomid gives me gas topamax hair loss answers where can i buy over the counter viagra no prescription buy septra no prescription liquid clomid and nolva xenical ni una dieta mas how long to wean off escitalopram before pregnancy is it okay for pregnant women to take amoxicillin celebrex and bone healing allegra lounge dubai menu celexa steroids seroquel au besoin fluconazole side effect on menstruation atarax et cystite para que se usa premarin crema wellbutrin side effect depression nexium 40 a cosa serve terbinafine sperm quality nizoral stop hairloss amoxicillin instead of penicillin testosterone finasteride online pharmacy cialis groningen doxycycline treatment for diverticulitis causas do estradiol baixo anafranil h?gt blodtryck antibiotico ciproxin e pillola anticoncezionale how many months can you use clomid get rid clomid headaches taking levaquin for sinus infection why should i not take lipitor bactrim ds and low blood sugar hyperthyroidism caused by thyroxine what is the dosage of synthroid by weight use of spironolactone for acne sub heading no. of orlistat capsules 60mg therapeutic dose quetiapine viagra safe buy over internet synthroid and ethinyl estradiol interactions allopurinol adenuric zovirax 200 mg bijsluiter how long it take to work cialis clomiphene citrate for men low sperm count levothyroxine feeling better zoloft or celexa better disulfiram reaction wikipedia fungsi obat bactrim which is the best viagra levitra gabapentin and peripheral edema prescribing information for zyprexa fda approval of amoxicillin glucophage black can you use doxycycline for birds with dogs cephalexin for genital herpes flagyl ovule pour femme enceinte medicamento orlistat para que sirve klacid czy augmentin put amoxicillin in bottle lexapro sennosc can i take metronidazole for sore throat keflex and kidney transplant doxycycline 20mg canada uk viagra sellers antibiotics for eye side effects for dog can you take zoloft with ritalin can i take benadryl while taking bactrim cialis a skopje ci cipro 55 prednisone efficacy what is zithromax made from nexium and gastric polyps does wellbutrin cause sweating engravidou com clomid flagyl for dogs bad breath cialis 5 mg how work ing long start composition du neurontin inderal mims philippines viagra no orgams cephalexin ok for dogs oxytetracycline neutropenia neurontin and thyroid olanzapine for generalised anxiety disorder esomeprazole magnesium trihydrate description zoloft structure can a woman tell if a man is on viagra azithromycin group b strep neurontin et perte de poids allopurinol wikipedia indonesia viagra bestellen aus der eu prijzen viagra belgie cialis 10 milligrams is zoloft an upper or downer avodart and sleeping tablets medicamento nexium 2.5 generic4all viagra review kamagra fast .co.uk recharger mobicarte carte bleue stability of metronidazole solution tim wood allegra network prednisone and infants kamagra im laden is ketoconazole good for ringworm metformin side effects pancreas levitra side effects arrhythmia how soon will nexium work trotz tamoxifen schwanger how many doses of clomid before pregnancy paxil side effects anxiety disorder clopidogrel serotonin ampicillin untuk keputihan dapoxetine and cialis etinilestradiol desogestrel vademecum can i have multiple erections with levitra dosage for azithromycin for ear infection prozac versus lexapro depression prednisone in dental treatment wikipedia olanzapine bupropion fluoxetine weight loss how long for finasteride to leave the system carvedilol and hydrochlorothiazide can you take azithromycin with coricidin amitriptyline 10mg for migraines foods high in potassium spironolactone what happens if you miss a dose of celexa cialis and vision effects tom kaulitz viagra overdose rizatriptan benzoate drug interactions advantages of seroquel xr mi nitric oxide and viagra vardenafil hydrochloride manufacturer cephalexin affect breast milk posso tomar dostinex e continuar amamentando erectile dysfunction oral gel cialis diario eli lilly metoprolol 100 wirkstoff lexapro when is the best time to take para que es neotrex isotretinoina does ivermectin kill ear mites in rabbits compare viagra prices cvs walgreens fexofenadine 30 mg tablets achat anafranil 25 cialis 5 mg buy online haarausfall bei einnahme von femara clomid price in sa prednisone side effects temporal arteritis can amoxicillin cure gum abscess generic flagyl online buy buy viagra lloyds chemist sukhumvit kamagra opinions from people on flagyl cream for bv will cytotec start labor how to best use of cialis pid doxycycline metronidazole ciprodex dog ear infection viagra ed infarto estradiol on saame days as clomid common adverse effects of propranolol losing hair on tamoxifen ampicillin beta lactamase resistant what can amoxicillin do clinical guideline for cytotec induction of abortion zithromax genital mycoplasma viagra men before and after safe place to buy viagra without a prescription lamisil at cream doesn t work robitussin dm synthroid find viagra boyfriend propranolol and levothyroxine bactrim for bowel infection erythromycin gastroparesis side effects

Melky or Gardner?

Featured — By Scott Ham on December 11, 2009 2:26 pm

Now that Curtis Granderson is a Yankee, Brett Gardner’s name is popping up.  ESPN’s Trade Rumors:

The Curtis Granderson deal seems to have made Brett Gardner a more valuable commodity.

Gardner became expendable in New York once Granderson was acquired in a three-team deal, and the latest team to make an inquiry is the Chicago White Sox. The Sun-Times says today that White Sox GM Ken Williams views Gardner as a reasonably-priced option in center field.

Competition for Gardner could come from another team in the AL Central. ESPN.com’s Jayson Stark tweeted Wednesday night that the Kansas City Royals have inquired about Gardner.

The Royals are in the market for a center fielder since free agent Coco Crisp is expected to sign elsewhere.

Sure, Gardner is a reasonably priced option for the White Sox and Kansas City.  His service time is low which makes him cheap and under team for control (I believe) for another two years.

As a matter of fact, he’s just the type of player that the Yankees could use as a backup outfielder.  Jamie Hoffman, recently acquired via the Nats from the Dodgers in the rule 5 draft will also be vying for that role once he’s completed his subterfuge against Johnny Damon.

It’s nice that teams are looking at Gardner but my question is, if the White Sox think he can start in centerfield, why would the Yankees not want him as backup?  In my mind, Melky Cabrera is the one the Yankees should be shopping.

Cabrera is a year older than Gardner but has never shown the type of plate discipline that Gardner has in the minors.  Gardner is the superior centerfielder and obviously has the better speed of the two, despite Gardner’s inability to actually utilize that speed in the playoffs.

Also, Gardner will be cheaper for longer.  That may sound like a silly argument for the Yankees, but they need cheap young talent just like everyone else.  Consider 2009, where the Yankees ranked 25th out of 30 clubs in percentage of their payroll devoted to their bullpen.  Consider also that of that $22.5 million, $15 million of it was devoted to Mariano Rivera. The Cincinnati Reds, with a $71.5 million payroll, spent $20.8 million on their bullpen, just $1.7 million less than the Yankees, whose payroll was almost three times that of the Reds ($206.8 million versus $71.5 million).

* As a side note, the Yankees also ranked 28th in percentage of salary devoted to pitching even with the big money devoted to CC Sabathia and AJ Burnett.  The entire chart as provided by Cot’s Baseball Contracts looks like this:

Club Payroll Pos. Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Atlanta $97,692,834 33.96% 30 66.04% 1
Cincinnati $71,458,500 38.56% 29 61.44% 2
Arizona $72,475,000 45.43% 28 54.57% 3
San Diego $42,746,653 47.19% 27 52.81% 4
Texas $76,255,380 48.46% 26 51.54% 5
NY Mets $139,602,235 49.60% 25 50.40% 6
San Francisco $88,777,106 49.79% 24 50.21% 7
Philadelphia $128,587,380 50.31% 23 49.69% 8
Colorado $74,730,533 51.36% 22 48.64% 9
Cleveland $81,325,900 51.67% 21 48.33% 10
Chicago Sox $98,268,500 51.86% 20 48.14% 11
Kansas City $76,446,243 52.02% 19 47.98% 12
Seattle $99,346,926 52.14% 18 47.86% 13
Toronto $80,993,657 53.05% 17 46.95% 14
Milwaukee $64,560,861 53.59% 16 46.41% 15
Chicago Cubs $137,795,612 53.90% 15 46.10% 16
St. Louis $94,498,500 55.91% 14 44.09% 17
Tampa Bay $64,996,368 56.08% 13 43.92% 18
LA Angels $116,709,000 57.92% 12 42.08% 19
Houston $104,785,000 59.54% 11 40.46% 20
Boston $122,624,689 60.32% 10 39.68% 21
LA Dodgers $109,176,603 61.74% 9 38.26% 22
Detroit $129,598,000 62.21% 8 37.79% 23
Pittsburgh $52,268,000 63.25% 7 36.75% 24
Baltimore $76,169,792 66.16% 6 33.84% 25
Florida $35,458,951 67.82% 5 32.18% 26
Minnesota $67,899,267 68.19% 4 31.81% 27
NY Yankees $206,811,689 68.46% 3 31.54% 28
Oakland $62,396,066 79.53% 2 20.47% 29
Washington $61,455,049 80.22% 1 19.76% 30
Club Payroll Pos Players Rk Pitchers Rk

Clearly, the Yankees have found some benefit to going cheaper in their bullpen, utilizing the arms within their own system, or picking up guys like Brian Bruney off the scrap heap to provide innings when needed.  The rest of the league seems to be picking up on this.  Well, seems to, anyway.

The point is, even with an inflated budget, you have to find the most appropriate places within your roster to apply cheap, young talent.  For the Yankees, that place has been the bullpen and the bench.  The bench will get a bit cheaper this year when Francisco Cervelli likely takes over the backup catcher position from Jose Molina.  It’s possible that Ramiro Pena could be a backup infielder as well depending on what the front office feels they can get out of Pena in 2010 and beyond.

Given the Brett Gardner has proven at least equally valuable as Melky Cabrera, has more time under team control and is a better defensive outfielder, there’s little reason to trade him over Cabrera.  The return for Gardner may be a little better, but we’re talking a negligible difference in return, one that certainly can be outweighed by the usefulness and flexibility of Gardner.

The only major difference between the two players is that Gardner is left-handed while Melky is a switch hitter.  Both hitters hit worse against lefties which elevated neither over the other when considering a platoon partner with Curtis Granderson.

Club Payroll Pos. Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Atlanta $97,692,834 33.96% 30 66.04% 1
Cincinnati $71,458,500 38.56% 29 61.44% 2
Arizona $72,475,000 45.43% 28 54.57% 3
San Diego $42,746,653 47.19% 27 52.81% 4
Texas $76,255,380 48.46% 26 51.54% 5
NY Mets $139,602,235 49.60% 25 50.40% 6
San Francisco $88,777,106 49.79% 24 50.21% 7
Philadelphia $128,587,380 50.31% 23 49.69% 8
Colorado $74,730,533 51.36% 22 48.64% 9
Cleveland $81,325,900 51.67% 21 48.33% 10
Chicago Sox $98,268,500 51.86% 20 48.14% 11
Kansas City $76,446,243 52.02% 19 47.98% 12
Seattle $99,346,926 52.14% 18 47.86% 13
Toronto $80,993,657 53.05% 17 46.95% 14
Milwaukee $64,560,861 53.59% 16 46.41% 15
Chicago Cubs $137,795,612 53.90% 15 46.10% 16
St. Louis $94,498,500 55.91% 14 44.09% 17
Tampa Bay $64,996,368 56.08% 13 43.92% 18
LA Angels $116,709,000 57.92% 12 42.08% 19
Houston $104,785,000 59.54% 11 40.46% 20
Boston $122,624,689 60.32% 10 39.68% 21
LA Dodgers $109,176,603 61.74% 9 38.26% 22
Detroit $129,598,000 62.21% 8 37.79% 23
Pittsburgh $52,268,000 63.25% 7 36.75% 24
Baltimore $76,169,792 66.16% 6 33.84% 25
Florida $35,458,951 67.82% 5 32.18% 26
Minnesota $67,899,267 68.19% 4 31.81% 27
NY Yankees $206,811,689 68.46% 3 31.54% 28
Oakland $62,396,066 79.53% 2 20.47% 29
Washington $61,455,049 80.22% 1 19.76% 30
Club Payroll Pos Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Tags: Brett Gardner, Brian Bruney, Chicago White Sox, Coco Crisp, Curtis Granderson, Francisco Cervelli, Jamie Hoffman, Jayson Stark, Johnny Damon, Jose Molina, Kansas City Royals, Ken Williams, Mariano Rivera, Melky Cabrera, Ramiro Pena

4 Comments

  1. Greg F. says:

    I would definitely hold on to Gardner. He is under team control for another five seasons and his defense is significantly better than the Melk Man’s.

  2. I say hold on to both. Melky Cabrera and Brett Gardner are not great but they have something to offer to the Yankees especially in the future. The Yankees don’t need to trade their outfield players just because they are overloaded. One or two them can go back to the farm. They are still young and Damon can’t play forever (that is if he signs with the Yankees).

    The Yankees should stick with this and be conservative. It’s pitching that they need. They should aggressively look for another arm for their starting rotation or their bullpen.

  3. Scott Ham says:

    I think the only upside you can expect from either player is possibly a better OBP from Gardner with more playing time, and even then I’m not sure he’ll reach the .400 levels he did in the minors. Melky has just about peaked. He never hit for power in the minors and he’s unlikely to suddenly develop it now.

    I’m not sure what Melky’s options are, but he’s close to having none. He has four full seasons and a cup of coffee year so, at best, this is his last year with an option. Gardner should have another year or two, I believe.

    I’m not sure it matters, though. With Granderson aboard, both guys are bench players. Neither has the kind of offense you can just bury in a corner outfield spot and neither are likely to be more valuable then they are right now. Drop Melky down to part time status and he’s going to look like an even worse player.

    When/if Damon signs or the Yankees get their hands on a left fielder, I think one of the two will be traded and it’s the right move.

  4. balistes says:

    gardner for a quality reliever sounds like a good deal to me. everyone on the yankee blogs always sings his praises and puts melky down but gardner just can’t hit and therefore get on base enough to make his speed into a real weapon (except, of course, as a pinch runner).

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.