9 teaspoons to tablespoons how to lower pulse rate eternal spirit beauty usp propylene glycol walmart a ketoglutarate dehydrogenase cortisone shot in shoulder to and fro murmur humerus surgical neck blue dye 1 allergy head and shoulders cowash nerves in your legs pinworms otc treatment treatment of diverticulitis symptom of herniated disc rheumatoid arthritis in knees pictures of what pills help hair growth otc anesthetic cream what causes drainage promethazine over the counter kidney drain bag thyroid disorders treatment tick bite treatment for humans lexapro and lamictal luteinizing hormone releasing hormone safe drugs online 44403 yellow pill dietary fiber supplements rectal temperature conversion sensitivity to light symptoms antimalarial drugs lupus what is chaste tree increased cervical mucus panrosa hand soap white percocet 30 mg ingredients in aspartame how to heal a bruised toe makena shot reviews what does neupogen do blues pills drug dexamethasone adverse effects what is an abcessed tooth resection of bladder tumor what causes swollen lips heart medications for afib picture of wrist side effects of anti malaria medication ms tooth pain arms and hands probability of getting pregnant from precum does brain cancer spread dopamine receptor agonists can you get the mumps twice ears ringing loudly what can cause headaches everyday crackling sound in head ofloxacin otic solution 0.3 does mirena affect breastfeeding pain in the penis prezcobix side effects sex pills for men viagra uti for men symptoms new mole on chest anti eczema cream detox pain killers konsyl original natural fiber supplement prescription sleeping pills for insomnia frequent urination bladder pain can you get high off seroquel shot to stop menstrual bleeding stomach pain for a week synthroid food interactions greenbrier international inc dollar tree stores plan b and period late magnesium and ibs what is bilberry good for silymarin milk thistle benefits laparoscopic surgery for ovarian cyst removal female abdominal hernia passion flower extract what causes frequent migraines anxiety attack pass out levonorgestrel birth control pill small round orange pill r 127 uses of sodium acetate best monophasic birth control pill sodium hydrogen carbonate in water typical wholesale discount when to use a vaporizer vitamin d2 50000 crystalline glucosamine sulfate two days late negative pregnancy test 8 week abortion high pitched ringing in ear is pepto bismol for diarrhea complex b 100 aleve d sinus and cold dosage monday morning sex my kid swallowed a dime cor 136 pill 1mg folic acid small red blotches on face pcos hair thinning sore breasts no period infliximab infusion protocol oxy-ir 5mg xanax sleep aid flu contagious timeline acute psychotic disorder black toe fungus treatment aspartame and breastfeeding side effects of coq10 ubiquinol prednisone weaning off sodium withdrawal symptoms kadcyla prescribing information humalog vs novolog cost ovarian cyst causing pregnancy symptoms chemo for liver cancer stage 4 how to take a babys temperature is there vitamin k in bananas synonym for sediment keflex for strep taxanes side effects hair loss gel ri-1 patellar tendon treatment treatment for mild copd wild yam dioscorea villosa plectranthus barbatus plant can you take tylenol and benadryl cortisone injection and breastfeeding antibiotic for scarlet fever guillain barre pain brain cancer cures sunscreen and pregnancy magnesium and zinc supplement side effects of spice prescription for walking pneumonia bausch and lomb areds pain front right abdomen lamotrigine bipolar ii triple c withdrawal contrave before and after pictures clonazepam and adderall simethicone 80 mg cramp in the foot right atrium definition toes turn blue multaq mechanism of action dosage vitamin b12 what is syphilis symptoms why am i hurting normal arm x ray what is hemangioma of the liver clinical depression? sarsaparilla root health benefits alcohol and bloody stool can panic attacks cause memory loss what do tumors feel like neck what does noni juice taste like soft snacks to eat sunburn like rash on face puncture wound infection antibiotics uses for isopropyl alcohol toddler smashed finger half life sucks what works best for hemorrhoids tetracaine eye drops what is ziac used for psoriasis on back before meal abbreviation frontline dosage chart what is prednisone 20mg used for celebrex 400 mg twice daily vitamins cause constipation type 1 diabetes is caused by best way to use heroin cramping after d&c broken middle toe bulging disc relief pink discharge before period does testosterone work burning thigh pain meralgia paresthetica drug for inflammation uses for sweet almond oil pt inr range normal doxycycline 100mg chlamydia swollen black eye how long does spotting last ingredients in tiger balm severe strep throat best medicine for foot fungus trigeminal neuralgia attack skin around fingernails early symptoms of leukemia how long for accutane to work po sum on venlafaxine dose range can mirena cause yeast infection club drugs street names pics of yeast infection discharge how do you treat an ulcer upsher smith laboratories inc breast milk curdled spit up symptoms of heat stoke prednisone vs naproxen bump inside ear canal enlarged prostate treatments lorcet vs lortab headache in left eye sharp pain in boob i keep dry heaving brown spotting a week before period sulfasalazine vs mesalamine ketamine fda approval warfarin and vitamin k how to avoid scabies cacao powder side effects sertraline 75 mg asperger syndrome causes bladder falling out symptoms heart slows down leaking amniotic fluid at 37 weeks drug testing while pregnant incentive spirometer directions chlamydia orally transmitted symtoms of ringworm ruptured colon symptoms no period mirena iud ferrous sulfate oral optimmune ophthalmic ointment for dogs wellbutrin and vyvanse weight loss what causes lactose intolerance in adults withdrawal bleeding birth control other names for sodium miconazole nitrate 2 powder effects of rabies in humans diverticulitis list of foods to avoid brown recluse arizona acetaminophen generic name gastritis in infants rogaine for men reviews clinical signs of anemia ethanol urine test marijuana hair follicle sudden frequent heartburn new ppi drug therapeutic class of drugs rib cage pain uterus bleeding after menopause what is forgetfulness diets pills that work fast what is triphasic birth control how to use the female condom how to use qcarbo barley grass juice benefits allergic reaction to shingles vaccine sharp pain right side abdomen allergic reaction to benadryl symptoms vant hoff equation american crew ingredients wart in lip blood pressure medicine hydro reduce stomach gas zinc oxide benefits headache same spot one side of face numb how to decrease edema fungal scalp infection pictures cialis doesnt work hand foot and mouth in toddlers lump in knee oval peach pill lactated ringers classification synalar simple para que sirve side effects of antiarrhythmics find me a pad pulp fiction foot massage scene vagina itches and burns 27 27 27 side effects of antibiotic how long until proactive works cat licked flea medicine symptoms of allergic reaction to medication what is pure molly made of opdivo for lung cancer fibula fracture recovery time how to make opium at home how to choose a wheelchair dizzy nausea headache fatigue when you have a fever medications for agoraphobia iodide to iodine 30 mls equals how many tablespoons max xanax dosage fungal infection on the skin list of cholesterol lowering medications photos of medications costco nicotine gum kid knee pain what is bladder prolapse safe diet pills fda approved what does no. stand for lamictal and dizziness tiger balm uses tendon sprain in foot long term side effects of doxycycline vicodin for sore throat best cream for seborrheic dermatitis false negative home pregnancy test severe headache for a week me duele la espalda baja white spot on cornea can you sunburn your eyeballs what doctor can prescribe xanax side effects of azt where to buy estrogen cream does bronchitis cause shortness of breath where to buy sski drops what causes vaginal warts rynex dm liquid zinc dosage for men trinessa and weight gain thyroid surgery removal l-carnitine complex pictures of tooth abscess crest baking soda and peroxide does chlamydia have a cure withdrawal from effexor xr how long symptoms of sugar overdose bone resorption definition mineral oil laxative dose stress induced amenorrhea what causes soft stools in adults delsym 12 hour protect heels from blisters yellow vomit child eli lilly mexico trazodone and xanax what is metoclopram used for greenish black stool in adults l carnitine 1500 mg reviews swelling after root canal treatment avon 24 hour deodorant red skin on face what is a cerumen hard bump under skin on finger ppd tb skin test what is empirical treatment walmart 4 dollar prescription list 2016 piperacillin/tazobactam pneumonia vaccine every 5 years difference between peppermint oil and extract fractured skull mask mrsa breast infection external hemorrhoid removal recovery treatment of post concussion syndrome acidophilus for vaginal health swollen eye socket ephedra plants for sale how to numb your arm what causes intrauterine scarring folic acid 5mg daily what is kraton petite and pregnant top 200 drug calming collar for cats black market prescription drugs uses for botox codeine acetaminophen syrup kenalog injections for alopecia pt vs nursing 500 pound patient testosterone shot cost using aloe vera how does cystic acne start bronchitis recovery time left thumb is numb plugging suboxone strips gabapentin with hydrocodone does kelly services drug test simply saline nasal james river psychotherapy overdose symptoms of oxycodone gpi a325 street value discoloration upper lip tilt table test risks how often can you take flonase tear in back muscle natural ed med otc ed pills bitter orange plant tendonitis in shoulder blade nausea headache blurred vision how to cut coke how fast does gas x work ear wont stop ringing shots for osteoarthritis treatment panic disorder half life of atropine lump testicle pain my stomach is sore what antibiotic treats strep throat citrate of magnesium liquid crest for sensitive teeth pain reduction techniques prochlorperazine for anxiety theraflu sugar free abnormal kidney test fever and diarrhea in toddler flu skin sensitivity who makes medicine upper arm muscle pain relief tunnel vision synonym sprintec birth control white pills strep throat amoxicillin dose cure for seborrheic dermatitis brown discharge 3 weeks after period side effects milk thistle headache from concussion lung infection treatment erythromycin ophth oint cancer spread to brain motion sickness patches over the counter how to drink water without swallowing zithromax sinus infection weight and hypertension right side hurts after drinking tendons in knee definition of insensible right eye tear dry skin on newborns face anti-d antibody baking soda gout mayo clinic cytotec abortion pill what is doxazosin for what is charcoal good for can urgent care prescribe sun damage skin care severe croup treatment gout during pregnancy enoxaparin in pregnancy small white pill rx 526 muscle pain in lower leg symptons of hernia what causes a barrel chest calcium needed during pregnancy can you shoot adderall xr can swollen lymph nodes cause pain sinus infection headache afib heart beat herniated disc pregnancy how are fevers caused side effects of suboxin how common are pilonidal cysts second degree burns healing stages naloxone and naltrexone celexa 20 mg and alcohol 30 mg codeine vs oxycodone left side of body hurts inner ear causing dizziness treatment fowl pox vaccine for chickens how to take keflex price of claritin d how is albinism treated what does abscess tooth mean atovaquone-proguanil side effects how to make ur ear pop list of oral contraceptives robitussin allergy cough syrup fractured toe vs broken toe cost of rogaine sore throats and allergies calcium magnesium zinc supplement side effects chronic motor tic disorder snri vs ssri for anxiety depo-provera injection measles chicken pox ibuprofen ib vs ibuprofen treatment for hives on face what is papilloma bovi sera goats half cup blueberries calories is heroin an agonist or antagonist buy drugs online without prescription anti inflammatory nsaids side effects of multivitamin yeast infection corners of mouth ways to stop menstrual bleeding ergocalciferol 50000 units capsule canine dosage for benadryl eastern equine encephalitis symptoms iud vs depo squamous cell carcinoma smoking what is your axilla femoral lymph node swollen how to numb skin at home does pseudoephedrine raise blood pressure tamoxifen and anxiety ml to once what is dhea 25 skin bumps on neck

Melky or Gardner?

Featured — By Scott Ham on December 11, 2009 2:26 pm

Now that Curtis Granderson is a Yankee, Brett Gardner’s name is popping up.  ESPN’s Trade Rumors:

The Curtis Granderson deal seems to have made Brett Gardner a more valuable commodity.

Gardner became expendable in New York once Granderson was acquired in a three-team deal, and the latest team to make an inquiry is the Chicago White Sox. The Sun-Times says today that White Sox GM Ken Williams views Gardner as a reasonably-priced option in center field.

Competition for Gardner could come from another team in the AL Central. ESPN.com’s Jayson Stark tweeted Wednesday night that the Kansas City Royals have inquired about Gardner.

The Royals are in the market for a center fielder since free agent Coco Crisp is expected to sign elsewhere.

Sure, Gardner is a reasonably priced option for the White Sox and Kansas City.  His service time is low which makes him cheap and under team for control (I believe) for another two years.

As a matter of fact, he’s just the type of player that the Yankees could use as a backup outfielder.  Jamie Hoffman, recently acquired via the Nats from the Dodgers in the rule 5 draft will also be vying for that role once he’s completed his subterfuge against Johnny Damon.

It’s nice that teams are looking at Gardner but my question is, if the White Sox think he can start in centerfield, why would the Yankees not want him as backup?  In my mind, Melky Cabrera is the one the Yankees should be shopping.

Cabrera is a year older than Gardner but has never shown the type of plate discipline that Gardner has in the minors.  Gardner is the superior centerfielder and obviously has the better speed of the two, despite Gardner’s inability to actually utilize that speed in the playoffs.

Also, Gardner will be cheaper for longer.  That may sound like a silly argument for the Yankees, but they need cheap young talent just like everyone else.  Consider 2009, where the Yankees ranked 25th out of 30 clubs in percentage of their payroll devoted to their bullpen.  Consider also that of that $22.5 million, $15 million of it was devoted to Mariano Rivera. The Cincinnati Reds, with a $71.5 million payroll, spent $20.8 million on their bullpen, just $1.7 million less than the Yankees, whose payroll was almost three times that of the Reds ($206.8 million versus $71.5 million).

* As a side note, the Yankees also ranked 28th in percentage of salary devoted to pitching even with the big money devoted to CC Sabathia and AJ Burnett.  The entire chart as provided by Cot’s Baseball Contracts looks like this:

Club Payroll Pos. Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Atlanta $97,692,834 33.96% 30 66.04% 1
Cincinnati $71,458,500 38.56% 29 61.44% 2
Arizona $72,475,000 45.43% 28 54.57% 3
San Diego $42,746,653 47.19% 27 52.81% 4
Texas $76,255,380 48.46% 26 51.54% 5
NY Mets $139,602,235 49.60% 25 50.40% 6
San Francisco $88,777,106 49.79% 24 50.21% 7
Philadelphia $128,587,380 50.31% 23 49.69% 8
Colorado $74,730,533 51.36% 22 48.64% 9
Cleveland $81,325,900 51.67% 21 48.33% 10
Chicago Sox $98,268,500 51.86% 20 48.14% 11
Kansas City $76,446,243 52.02% 19 47.98% 12
Seattle $99,346,926 52.14% 18 47.86% 13
Toronto $80,993,657 53.05% 17 46.95% 14
Milwaukee $64,560,861 53.59% 16 46.41% 15
Chicago Cubs $137,795,612 53.90% 15 46.10% 16
St. Louis $94,498,500 55.91% 14 44.09% 17
Tampa Bay $64,996,368 56.08% 13 43.92% 18
LA Angels $116,709,000 57.92% 12 42.08% 19
Houston $104,785,000 59.54% 11 40.46% 20
Boston $122,624,689 60.32% 10 39.68% 21
LA Dodgers $109,176,603 61.74% 9 38.26% 22
Detroit $129,598,000 62.21% 8 37.79% 23
Pittsburgh $52,268,000 63.25% 7 36.75% 24
Baltimore $76,169,792 66.16% 6 33.84% 25
Florida $35,458,951 67.82% 5 32.18% 26
Minnesota $67,899,267 68.19% 4 31.81% 27
NY Yankees $206,811,689 68.46% 3 31.54% 28
Oakland $62,396,066 79.53% 2 20.47% 29
Washington $61,455,049 80.22% 1 19.76% 30
Club Payroll Pos Players Rk Pitchers Rk

Clearly, the Yankees have found some benefit to going cheaper in their bullpen, utilizing the arms within their own system, or picking up guys like Brian Bruney off the scrap heap to provide innings when needed.  The rest of the league seems to be picking up on this.  Well, seems to, anyway.

The point is, even with an inflated budget, you have to find the most appropriate places within your roster to apply cheap, young talent.  For the Yankees, that place has been the bullpen and the bench.  The bench will get a bit cheaper this year when Francisco Cervelli likely takes over the backup catcher position from Jose Molina.  It’s possible that Ramiro Pena could be a backup infielder as well depending on what the front office feels they can get out of Pena in 2010 and beyond.

Given the Brett Gardner has proven at least equally valuable as Melky Cabrera, has more time under team control and is a better defensive outfielder, there’s little reason to trade him over Cabrera.  The return for Gardner may be a little better, but we’re talking a negligible difference in return, one that certainly can be outweighed by the usefulness and flexibility of Gardner.

The only major difference between the two players is that Gardner is left-handed while Melky is a switch hitter.  Both hitters hit worse against lefties which elevated neither over the other when considering a platoon partner with Curtis Granderson.

Club Payroll Pos. Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Atlanta $97,692,834 33.96% 30 66.04% 1
Cincinnati $71,458,500 38.56% 29 61.44% 2
Arizona $72,475,000 45.43% 28 54.57% 3
San Diego $42,746,653 47.19% 27 52.81% 4
Texas $76,255,380 48.46% 26 51.54% 5
NY Mets $139,602,235 49.60% 25 50.40% 6
San Francisco $88,777,106 49.79% 24 50.21% 7
Philadelphia $128,587,380 50.31% 23 49.69% 8
Colorado $74,730,533 51.36% 22 48.64% 9
Cleveland $81,325,900 51.67% 21 48.33% 10
Chicago Sox $98,268,500 51.86% 20 48.14% 11
Kansas City $76,446,243 52.02% 19 47.98% 12
Seattle $99,346,926 52.14% 18 47.86% 13
Toronto $80,993,657 53.05% 17 46.95% 14
Milwaukee $64,560,861 53.59% 16 46.41% 15
Chicago Cubs $137,795,612 53.90% 15 46.10% 16
St. Louis $94,498,500 55.91% 14 44.09% 17
Tampa Bay $64,996,368 56.08% 13 43.92% 18
LA Angels $116,709,000 57.92% 12 42.08% 19
Houston $104,785,000 59.54% 11 40.46% 20
Boston $122,624,689 60.32% 10 39.68% 21
LA Dodgers $109,176,603 61.74% 9 38.26% 22
Detroit $129,598,000 62.21% 8 37.79% 23
Pittsburgh $52,268,000 63.25% 7 36.75% 24
Baltimore $76,169,792 66.16% 6 33.84% 25
Florida $35,458,951 67.82% 5 32.18% 26
Minnesota $67,899,267 68.19% 4 31.81% 27
NY Yankees $206,811,689 68.46% 3 31.54% 28
Oakland $62,396,066 79.53% 2 20.47% 29
Washington $61,455,049 80.22% 1 19.76% 30
Club Payroll Pos Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Tags: Brett Gardner, Brian Bruney, Chicago White Sox, Coco Crisp, Curtis Granderson, Francisco Cervelli, Jamie Hoffman, Jayson Stark, Johnny Damon, Jose Molina, Kansas City Royals, Ken Williams, Mariano Rivera, Melky Cabrera, Ramiro Pena

4 Comments

  1. Greg F. says:

    I would definitely hold on to Gardner. He is under team control for another five seasons and his defense is significantly better than the Melk Man’s.

  2. I say hold on to both. Melky Cabrera and Brett Gardner are not great but they have something to offer to the Yankees especially in the future. The Yankees don’t need to trade their outfield players just because they are overloaded. One or two them can go back to the farm. They are still young and Damon can’t play forever (that is if he signs with the Yankees).

    The Yankees should stick with this and be conservative. It’s pitching that they need. They should aggressively look for another arm for their starting rotation or their bullpen.

  3. Scott Ham says:

    I think the only upside you can expect from either player is possibly a better OBP from Gardner with more playing time, and even then I’m not sure he’ll reach the .400 levels he did in the minors. Melky has just about peaked. He never hit for power in the minors and he’s unlikely to suddenly develop it now.

    I’m not sure what Melky’s options are, but he’s close to having none. He has four full seasons and a cup of coffee year so, at best, this is his last year with an option. Gardner should have another year or two, I believe.

    I’m not sure it matters, though. With Granderson aboard, both guys are bench players. Neither has the kind of offense you can just bury in a corner outfield spot and neither are likely to be more valuable then they are right now. Drop Melky down to part time status and he’s going to look like an even worse player.

    When/if Damon signs or the Yankees get their hands on a left fielder, I think one of the two will be traded and it’s the right move.

  4. balistes says:

    gardner for a quality reliever sounds like a good deal to me. everyone on the yankee blogs always sings his praises and puts melky down but gardner just can’t hit and therefore get on base enough to make his speed into a real weapon (except, of course, as a pinch runner).

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.