amitriptyline cost uk can you buy nizoral shampoo over the counter uk mamabz.com punkfiction.com atorvastatin p q sirve levofloxacin 750 mg used prostatitis how much cialis equals 50mg viagra augmentin bd 1g tablets csipropertyservices.com quetiapine patent expiry australia can i take prednisone for poison ivy cheap esomeprazole cialis 5 mg daily side effects tamsulosin hydrochloride blakesgourmet.com amitriptyline 50 mg tablets side effects avapro how much potasium does it have desogestrel cost coupons for strattera 80g are side effects less on paxil cr vs paxil pil viagra 6800 bactrim dose for cystitis httwp.com glaxosmithkline amoxil 500 clomid online cheap california-employment-lawyers.com generic lexapro prescription muslimdate.com directmobility.co.uk amoxicillin dosage for toothache for 12 years old metronidazole 200 for sinusitis celexa alternatives paxil 40 mg ocd que efectos produce premarin can you get high on strattera 40 mg finasteride 1mg anabol effect hydroxyzine doses get you high muteber.com cerisdieventi.com buy viagra cialis online australia when i can stop using escitalopram 10 mg tablet cialis soft uk how to use clomid as a pct buspirone can it get you high side effects coming off buspar could septra cause the sweats topiramate espanol metronidazole online fastcure uk advantages and disadvantages of metformin for pcos does 4mg prednisone give you energy how to spot fake misoprostol pills metronidazole acne anastrozole price cvs hamilelik paxil viagra pills in adult world pretoria espanol ketoconazole 200 mg farmacias guadalajara misoprostol saltillo upperbe.it emarkination.web5.ict4b.eu can nexium be taken prn synthroid cost propecia generic paypal mirtazapine 22.5mg cflailesi.org wellbutrin hci xl sleepy flagyl use in wound logistic propranolol 20 mg 3 times a day marashthermal.com kamagra 50mg egyptgolftours.com brtop.net when to start clomid ovulation es azithromycin 1g bueno para la balanitis zovirax priceliat is it bad to take clonidine hcl after smoking weed rizatriptan benzoate and valium interaction cytotec 200mg asli uses price and indications of augmentin 625 spacecityparent.com disulfiram pellet farmacias ahumada harga atorvastatin 40 mg caverject and viagra combination ciprofloxacin in treatment acne mildreddeskinsjewelry.com defysiomarkt.nl metronidazole dosing for worms mutien.be what is the next step if clomid doesnt work buscomi.com stopping flomax after kidney stones levothyroxine synthroid side effects itching what is the street value of bupropion street price for buspirone prnc.tv purchase fluconazole 150mg benazepril 40 mg how long it takes to work focva.org posologie flagyl lyme dosing bactrim ds for dog bites cyproheptadine 10 mg viagra generic us pharmacy buy periactin weight gain pills iphone-accessory.cn buy nexium online emedoutlet amaryl 5 van dogs quit taking prednisone how to get rid of furry tongue after metronidazole brand list of tamsulosin with tolterodine danazol tabletta apparel-chic.com drhildaong.com obat jamur nizoral tablet taking benadryl with lexapro and buspar celexa day 9 does homeopathy work with cipro poisening weight loss on trazodone neurontin 800 mg cost at walmart how long will effect to take amoxicillin himox focva.org how much does flomax cost how much is a lethal dose of trazodone md.gradgroup.com locksmithfairfax.us gelernt.net weaning off anti anxiety medication remeron buy provera online canada gandhipucollege.com bupropion il shelf life nolvadex 10 tab are there cases where diflucan doesnt work albuterol inhaler ban tai vietnam iching torsemide buy nolvadex anabolic steroids plavix price in india apo lisinopril reviews i took 600 grams of sertraline zoloft can i take clomid with vitamin e to conceive twins metronidazole pigeons femara 2.5 mg fertility side effects clomid without inducing period can you take benadryl with bactrim ds side effects of cifoprox antibiotic in 5 year old long term side effects bactrim can you take zantac with allegra d 1cialis levitra sales viagra aclovate cream and nizoral cream flagyl 500 mg tab price no tamoxifen breast cancer fotografie-cursus.net dosage of flagyl to stop uti monitoring parameters for metformin can i take lamisil 250 twice a day where can i buy amoxicillin pill identifier metronidazole 500 mg white capsule nizoral shampoo cream uses scalp keratosis yalovadaarsa.com how long until relief from diflucan dickhopper.com im taking 8mg of coumadin albuterol for 7 month old safe albuterol cough syrup in india where to buy kamagra gel in kolkatta golfnewmexico.com THUMBUY.COM fluconazole uses for men can i get off 10mg of olanzapine to 40mg paxil dickhopper.com dosage of mexpharm 15 meloxicam montelukast in philippines clopidogrel prise irbesartan 600 generic zoloft diflucan dosagevitacost augmentin doziranje accommodationmadeasy.com how long does 500 mg of flagyl stay in your system can i gove metronidazole to my dog without food lexapro 20 mg price walmart cytotec cuantas vienen en una caja para que sirve el montelukast sodium 4mg can flagyl work like morning after pills como comprar cytotec en el salvador adalat cost como se usa cytotec de 100 mg where can you buy clomipramine 200mg naprosyn sr 750 mg side effects africanamericanimages.us amoxil 800 csipropertyservices.com gabapentin adverse affect with quetiapine lamisil pastillas 250 mg viagra for men tablet witch price of india naprosyn 500mg gastro resistant toothache can i give my 5 yr old albuterol disabledinafghanistan.com springracinginsights.com lisinopril 10mg buy clonidine patch uses for mental health clomid pregnancy sign pimples hot flashes after ovulation on clomid dosage of bactrim for toddlers mrsa skin infections augmentin duo forte amoxicillin for dog uso del captopril25mg 10mg prozac not enough can you drink alcohol while taking levaquin 500 mg how to make my dog to eat flagyl success rate of clomid after 6 months zynaps.com zofran first trimester safe prednisone pack side effeects levoflaxacin zyvox how to make viagra verapamil price without insurance ketoconazole vs mupirocin defysiomarkt.nl premarin 25 mg vial ciprofloxacin 6 weeks prozac side effects first 2 weeks gabapentin back pain dogs will prednisone work for rosacea trazodone 100mg side effects in dogs blakesgourmet.com gabapentin sleep aid mayo clinic can you eat ice cream after taking amoxicillin kurs-speyer.de emarkination.web5.ict4b.eu dexamethasone 0 5 mg obat apa ya captopril oral solution australia csipropertyservices.com celexa 25mg diflucan candida why would someone take cialis can a12 year old take azithromycin 250mg five days taking nitroglycerin without heart problems is prednisone safe to take for a week without a taper neurontin 500 mg em2nt.net gia thuoc fluconazole capsule can u get pregnant wen adminstering clomid tablets mirtazapine 15 mg australia ciprofloxacin 750 mg once weekly hillsidesanctuary.com accommodationmadeasy.com cheap plavix clopidogrel cipro over the counter spain baclofen, dose, narcolepsy punkfiction.com does phenergan help with stomach virus para q sirve la pastilla priligy en bogota what is esomeprazole with sodium bicarbonate as buffer fehmierduran.com balitoursclub.com terbinafine hydrochloride solution 1 antifungal can metronidazole be given to dogs without food chloramphenicol bula e um antiviral metronidazole 500 viagra professional cheap cost of real levitra mejer aborto de 4 semanas de embarazo von cytotec giardia dogs liver metronidazole cialis brand danazol 50 mg 3 pastillas de misoprostol caducadas can taking valacyclovir hcl 500mg cause dry eyes valley fever in dogs and metronidazole california-employment-lawyers.com MASTERRAFTING.COM cdfeorellana.com cytotec poza rica tab flagyl 400 mg action buy generic cabergoline show me the tablet azithromycin what dose of armour thyroid equals 1mg levothyroxine 75 mg seroquel lifesaverpoolfencesofnevada.com croup 3 year old dosage o albuterol syrup metronidazole nystatin price can flagyl stop diarrhea in dog after one dose zovirax cream buy online batterymedix.com safe to take remeron and ketamine together donde venden misoprostol en monterrey ocd lexapro 15 mg viagra normal dose pamelor and sleep si me tomo una pastilla de 100 de sildenafil acyclovir no prescription online should i take augmentin before or after meal success rate of acyclovir for shingles can azithromycin be purchased over the counter augmentin duo 625 metoprolol labetalol conversion topiramate sales ketoconazole tablets for dogs without prescription propecia and sperm quality cymbalta australia price wellbutrin 150 stopped working after a week how fluconazole works on yeast tab indomethacinsr 75mg hanhvyshop.vn can i take ventilin ingaler while on verapamil when taking fluconazole when does start working does amoxicillin get you high generic mircette reviews punkfiction.com bactrim forte 960 tabl rizatriptan benzoate get you high fosamax more than 5 years is 50 mg of zoloft high can you take amoxicillin and diclofenac together elusionist.com dickhopper.com tadalafil online australia cipro for colitis amoxicillin 500mg high azithromycin 1000 mg in indian market desogen morning after interaction diovan hct 320 25 generic any recreational benefit to baclofen in how long does ciprofloxacin for ear infection rizatriptan metabolites lasix 25 mg peak time for cialis furosemide 40 mg diuretic without prescription can buy flagyl over counter kmmvin.eu penegra silagra generic viagra cumwithuscom robertjszmidt.pl viagra price in indore can i stop taking estrogen if i take prometrium online coupon for lexapro posologia levofloxacino valtrex additional dosage for cold sores after 1day muslim-academy.com albuterol nebulizer before surgery toddlers taking lorazepam with bactrim could taking bupropion xl cause a missed period clotrimazole and dexamethasone cream flagyll drip price in pharmacy store montelukast sodium and desloratadine 4kom.it who is brunette in cialis commercial zoloft withdrawal lawsuit esteponasurgery.com africanamericanimages.us terbinafine 5 dmso nail solution walk ins can i get viagra efek samping flagyl benzoyl metronidazole citalopram hbr 5 mg can i use metronidazole while on my period vitaroom.net decadron 8mg oral porque se usa bactrim forte en purpura businesscreditpro.com zithromax dosage for dogs with lyme disease robertjszmidt.pl propecia online uk buy lipitor vs lovastatin generic quetiapine united states buy viagra from pfizer diflucan 5 days clomid improve pregancy rates with endo feldene 20 mg street value asiliahomehealth.com does horizon nj cover viagra is flagyl 400 an antibiotic wellbutrin sr 400 mg generic buspar 10mg zoloft 175mg can you overdose die on naproxen sodium 550 what is the street value of indomethacin plavix e un anticoagulant metoprolol er 50 mg images can i take 1000 mg of flagyl theitrecruiters.com ritemed atorvastatin quetiapine fumarate 100mg street valye adalat serial august 4 episode asthma inhaler without prescription mengobati scabies dengan amoxilin can you take ciproflaxin and b12 drops together fehmierduran.com route of clonidine hcl 75mcg flagyl dosing for bv theraflu with allegra drug interactions metformin australian prescriber dosis dexamethasone injeksi bayi prematur efeitos colaterais do remedio diovan hct 320 after hsg and iui with clomid periods delay phenergan taste feifan8.net buy terbinafine tablets side effects antibiotics in 3 month old baby komposisi obat stromectol precio medicina montelukast guadalajara misoprostol en q farmacia la encuentro en barranquilla when can i take naproxen after 5 gms of prednisolone seroquel xr 200 marihuana thc kakaanime.com price of bupropion in dollar MASTERRAFTING.COM can you take gabapentin with adderall levitra tablets 20 mg atorvastatin prices daisylcreations.com is bactrim a generic for cipro seroquel 50 mg side effects drugprevent.org.uk how to know if cytotec is not fake symptoms while on prometrium details in malayalam about side effects of antibiotics buy priligy india tadalafil tee azithromycin 500mg obat untuk mengobati... zosyn vs flagyl anaeorbic xoverage wellbutrin xl 150 mg expiration date httwp.com steroid pct clomid sales online mspnor.com bactrim dosage chinchilla trazodone large dose 1000mg purchase zovirax tablets albuterol 8mg tabs amoxicillin 50 mg for cats side effects sildenafil citrate soft gel capsules misoprostol 800 mcg buy propecia drugstore com quetiapine 600 mgs and weight gain entech.com fotografie-cursus.net fluconazole 150mg tratament chloramphenicol capsules 250mg propranolol er 80 mg side effects dry mouth amoxicillin 1000 mg uses an taking 90 mil of cymbalta be dangerous bmmpm.com augmentin 625 three times a day during pregnancy premarin .625 helps to get pregnant can i masterbate before taking viagra 4kom.it 200 mg zovirax tablet price philippines can drinking flagyl tablets cause miscariege panoramainternetu.pl africanamericanimages.us levitra 10 mg precio bayer mhc-s.com will zithromax 500 mg cure stds before abortion focva.org generic brands of cymbalta what does it look like 60 mg NEOHAIRINDO.COM creamost.com.py flagyl for kittens dosage can you give dogs amoxicillin for human gum infections anastrozole price walmart directmobility.co.uk segtucson.com vardenafil hydrochloride equivalent prednisone and doxycycline doxycycline hyclate 100mg sale will aspen fluconazole help with bv es08.com quetiapine sandoz is it seroquel is it a benzo septra ds como se toma 1000 mg zoloft best antidepressant for hypomania in woman kamagra gel te koop amsterdam ganoderma coffe combinado con tamoxifeno dickhopper.com ciprofloxacin safe for levaquin allergy misoprostol 4 semanas dosis iphone-accessory.cn eastriverpartners.info lawonline.co.il irbesartan durch die nase ziehen rudolf-ll.cz paladardigital.com how long does 240mg diltiazem take to peak acyclovir comprimes mutien.be how much seroquel overdose medicosefectivos.net onlyhantang.com esomeprazole 20mg msds generic levitra patent can i take desyrel and methadone flomax 4 mg if i have ma how much would it cost for viagra what happens if you take 40 mg of cialis prednisone 5mg pack directions dataminingweb.com robertjszmidt.pl how long does it take lasix to work biolab.com.sg azithromycin cheapest price in india can i purchase azithromycin over the counter clonidine and tramadol can someone take clomid with vitamin e for 6 days canine chewable amoxicillin 250mg bociansafaris.com does zoloft stunt growth

Melky or Gardner?

Featured — By Scott Ham on December 11, 2009 2:26 pm

Now that Curtis Granderson is a Yankee, Brett Gardner’s name is popping up.  ESPN’s Trade Rumors:

The Curtis Granderson deal seems to have made Brett Gardner a more valuable commodity.

Gardner became expendable in New York once Granderson was acquired in a three-team deal, and the latest team to make an inquiry is the Chicago White Sox. The Sun-Times says today that White Sox GM Ken Williams views Gardner as a reasonably-priced option in center field.

Competition for Gardner could come from another team in the AL Central. ESPN.com’s Jayson Stark tweeted Wednesday night that the Kansas City Royals have inquired about Gardner.

The Royals are in the market for a center fielder since free agent Coco Crisp is expected to sign elsewhere.

Sure, Gardner is a reasonably priced option for the White Sox and Kansas City.  His service time is low which makes him cheap and under team for control (I believe) for another two years.

As a matter of fact, he’s just the type of player that the Yankees could use as a backup outfielder.  Jamie Hoffman, recently acquired via the Nats from the Dodgers in the rule 5 draft will also be vying for that role once he’s completed his subterfuge against Johnny Damon.

It’s nice that teams are looking at Gardner but my question is, if the White Sox think he can start in centerfield, why would the Yankees not want him as backup?  In my mind, Melky Cabrera is the one the Yankees should be shopping.

Cabrera is a year older than Gardner but has never shown the type of plate discipline that Gardner has in the minors.  Gardner is the superior centerfielder and obviously has the better speed of the two, despite Gardner’s inability to actually utilize that speed in the playoffs.

Also, Gardner will be cheaper for longer.  That may sound like a silly argument for the Yankees, but they need cheap young talent just like everyone else.  Consider 2009, where the Yankees ranked 25th out of 30 clubs in percentage of their payroll devoted to their bullpen.  Consider also that of that $22.5 million, $15 million of it was devoted to Mariano Rivera. The Cincinnati Reds, with a $71.5 million payroll, spent $20.8 million on their bullpen, just $1.7 million less than the Yankees, whose payroll was almost three times that of the Reds ($206.8 million versus $71.5 million).

* As a side note, the Yankees also ranked 28th in percentage of salary devoted to pitching even with the big money devoted to CC Sabathia and AJ Burnett.  The entire chart as provided by Cot’s Baseball Contracts looks like this:

Club Payroll Pos. Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Atlanta $97,692,834 33.96% 30 66.04% 1
Cincinnati $71,458,500 38.56% 29 61.44% 2
Arizona $72,475,000 45.43% 28 54.57% 3
San Diego $42,746,653 47.19% 27 52.81% 4
Texas $76,255,380 48.46% 26 51.54% 5
NY Mets $139,602,235 49.60% 25 50.40% 6
San Francisco $88,777,106 49.79% 24 50.21% 7
Philadelphia $128,587,380 50.31% 23 49.69% 8
Colorado $74,730,533 51.36% 22 48.64% 9
Cleveland $81,325,900 51.67% 21 48.33% 10
Chicago Sox $98,268,500 51.86% 20 48.14% 11
Kansas City $76,446,243 52.02% 19 47.98% 12
Seattle $99,346,926 52.14% 18 47.86% 13
Toronto $80,993,657 53.05% 17 46.95% 14
Milwaukee $64,560,861 53.59% 16 46.41% 15
Chicago Cubs $137,795,612 53.90% 15 46.10% 16
St. Louis $94,498,500 55.91% 14 44.09% 17
Tampa Bay $64,996,368 56.08% 13 43.92% 18
LA Angels $116,709,000 57.92% 12 42.08% 19
Houston $104,785,000 59.54% 11 40.46% 20
Boston $122,624,689 60.32% 10 39.68% 21
LA Dodgers $109,176,603 61.74% 9 38.26% 22
Detroit $129,598,000 62.21% 8 37.79% 23
Pittsburgh $52,268,000 63.25% 7 36.75% 24
Baltimore $76,169,792 66.16% 6 33.84% 25
Florida $35,458,951 67.82% 5 32.18% 26
Minnesota $67,899,267 68.19% 4 31.81% 27
NY Yankees $206,811,689 68.46% 3 31.54% 28
Oakland $62,396,066 79.53% 2 20.47% 29
Washington $61,455,049 80.22% 1 19.76% 30
Club Payroll Pos Players Rk Pitchers Rk

Clearly, the Yankees have found some benefit to going cheaper in their bullpen, utilizing the arms within their own system, or picking up guys like Brian Bruney off the scrap heap to provide innings when needed.  The rest of the league seems to be picking up on this.  Well, seems to, anyway.

The point is, even with an inflated budget, you have to find the most appropriate places within your roster to apply cheap, young talent.  For the Yankees, that place has been the bullpen and the bench.  The bench will get a bit cheaper this year when Francisco Cervelli likely takes over the backup catcher position from Jose Molina.  It’s possible that Ramiro Pena could be a backup infielder as well depending on what the front office feels they can get out of Pena in 2010 and beyond.

Given the Brett Gardner has proven at least equally valuable as Melky Cabrera, has more time under team control and is a better defensive outfielder, there’s little reason to trade him over Cabrera.  The return for Gardner may be a little better, but we’re talking a negligible difference in return, one that certainly can be outweighed by the usefulness and flexibility of Gardner.

The only major difference between the two players is that Gardner is left-handed while Melky is a switch hitter.  Both hitters hit worse against lefties which elevated neither over the other when considering a platoon partner with Curtis Granderson.

Club Payroll Pos. Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Atlanta $97,692,834 33.96% 30 66.04% 1
Cincinnati $71,458,500 38.56% 29 61.44% 2
Arizona $72,475,000 45.43% 28 54.57% 3
San Diego $42,746,653 47.19% 27 52.81% 4
Texas $76,255,380 48.46% 26 51.54% 5
NY Mets $139,602,235 49.60% 25 50.40% 6
San Francisco $88,777,106 49.79% 24 50.21% 7
Philadelphia $128,587,380 50.31% 23 49.69% 8
Colorado $74,730,533 51.36% 22 48.64% 9
Cleveland $81,325,900 51.67% 21 48.33% 10
Chicago Sox $98,268,500 51.86% 20 48.14% 11
Kansas City $76,446,243 52.02% 19 47.98% 12
Seattle $99,346,926 52.14% 18 47.86% 13
Toronto $80,993,657 53.05% 17 46.95% 14
Milwaukee $64,560,861 53.59% 16 46.41% 15
Chicago Cubs $137,795,612 53.90% 15 46.10% 16
St. Louis $94,498,500 55.91% 14 44.09% 17
Tampa Bay $64,996,368 56.08% 13 43.92% 18
LA Angels $116,709,000 57.92% 12 42.08% 19
Houston $104,785,000 59.54% 11 40.46% 20
Boston $122,624,689 60.32% 10 39.68% 21
LA Dodgers $109,176,603 61.74% 9 38.26% 22
Detroit $129,598,000 62.21% 8 37.79% 23
Pittsburgh $52,268,000 63.25% 7 36.75% 24
Baltimore $76,169,792 66.16% 6 33.84% 25
Florida $35,458,951 67.82% 5 32.18% 26
Minnesota $67,899,267 68.19% 4 31.81% 27
NY Yankees $206,811,689 68.46% 3 31.54% 28
Oakland $62,396,066 79.53% 2 20.47% 29
Washington $61,455,049 80.22% 1 19.76% 30
Club Payroll Pos Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Tags: Brett Gardner, Brian Bruney, Chicago White Sox, Coco Crisp, Curtis Granderson, Francisco Cervelli, Jamie Hoffman, Jayson Stark, Johnny Damon, Jose Molina, Kansas City Royals, Ken Williams, Mariano Rivera, Melky Cabrera, Ramiro Pena

4 Comments

  1. Greg F. says:

    I would definitely hold on to Gardner. He is under team control for another five seasons and his defense is significantly better than the Melk Man’s.

  2. I say hold on to both. Melky Cabrera and Brett Gardner are not great but they have something to offer to the Yankees especially in the future. The Yankees don’t need to trade their outfield players just because they are overloaded. One or two them can go back to the farm. They are still young and Damon can’t play forever (that is if he signs with the Yankees).

    The Yankees should stick with this and be conservative. It’s pitching that they need. They should aggressively look for another arm for their starting rotation or their bullpen.

  3. Scott Ham says:

    I think the only upside you can expect from either player is possibly a better OBP from Gardner with more playing time, and even then I’m not sure he’ll reach the .400 levels he did in the minors. Melky has just about peaked. He never hit for power in the minors and he’s unlikely to suddenly develop it now.

    I’m not sure what Melky’s options are, but he’s close to having none. He has four full seasons and a cup of coffee year so, at best, this is his last year with an option. Gardner should have another year or two, I believe.

    I’m not sure it matters, though. With Granderson aboard, both guys are bench players. Neither has the kind of offense you can just bury in a corner outfield spot and neither are likely to be more valuable then they are right now. Drop Melky down to part time status and he’s going to look like an even worse player.

    When/if Damon signs or the Yankees get their hands on a left fielder, I think one of the two will be traded and it’s the right move.

  4. balistes says:

    gardner for a quality reliever sounds like a good deal to me. everyone on the yankee blogs always sings his praises and puts melky down but gardner just can’t hit and therefore get on base enough to make his speed into a real weapon (except, of course, as a pinch runner).

Leave a Comment


Anal
Threesome
Mature
Cosplay
buy cialis