enalapril discount safe age for benadryl how do i purchase prednisone packs xenical drug in ghana aldactone brand gabapentin 50 mg koiralle how much acetaminophen is in percocet 30 buy cialis online in south africa 100 mg of elavil and alcohol street price 100 mg viagra gabapentin 300 mg tablet in india wo kaufe ich viagra in der schweiz prescriptions benicar clopidogrel 600 mg loading dose trial albuterol in pregnancy acog canadian pharmacy viagra 50mg where can i buy voltaren cream much does fosamax cost australia osmo adalat 30 mg propecia howdotofound reviews cialis safe for patients with hep c what is clindamycin hydrochloride used for in cats merk salep yang mengandung ketoconazole safe quit cymbalta aciclovir comprimidos comprar reviews for provera glucophage 850 mg nedir jack wagner in cialis commercial can you get lisinopril in mexico much ibuprofen can you safely take one day ciloxan cost meu marido usa viagra glimepiride 2 mg spc ibuprofen generika schweiz accutane low dose 5 mg tadacip howdotofound canada purchase flagyl canada acquisto viagra in austria diltiazem 180 mg para que sirve can you buy naltrexone over the counter claritin uk boots was ist generic strattera role of cefixime in urti feldene flash 20 mg 10 tablet can acyclovir iv go in the refrigerator prozac in eating disorders chloramphenicol salep adalah clonidine o.1 mg viagra hereisthebestin australia generic caverta metoprolol tartrate 50 mg pink kamagra payment by paypal do generic brands of singulair have a milk ingredient hva er flagyl 400 mg costo del viagra en lima peru buying clomid canada can you buy viagra over the counter in edmontonalberta nolvadex generics quienes no deben usar viagra what is the cost for viagra 100mg safe take aleve tramadol hi binimar resort menorca calan forcat reviews nebenwirkungen atacand 16 mg price of xenical in walmart canada dapoxetine tablet available in india carvedilol 3125 mg harga viagra usa original erythromycin 500 mg in pregnancy gabapentin generic names safe to take ibuprofen when ttc anafranil purchase australia accutane kick in time clopidogrel in combination with aspirin zithromax for ear infection in babies much prilosec otc cost wholesaler amoxicillin 500mg philippines cytotec online canadian why propecia is safe cipro price estradiol level in pcos 600 mg effexor para que serve tadalafil 75 mg is there now a generic for lipitor what hormone is used in depo provera paroxetine in bipolar price for ondansetron 4 mg gwd houses sale artane ciprofloxacina 500 mg usos generico do viagra neo quimica albuterol inhalers generic no rx en cuanto sale la pastilla cytotec augmentin 1.2 ing price teva irbesartan 75 mg benadryl cough syrup for dry cough price how to purchase flagyl online cialis reliable purchase uk jual viagra generic safety generic cialis 20 mgs lexapro better than 10 inderal 10 mg tablet side effects is nexium going to be over the counter 800 mg ibuprofen for sciatica tamoxifen price in pakistan priligy price in thailand i took 10000 mg of ibuprofen paroxetine 10 mg prijs propranolol 40 mg prise de poids medicamento trileptal de 300 mg best price on lisinopril indomethacin hereisthebestin side effects is generic effexor expensive evista asbestos testing alli orlistat in india paxil vs lexapro reviews cipro 250 mg buy price of depo provera injection paroxetine dose 40 mg is it safe to take ambien and prozac doxycycline hyclate side effects in cats iv protonix price pain specialists in oswego county ny metformin xr 850 mg para que sirve la pastilla celecoxib 200 mg can i take allegra in the morning and claritin at night cialis 20mg tablets online aciclovir de 200 mg posologia is it safe to mix acetaminophen and ibuprofen gabapentin in dubai directions for taking 200 mg ibuprofen articox celecoxib 200 mg para que sirve viagra manila kaufen meloxicam for dogs reviews methocarbamol 750 mg good el generico de motrin can u get valtrex over counter how often do you take nexium 40 mg can i buy viagra without prescription se usar viagra sin receta kamagra jellies africa sales ketoconazole shampoo available in the philippines generic tadalafil 2.5 mg betamethasone in fetal lung development valacyclovir hcl 500 mg mylan can i take nexium in the evening what is the price of the drug cialis methocarbamol canada no prescription nizoral 500 ml shampoo online buy viagra pain in the eye bactrim thyroid disorder purchase cialis canada online zofran overdose in dogs metformin price in philippines c20 cialis buy tegretol side effects in pregnancy brand name of tadalafil in india propecia side effects health canada mobicom papers routing vinod muthusamy milenko petrovic buy cheap cephalexin signs of ibuprofen overdose in baby ditropan 5 mg tablet overdose benadryl mg hytrin 5 mg para que sirve lansoprazole forum uk cialis 5 mg testimonial mirtazapine 15 mg for cats only best way stop prozac 25 mg atenolol reviews paxil still on market how much amoxilcillin 500 mg should 6 year old take cialis made in spain clindamycin gel in eyes best mg of elavil for depression and headache amlodipine brand which is best mebeverine or buscopan paxil 30 mg anxiety aciclovir 1000 mg montelukast 5mg price generic name glipizide xl much does fosamax cost australia lexapro side effects in men weight gain sildenafil for sale in uk tretinoin gel uk buy aldactone generic spironolactone ciprofloxacino causa incha azithromycin dosage: 1 g orally in a single dose clomid 50 mg a day foro levitra genericos anafranil 25 mg prospektüs lipitor pricing walmart hydroxyzine highest mg how much can you get for lexapro 20 mg buy viagra from us pharmacy reviews of bupropion hcl extended release ratiopharm ibuprofen 500 mg is oxytetracycline safe for humans what countries sell amoxicillin over the counter ondansetron hcl 12 mg po comprare cialis online cialis 5 mg testimonial nitroglycerine medicine available in kerala tablet lasix action in wikepedia do i need a prescription for lamisil in ontario buy pill viagra glucophage xr 750 mg cena methotrexate mechanism of action in breast cancer preis viagra in usa zofran not safe price of naproxen 500mg ciprofloxacin hcl manufcturer india dose of dexamethasone in quinsy retinal detachment lexapro 20 mg viagra 25 mg online what allergy medicine is safe with zoloft ciprofloxacin real 500 600 mg of metronidazole at once orally generic for viramune lamisil generic equivalent ed specialists in nj where we get women viagra in bangalore online shopping ampicillin 500 mg injection price lok adalat india wiki dostinex 0.5 mg endikasyonlar? is cephalexin safe while breast feeding hydroxyzine antihistamine over counter viagra online paypal deutschland amoxicillin 125 mg dosage for kittens toprol xl 25 mg used levitra professional 20 mg generic doxycycline use in prostatitis mefloquine hydrochloride tablets 250 mg contact dermatitis prednisone single dose 40 mg novartis lamisil tablets price pakistan generic release date plavix can yoou take viagra twice in two days why does warfarin cause blood in urine sildenafil mylan 50 mg prix really tired accutane purchase valtrex bertibarots 25 mg meclizine hcl best price for ranitidine zithromax 400mg price ph buy tolterodine tartrate azithromycin 250 mg 3 times a week generic avodart buy what is safer paracetamol or ibuprofen buy tamoxifen from uk kamagra jelly new zealand ciprofloxacin 500 mg kegunaan getting prescription prednisone online aciclovir nombre generico comercial inactive ingredients generic effexor amoxicillin clavulanic acid liquid dosage captopril 25 mg tomar chloramphenicol toxicity in neonates levitra generika preise 5 mg lexapro during first trimester doxazosin 2 mg tab apotex warfarin weight gain uk priligy und viagra zusammen isotretinoin philippines review phenytoin sodium extended 100 mg capsule generika von lisinopril atenolol baownbeuv price viagra buy 100 nexium y para perfusi?n 40 mg buy one viagra online metoprolol generic and trade name costa allegra website hair loss in women taking wellbutrin reviews of meloxicam zyrtec d generic amoxicillin antibiotics buy online wo viagra online kaufen what is prednisone 30 mg is augmentin safe during early pregnancy allopurinol in kidney disease onde comprar viagra or similar online amoxicillin for dogs how many mg naproxen in aleve sildenafil abz 50 mg fta can amoxicillin cause vomiting in toddlers para comprar viagra tem que ter receita medica how to purchase levitra fluvoxamine maleate oral tablet 100 mg contraindicaciones captopril 25 mg is cymbalta prescribed for bipolar disorder cost of tablet orlistat in india. is it safe to take ibuprofen when you have the flu celebrex genericos actonel drug reviews meclizine 25 mg bonine sertraline costs is there a generic form of evista acetaminophen codeine in canada does viagra help in the long run viagra cipla prices how many mg of zantac can you take when pregnant buy lipitor without zyprexa price increase how much is xenical drug in nigeria para que sirve el medicamento aciclovir 800 mg fluoxetine cost cats best way to take topamax for weight loss fl real estate broker license reciprocity maxalt rpd 10 costo pro fluoxetine 10 mg generic zoloft and breastfeeding can fluoxetine cause constipation in dogs seroquel 300 mg rilascio prolungato diflucan 150 ml cures yeast retina specialist in hartford ct es naprosyn 500 mg tabletss.i tabs po od metformin in the prevention of diabetes is gabapentin 600 mg a narcotic is it safe to take naproxen after tooth extraction ketoconazole over the counter products fungsi obat clomiphene citrate 50 mg is ibuprofen a safe drug elavil bertibarots online cost of nimodipine how safe is ciprofloxacin metoprolol contraindicated in glaucoma phenergan suppositories for sale order plavix terbinafine hcl liquid lamisil 250 mg results zyprexa 20 mg buy cialis 5mg everyday use is it safe to take ondansetron 4 mg while pregnant cost methotrexate misoprostol folic acid use in methotrexate novamoxin 500 mg amoxicillin uses donde comprar viagra en bolivia comprare cialis in svizzera senza ricetta buying nolvadex for gyno uk metronidazole 500 mg antibiotic liquid where can i buy cialis or viagra safer alternative coumadin amoxicillin for dogs in season triamcinolone acetonide ointment usp 0.1 buy online cefuroxime 750 mg tablet metronidazole 250 mg tabletten como usar combivent discount generic cialis professional india il clomid quanto costa xenical indian pharmacy cephalexin 500 mg side effects and alcohol cialis auf kaufenf rechnung online purchase viagra india walmart pharmacy cialis 5 mg cost clomid spain purchase cardura 2 mg fiyati generic zofran birth defect accutane sterility in men is is safe to buy generic cialis online synthroid drip in organ donation zithromax really work for cat does aetna cover cialis in california walmart printable zyrtec coupon generic alternative to propecia escitalopram oxalate 20mg reviews prilosec on sale brand name of duloxetine dose of metronidazole in diverticulitis benefits of nifedipine in pregnancy canadian sales of viagra viagra 100 mg n3 compare viagra and cialis prices cialis rougeurs visage viagra order in india finpecia g?nstig bestellen cymbalta attention deficit disorder secure tabs viagra reviews naltrexone injections cost adco paroxetine 20 mg night sweats safety of norfloxacin in pregnancy buy generic viagra by phone generic name of effexor xr is there a generic for plavix yet omeprazole cheapest price on warfarin blood in urine buy generic viagra online next day quanto costa viagra da 25 orlistat sales in singapore c diff metronidazole reviews nizoral 20 mg krém ára buy kamagra jelly nederlands prescriptions benicar buy doxycycline tablets for pigeons trental 400 mg cost clonidine in adults losartan potassium chemistry celebrex 400 mg capsule efficacy of bactrim in treating utis is zofran safe during second trimester is albuterol contraindicated in pneumonia viagra accross the counter clopidogrel 75 mg bid is it ok to take cialis 2 days in a row cialis da 10 mg quanto dura where to buy cialis in malaysia phamarcy will you ever be able to get viagra over the counter buy aricept online sporetik cefixime 100 mg naproxen 300 mg side effects capoten de 25 mg where to buy viagra bangkok best website for brand name viagra diflucan dosage for yeast infection in women hydrocodone acetaminophen liquid price pantozol pantoprazole 40 mg can u take tadalafil and viagra in same day cost for accutane and blood work abilify cost assistance can i use flagyl tablet in pregnancy 22 weeks how good and safe is levitra acyclovir 800 mg overdose topamax review weight loss health canada amlodipine kaiser permanente viagra cost 25 mg zoloft dosage is xenical over the counter in canada cheap citalopram permethrin legal canada is obama really a socialist side effects of 20 mg prednisone do you need a prescription to buy nexium in ireland ampicillin dosage in adults tretinoin cream brands in pakistan indications for coumadin in stroke generic name for alendronate xenical prix france best ibuprofen for 1 year old pastilla cytotec donde comprar material safety data sheet orlistat what other drugs are in the same class as lexapro is dapoxetine available in the us viagra compresse costo walmart zyrtec equate over counter substitute neurontin generic viagra korea atorvastain with clopidogrel bisulfate capsules usage spironolactone cheap street value pill prices amitriptyline 25mg what is the cost of ondansetron cyproheptadine 4 mg price oxytetracycline in bangladesh buy indomethacin online uk cost zovirax cream prozac discovery salud para que sirve prednisone 5 mg roxane 7 day 500 mg metronidazole over the counter comprare casa a cipro isotretinoin mg pro kg cialis 20 mg yahoo buy nolvadex with e money transfer nebenwirkungen von viagra generika 40 mg furosemide how much torsemide mobicip android reviews propecia dosaze in a day yahoo answers in india find 150 mg viagra cheap metformin api price diflucan 150 mg fluconazole buy ventolin no prescription uk use of amitriptyline in sciatica does lisinopril 10 mg effect running atorvastatin walmart cost is prozac available in south africa where to buy good kamagra online 1 mg overnight dexamethasone test ou acheter lasix 40 mg cipla clomid review mometasone furoate cream in bangladesh uae acyclovir over the counter topamax 50 mg comprimidos recubiertos how much liquid benadryl can i give my 12 lb dog nolvadex buy cheap glucophage 1000 mg weight loss mallika sherawat in aap ki adalat full episode como se usar el cytotec generic zocor side effects best treatment for scabies permethrin cost of cialis a all wichita kansas metoclopramide 10 mg used requip prix para que sirve el valsartan 160 mg seroquel goes generic mometasone furoate in ear 100 mg gabapentin 20 mg fluoxetine clomid price in malaysia diflucan 150 mg sweat exercise nexium shampoo canada desloratadine 5 mg dosage mylan valacyclovir 500 mg dosage orlistat ponto de fusao lamictal dose for bipolar disorder pantoprazole 40 mg espanol lipitor muscle pain in buttocks

Melky or Gardner?

Featured — By Scott Ham on December 11, 2009 2:26 pm

Now that Curtis Granderson is a Yankee, Brett Gardner’s name is popping up.  ESPN’s Trade Rumors:

The Curtis Granderson deal seems to have made Brett Gardner a more valuable commodity.

Gardner became expendable in New York once Granderson was acquired in a three-team deal, and the latest team to make an inquiry is the Chicago White Sox. The Sun-Times says today that White Sox GM Ken Williams views Gardner as a reasonably-priced option in center field.

Competition for Gardner could come from another team in the AL Central. ESPN.com’s Jayson Stark tweeted Wednesday night that the Kansas City Royals have inquired about Gardner.

The Royals are in the market for a center fielder since free agent Coco Crisp is expected to sign elsewhere.

Sure, Gardner is a reasonably priced option for the White Sox and Kansas City.  His service time is low which makes him cheap and under team for control (I believe) for another two years.

As a matter of fact, he’s just the type of player that the Yankees could use as a backup outfielder.  Jamie Hoffman, recently acquired via the Nats from the Dodgers in the rule 5 draft will also be vying for that role once he’s completed his subterfuge against Johnny Damon.

It’s nice that teams are looking at Gardner but my question is, if the White Sox think he can start in centerfield, why would the Yankees not want him as backup?  In my mind, Melky Cabrera is the one the Yankees should be shopping.

Cabrera is a year older than Gardner but has never shown the type of plate discipline that Gardner has in the minors.  Gardner is the superior centerfielder and obviously has the better speed of the two, despite Gardner’s inability to actually utilize that speed in the playoffs.

Also, Gardner will be cheaper for longer.  That may sound like a silly argument for the Yankees, but they need cheap young talent just like everyone else.  Consider 2009, where the Yankees ranked 25th out of 30 clubs in percentage of their payroll devoted to their bullpen.  Consider also that of that $22.5 million, $15 million of it was devoted to Mariano Rivera. The Cincinnati Reds, with a $71.5 million payroll, spent $20.8 million on their bullpen, just $1.7 million less than the Yankees, whose payroll was almost three times that of the Reds ($206.8 million versus $71.5 million).

* As a side note, the Yankees also ranked 28th in percentage of salary devoted to pitching even with the big money devoted to CC Sabathia and AJ Burnett.  The entire chart as provided by Cot’s Baseball Contracts looks like this:

Club Payroll Pos. Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Atlanta $97,692,834 33.96% 30 66.04% 1
Cincinnati $71,458,500 38.56% 29 61.44% 2
Arizona $72,475,000 45.43% 28 54.57% 3
San Diego $42,746,653 47.19% 27 52.81% 4
Texas $76,255,380 48.46% 26 51.54% 5
NY Mets $139,602,235 49.60% 25 50.40% 6
San Francisco $88,777,106 49.79% 24 50.21% 7
Philadelphia $128,587,380 50.31% 23 49.69% 8
Colorado $74,730,533 51.36% 22 48.64% 9
Cleveland $81,325,900 51.67% 21 48.33% 10
Chicago Sox $98,268,500 51.86% 20 48.14% 11
Kansas City $76,446,243 52.02% 19 47.98% 12
Seattle $99,346,926 52.14% 18 47.86% 13
Toronto $80,993,657 53.05% 17 46.95% 14
Milwaukee $64,560,861 53.59% 16 46.41% 15
Chicago Cubs $137,795,612 53.90% 15 46.10% 16
St. Louis $94,498,500 55.91% 14 44.09% 17
Tampa Bay $64,996,368 56.08% 13 43.92% 18
LA Angels $116,709,000 57.92% 12 42.08% 19
Houston $104,785,000 59.54% 11 40.46% 20
Boston $122,624,689 60.32% 10 39.68% 21
LA Dodgers $109,176,603 61.74% 9 38.26% 22
Detroit $129,598,000 62.21% 8 37.79% 23
Pittsburgh $52,268,000 63.25% 7 36.75% 24
Baltimore $76,169,792 66.16% 6 33.84% 25
Florida $35,458,951 67.82% 5 32.18% 26
Minnesota $67,899,267 68.19% 4 31.81% 27
NY Yankees $206,811,689 68.46% 3 31.54% 28
Oakland $62,396,066 79.53% 2 20.47% 29
Washington $61,455,049 80.22% 1 19.76% 30
Club Payroll Pos Players Rk Pitchers Rk

Clearly, the Yankees have found some benefit to going cheaper in their bullpen, utilizing the arms within their own system, or picking up guys like Brian Bruney off the scrap heap to provide innings when needed.  The rest of the league seems to be picking up on this.  Well, seems to, anyway.

The point is, even with an inflated budget, you have to find the most appropriate places within your roster to apply cheap, young talent.  For the Yankees, that place has been the bullpen and the bench.  The bench will get a bit cheaper this year when Francisco Cervelli likely takes over the backup catcher position from Jose Molina.  It’s possible that Ramiro Pena could be a backup infielder as well depending on what the front office feels they can get out of Pena in 2010 and beyond.

Given the Brett Gardner has proven at least equally valuable as Melky Cabrera, has more time under team control and is a better defensive outfielder, there’s little reason to trade him over Cabrera.  The return for Gardner may be a little better, but we’re talking a negligible difference in return, one that certainly can be outweighed by the usefulness and flexibility of Gardner.

The only major difference between the two players is that Gardner is left-handed while Melky is a switch hitter.  Both hitters hit worse against lefties which elevated neither over the other when considering a platoon partner with Curtis Granderson.

Club Payroll Pos. Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Atlanta $97,692,834 33.96% 30 66.04% 1
Cincinnati $71,458,500 38.56% 29 61.44% 2
Arizona $72,475,000 45.43% 28 54.57% 3
San Diego $42,746,653 47.19% 27 52.81% 4
Texas $76,255,380 48.46% 26 51.54% 5
NY Mets $139,602,235 49.60% 25 50.40% 6
San Francisco $88,777,106 49.79% 24 50.21% 7
Philadelphia $128,587,380 50.31% 23 49.69% 8
Colorado $74,730,533 51.36% 22 48.64% 9
Cleveland $81,325,900 51.67% 21 48.33% 10
Chicago Sox $98,268,500 51.86% 20 48.14% 11
Kansas City $76,446,243 52.02% 19 47.98% 12
Seattle $99,346,926 52.14% 18 47.86% 13
Toronto $80,993,657 53.05% 17 46.95% 14
Milwaukee $64,560,861 53.59% 16 46.41% 15
Chicago Cubs $137,795,612 53.90% 15 46.10% 16
St. Louis $94,498,500 55.91% 14 44.09% 17
Tampa Bay $64,996,368 56.08% 13 43.92% 18
LA Angels $116,709,000 57.92% 12 42.08% 19
Houston $104,785,000 59.54% 11 40.46% 20
Boston $122,624,689 60.32% 10 39.68% 21
LA Dodgers $109,176,603 61.74% 9 38.26% 22
Detroit $129,598,000 62.21% 8 37.79% 23
Pittsburgh $52,268,000 63.25% 7 36.75% 24
Baltimore $76,169,792 66.16% 6 33.84% 25
Florida $35,458,951 67.82% 5 32.18% 26
Minnesota $67,899,267 68.19% 4 31.81% 27
NY Yankees $206,811,689 68.46% 3 31.54% 28
Oakland $62,396,066 79.53% 2 20.47% 29
Washington $61,455,049 80.22% 1 19.76% 30
Club Payroll Pos Players Rk Pitchers Rk
Tags: Brett Gardner, Brian Bruney, Chicago White Sox, Coco Crisp, Curtis Granderson, Francisco Cervelli, Jamie Hoffman, Jayson Stark, Johnny Damon, Jose Molina, Kansas City Royals, Ken Williams, Mariano Rivera, Melky Cabrera, Ramiro Pena

4 Comments

  1. Greg F. says:

    I would definitely hold on to Gardner. He is under team control for another five seasons and his defense is significantly better than the Melk Man’s.

  2. I say hold on to both. Melky Cabrera and Brett Gardner are not great but they have something to offer to the Yankees especially in the future. The Yankees don’t need to trade their outfield players just because they are overloaded. One or two them can go back to the farm. They are still young and Damon can’t play forever (that is if he signs with the Yankees).

    The Yankees should stick with this and be conservative. It’s pitching that they need. They should aggressively look for another arm for their starting rotation or their bullpen.

  3. Scott Ham says:

    I think the only upside you can expect from either player is possibly a better OBP from Gardner with more playing time, and even then I’m not sure he’ll reach the .400 levels he did in the minors. Melky has just about peaked. He never hit for power in the minors and he’s unlikely to suddenly develop it now.

    I’m not sure what Melky’s options are, but he’s close to having none. He has four full seasons and a cup of coffee year so, at best, this is his last year with an option. Gardner should have another year or two, I believe.

    I’m not sure it matters, though. With Granderson aboard, both guys are bench players. Neither has the kind of offense you can just bury in a corner outfield spot and neither are likely to be more valuable then they are right now. Drop Melky down to part time status and he’s going to look like an even worse player.

    When/if Damon signs or the Yankees get their hands on a left fielder, I think one of the two will be traded and it’s the right move.

  4. balistes says:

    gardner for a quality reliever sounds like a good deal to me. everyone on the yankee blogs always sings his praises and puts melky down but gardner just can’t hit and therefore get on base enough to make his speed into a real weapon (except, of course, as a pinch runner).

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.