natural source of metformin erythromycin lichtempfindlich cena cialis v lekarni estradiol spironolactone what is the role of thyroxine spironolactone and salt substitute metronidazole pill order how many days do i need to take metronidazole 500 for nizoral in costco breastfeeding while taking valtrex sildenafil citrate contraindications can we masturbate while taking gabapentin usp viagra list nexium tablets for anorexia likelihood of conceiving on clomid metoprolol conversion carvedilol famvir drug propecia ashley martin high dose of zoloft what is the best liquid to take viagra with zithromax sirop vidal beli cytotec daerah malang 10mg lexapro vs. 20 mg celexa nolvadex online pharmacy metformin vinegar viagra and suoper cum cheap viagra in bangalore generic versions of lipitor is hydrochlorothiazide n lisinopril good together femara adet d?zensizligi maxalt imitrex conversion prednisone bronchitis asthma maxalt mutuabile my first time taking cialis metformin pcos average weight loss why plavix and aspirin combination going off cialis abilify injection package insert when to start nolvadex and clomid side effects of nexium hp 7 and indigestion medicamentos gabapentin 300 dosage of doxycycline for cough in dogs 100lbs average dosage olanzapine albuterol nebulizer machine cost walgreens lipitor card problem grifulvin rowcmoadreders overnight coupons for strattera keflex side effects how long allegra for itchy best indian viagra names how long before 1g of azithromycin cures chlamydia how much clomid is too much accidentally took two nexium how young is too young for viagra can i take levaquin while pregnant aciclovir crema per brufoli what are the side effects of taking amlodipine besylate cymbalta tedavisi norvasc composi? atarax en zwangerschap levothyroxine tablets without lactose isotretinoina orale funziona estradiol uterine bleeding will clomid make my period heavier damn show propecia dead is generic synthroid just as good difference between acyclovir oral and cream drinking alcohol on celexa quand prendre viagra beneficios del prednisone des stents plavix where to buy priligy pills metoprolol tartrato 50 mg contraindicaciones can prednisone cause dehydration night sweats and prednisone withdrawal atenolol dosage migraine lexapro treating anxiety amoxicilline eg 1000 mg bijsluiter cytotec management is linezolid bacteriostatic or bactericidal viagra inhibiteur phosphodiesterase cheap olanzapine whartisthebestin hydrochlorothiazide metformin cost cialis daily vs usual topamax issues phenergan amp dose in pedi nexium price cvs farmacia andorra priligy mobiclic 125 ritalin strattera together methocarbamol naproxen sodium together how we treat amoxil omeprazole and plavix study quetiapine add on treatment dose of azithromycin for infants seroquel xr for kids prevent diarrhea taking amoxicillin flomax plus zyprexa efectos a largo plazo amoxicillin prescription walmart para que serve o medicamento avodart orlistat wirkmechanismus can i take an antibiotic with valtrex tetracycline citric acid seroquel sales generico cialis dr. simi clomid flu like symptoms purchase bupropion bertibarots carvedilol 12.5 cialis und paracetamol cephalexin antibiotic dosage for dogs flagyl 400 from india how long will nausea from zoloft last can you take imitrex and topamax together does prednisone cause rectal bleeding metformin 500 xr side effects gia cua dau goi nizoral about sildenafil 100mg take 2 viagra double dose tadalafil can you take two clomid and low bmi nexium directions taking kruszewski seroquel sildenafil citrate 100mg red antifungal shampoo for humans nizoral treating depression with lexapro albuterol inhaler military can you take advil with strattera bleeding while on azithromycin singulair nebenwirkungen propecia making hair worse prednisone effect on birth control prednisone 20mg 54760 viagra des alpes viagra for young healthy man nizoral 2 shampoo sizes metformin trial for breast cancer best diet pill prescription cephalexin congestion seroquel side effects autism the side effects of lisinopril amoxicillin help with cough seroquel urine analysis viagra online mumbai mifepristone and misoprostol sulit singulair sinusitis treatment azithromycin ratio 500 mg fta 1oo mil viagra how fast does it work what is the difference between diltiazem sr or er can you mix amoxicillin and metronidazole tetracycline and calcium side effects of sildenafil tablets cialis a skopje propranolol and wine medlineplus prednisone diferencia entre ventolin y combivent effects of viagra for men monthly cost of seroquel lisinopril usphctzuspsideffects what does keflex oz ss mean disulfiram drugs when do you take propranolol why does prednisone increase hair growth im scared to take lexapro levitra and blood prssure augmentin fiale intramuscolo olanzapine chemo bad cipro side effects aciclovir ratiopharm filmtabletten lioresal et cannabis prednisone treatment for dogs with cancer tadalafil generico espa?a how many hours fucking viagra dosificacion de nexium maxalt paroxetine what is metronidazole 500mg prescribed for cialis 3200 topamax free trial card metronidazole effect on a breastfed 1year old cymbalta 60 mg fiyat 95.mg . metoprololtartrast remedio premarin bula ciprofloxacina e diabete atorvastatin ldl can you buy cialis from canada clomid meerdere follikels fluconazole in china can women take kamagra 100mg oral jelly ciprofloxacina ed allattamento kamagra 100 mg india lisinopril withdrawal symptoms a comprehensive view how sells doxycycline hyclate cheper toronto buy viagra store cat costa mifepriston si misoprostol can you buy viagra uk nexium quanto costa diflucan metronidazole incendio su costa allegra alla deriva alle seychelles when will viagra cost go down erythromycin chancroid prednisone for dogs in pain abilify arreter cialisin tadalafil 20mg amitriptyline 200 formula medica de cytotec gabapentin original can you take prozac and amoxicillin azithromycin expiration side effects abilify 30 mg prospekt?s ofloxacin impurity a lyrica och atarax meloxicam howdotofound australia erythromycin suspension does accutane help with hyperpigmentation what does chewable amoxicillin look like tamoxifen koffie bactrim for sti buy zovirax cream at cvs meloxicam dose in ferrets bactrim ds work for strep throat generic viagra canadian overnight tamoxifen ovarian hyperstimulation wellbutrin sr xl dosage zovirax user reviews where to buy doxycycline for venerial disease do you need a prescription for viagra in tijuana what are side effects of cephalexin zantac 3 diet pill zovirax dvd azithromycin kidney function switch from cymbalta to viibryd baby allergy symptoms to amoxicillin orelox ou augmentin withdrawal symptoms amitriptyline how long viagra cenik dostinex e tsh helicobacter bactrim drogist online viagra uses for bactrim kamagra gel maribor effects of too much lisinopril ciprofloxacina dosis y administracion viagra entrega en 24 horas what is aldactone tablets can viagra cause miscarriage wellbutrin 150 mg withdrawal symptoms of hydrochlorothiazide olanzapine for recreational use definition disulfiram dostinex puedo tomar alcohol gabapentin 100 mg pret flu shot diflucan nursing care plan prednisone can viagra tablets seduce girls pregnancy on seroquel dr metformin zayiflatirmi can you lift weights while taking prednisone propranolol na co zoloft withdrawal symptoms length bactrim dosage availability costa allegra data varo can you drink alcohol and take celexa priligy generika forum buy viagra wolverhampton cialis rezeptfrei expressversand indomethacin whartisthebestin overnight robaxin show up in a drug test prilosec taken with zoloft side of valtrex rizatriptan indications em quanto tempo aciclovir comprimido faz efeito natural viagra substitutesn gnc can i drink alcohol while taking accutane when will there be a generic form of lexapro ivermectina para gado esomeprazole icu what are the generic names for synthroid wellbutrin xl versus wellbutrin sr for weight loss lioresal data sheet efeito colateral do aciclovir comprimido efeitos colaterais do viagra no homem xyzal allegra d does viagra help hair loss strattera online advertisements ventolin hfa dosage adults celexa tabs tarivid 200 mg ofloxacin can you split wellbutrin sr in half metformin and heavy bleeding precio cialis seguridad social 15 year old viagra viagra make you horny an you use propecia and rogaine strattera and risperidone how long does erythromycin last amoxicillin placenta mixing celexa and molly fluconazole200 mg dosage for male thrush cytotec kuwait indomethacin tqeovertoz discount what is amoxicillin oral phenergan with codeine high blood pressure cymbalta for smoking import viagra australia erythromycin and delayed gastric emptying phenergan for sale online metformin herbal medicine wellbutrin making me nauseous acyclovir 200m ivermectin pour on composition garlic and erectile dysfunction glucophage a pcos bupropion and paxin combination generic propecia europe zyvox zosyn kas ir cialis metformin and miscarriage prevention is kamagra as good as viagra cialis uk distributor does buspar dizziness go away propecia is making me hot villa cipro in lido ibuprofen paxil synthroid side effects with pregnancy does bactrim treat boils synthroid side effects chest pain seroquel side weight gain fluconazole infants dose can gabapentin side effects can paxil cause vertigo does acyclovir treat cmv clomid success rates at 40 does amoxicillin cure viruses finalidade do xenical kamagra super p singulair day or night amoxicillin baby dosagem ciprofloxacin usp 250 use of clomiphene citrate and birth defects metformin in pregnancy study para que se usa el medicamento diflucan strattera vs adderall depression cymbalta darreichungsformen is dutasteride a steroid mirtazapine interaction with propecia lipitor dosage take carte mobicarte 100 euros abstinencia lexapro long phenergan your system continuous lasix infusion griseofulvin scalp ringworm tadalafil eksi can you take creatine with doxycycline para que es bueno el atenolol wie richtig nimmt man die viagra tableten ein cialis. com free ivermectin baownbeuv cost trazodone mixed with buspar cipro mare opinioni lose weight after abilify estrace cream walmart generic medications for lexapro tapering prednisone and side effects sildenafil retinopathy doxycycline hard on liver side effects of prednisone on cats clomid causes cysts does accutane cause whiteheads buy 1 viagra should i stop taking lamisil pantoprazole amoxicillin clarithromycin zyprexa identify estradiol predictivo embarazo metoprolol re75 does amoxicillin have bactrim doxycycline hyclate 100 mg side effects cymbalta smelly gas lamisil receptfri celebrex hives what kind of drug is atarax imitrex interaction with zoloft can lipitor cause swollen ankles metformin ic50 ampk para que es la pastilla ciprofloxacino zoloft side effects spanish flagyl medication wiki priligy generico farmacia pra que serve misoprostol when to start allopurinol after gout attack kidney transplant prednisone regimen tetracycline is penicillin phenergan narcotic drug welche wirkung hat viagra what dose of cipro for uti spierx tamoxifen citrate allegra agency mexico viagra dziala na szwagra should septra be refrigerated misoprostol et asthme amoxicillin feeding mothers is it ok to mix amoxicillin and nyquil flagyl antibiotico intestinal can i take maxalt and cymbalta cheap acyclovir tqeovertoz amlodipine with simvastatin hidradenitis suppurativa metformin potency of generic cialis farmacias donde venden cytotec lima albuterol nebulizer technique metformin kullanan varmi is there home made viagra why xenical best than other cialis for sell is wellbutrin good for fatigue levitra length of effictiveness levothyroxine foreskin celebrex 100 mg indicatii cytotec online mexico l state orlistate nortadalafil efficiency revatio dergboadre side effects erythromycin injection stability augmentin per herpes can you take saw palimento with finasteride cialis reklami bisiklet metformin hydrochloride and glibenclamide capsules atomoxetine medicine lamisil glabrata kamagra damla bayan azdirici cephalexin side effects vomiting generic viagra and pay with paypal what is over the counter substitute for flagyl can rogaine and propecia be used at the same time ivermectin injection for dogs side effects loose 30 pounds with out a diet or pills allopurinol and renal insufficiency isotretinoina e bodybuilding gabapentin dose vs lyrica dose cialis 20mg pre?o portugal hookers with viagra clopidogrel arthritis blueberry 100 sildenafil obat generik accutane tetracycline concentration bacterial culture 252f500 glyburide metformin dosws viagra make women horny the power pill viagra metoprolol analysis does celebrex start working right away best price on cialis 5mg zyban eating disorder does keflex work on sinus infections para que sirve la tableta terbinafine hcl 250 mg rocky mountain spotted fever doxycycline dose aap ki adalat shahrukh khan viagra foods to avoid tetracycline give blood cymbalta web is it best to take propecia with rogaine antidepressants and long term health of fetus does ciprodex cause pain prozac 90 is viagra cialis or levitra the best bactrim mucus prednisone 7 day pack instructions proce of floxin versus ciprodex without insurance zithromax po ventolin acelera el corazon metformin and false positive pregnancy test venta de cytotec en valencia venezuela amoxicillin and chlamydia dosage absorption site of metformin valtrex de 500 mg erythromycin petsmart xenical 120mg weight loss fedex amoxicillin overnight telefone do laboratorio nexium antibiotics ear infection cipro albuterol sulfate inhalation solution babies famotidine synthroid interaction abilify and olanzapine interaction lipitor advil subscribe mailing list fr viagra accutane weight loss or gain azithromycin to treat ureaplasma natural substitute finasteride day 5 on 100mg zoloft does walgreens have generic lipitor oxytetracycline for skin conditions what do erythromycin tablets look like viagra en mano sevilla ph phenergan viagra when is it going generic propiedades del medicamento sildenafil cymbalta side effects loss appetite can you use cialis and viagra at the same time nolvadex odblokowanie ciprofloxacin hcl 500mgin spanish strattera for impulsivity septran jobs rockford

Why Nick and Not Matsui?

Columns, Featured — By Scott Ham on December 18, 2009 12:22 pm

Looks like the only thing left bringing DH/1B Nick Johnson back to New York is the dotting of the I’s.  The $5.5 million price tag has left many wondering why the accident prone Johnson and not the gimpy-legged Matsui?

Jason over at IIATMS led the charge:

Nick Johnson has the potential to thrive hitting in the #2 spot behind Jeter, ahead of Teixeira and ARod. Sure, he’s not gonna run, but then again, Damon batted #2 in 2009 and stole only 12 bases. Was that because of Damon or because Girardi didn’t want to run himself out of an inning with the horses up behind Damon?

Johnson, assuming he can remain healthy, will be a nice fit for this team.  He doesn’t have to play every game.  Will he quickly adjust to playing only half the game, and after that, only 4-5 times a week instead of 6-7?

Like I said up top: I like Nick. I like what he could bring this team.  I just don’t get why, if Cashman wanted a “pure” DH, he didn’t re-sign the one he had for the last seven years, the consummate professional, the one who is the reigning World Series MVP.

Jason and I tweeted back and forth a bit about this last night and our opinions are actually closer on the subject than they’re about to appear.

There’s a few X factors here that we are not aware of, the biggest being Matsui’s desire to play the outfield at least part time.  The Los Angeles California Angels of Anaheim California rather unwisely think that they may be better off if Matsui could play the outfield a few days a week:

Matsui played all 142 of his games last season at designated hitter, and though Scioscia would prefer to rotate his other three outfielders — Torii Hunter, Bobby Abreu and Juan Rivera — through the DH spot and give Matsui an occasional start in left field, he will not force the issue.

“It’s much more important for us to have him in the lineup swinging the bat every day rather than forcing him to play the outfield,” Scioscia said. “That being said, it would make us deeper if he could play the outfield two or three times a week.”

Some sources have said that “logic” was part of the reason Matsui jumped at the Angels offer.  Brian Cashman may have been considering Matsui but, given the fact that Matsui never touched a glove in 2009, it was pretty apparent his only role would be that of designated hitter.

Given the Yankees needs and Matsui’s wants, the Yankees may not have been a match to re-sign Hideki at this stage.

Comparing Matsui and Nick Johnson head to head, we find these numbers:

Year Age G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+
Nick 2009 30 133 574 457 71 133 24 2 8 99 84 .291 .426 .405 .831 122
Matsui 2009 35 142 526 456 62 125 21 1 28 64 75 .274 .367 .509 .876 131

And their career splits:


Split G PA H 2B 3B HR BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS BAbip
Nick vs RHP 702 2306 503 122 3 73 361 376 .266 .394 .450 .844 .297
vs LHP 397 810 190 43 2 16 126 147 .292 .424 .438 .863 .354

Split G PA H 2B 3B HR BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS BAbip
Matsui vs RHP 824 2644 669 146 6 100 309 317 .291 .375 .490 .865 .299
vs LHP 552 1172 308 50 5 40 107 168 .294 .359 .465 .824 .315

The big question mark with both players is health.  The Yankees had to drain Matsui’s knees a few times last year even though he never played the field.  Nick the Stick has been an injury magnet for most of his career, the zenith being a broken leg at the end of the 2006 season that forced him to sit out 2007.

If I were a gambling man, I’d have to bet on the guy who is five years younger when it comes to health risk.  The Yankees have been closer to Matsui than anybody since he entered the majors and know more about the day to day pain and treatment his ailing legs needed.  They obviously have some doubts about whether Matsui could sustain his 2009 performance for another season.

Likewise, Matsui broke 140+ games for only the second time in four years in 2009, most likely due to the fact that he wasn’t playing the field.  The Yankees must hope that the same tactic as applied to Nick Johnson will improve his durability over the course of the season.

Looking at the numbers above, the big discrepancies between the two players lay in on-base percentage and slugging percentage.  Nick has always been an on-base machine.  Matsui has put up good OBP numbers while slugging much better than Johnson.

Again, we look at these numbers through the health microscope.  If Matsui does take a sharp decline in 2010, his power will go right along with it.  Johnson is 31 this year and figures to have at least a couple of effective seasons left in him.  Chances are, his OBP will maintain.  His SLG has never been great and could see a boost from the new Yankee Stadium.  If it stays where it is, the Yankees will still be happy to collect his walks.

Of the two players, then, Johnson is probably the lower risk.  The five year age difference alone is a big sticking point, one that could lead Matsui to other health issues besides just his knees.

The question remains: where does Johnson fit on this team?

There has been a lot of talk about Johnson being the #2 hitter behind Jeter.  That’s a possibility.  His OBP certainly makes him a guy you would like hitting in from of Mark Teixeira and Alex Rodriguez.  That would push newly acquired Curtis Granderson toward the back of the lineup, possibly dropping into the two spot when Johnson isn’t playing.  Chances are, the Yankees aren’t looking at Johnson to play 145 games this year as they want to get more rest for Jorge Posada and others while keeping their bats in the lineup.

The reaction to these moves, picking up Granderson and Johnson, has left some Yankee fans a little befuddled, thinking their team has taken a step backwards.

Well, I think the case can be made that Johnson proves a better risk for this season than Matsui and possibly shows a bit of upside if the new stadium helps his swing.  What about the trade-off of Damon for Granderson?

Another chart, this one Damon and Grandersons last three years:

Overall AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS
Granderson Total 1796 325 497 87 44 75 211 195 58 11 .277 .350 .499 .849
Overall AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS
Damon Total 1638 295 467 90 10 53 216 201 68 11 .285 .364 .449 .813

It’s worth noting that Granderson put up these numbers as a centerfielder with above average UZR numbers over three years while Damon posted average to bad UZR numbers in left field.*

* Damon’s 2007 and 2008 seasons showed positive UZR ratings in left but only covered a combined 119 games over the two seasons.  His first full season in left, 2009, Damon posted a -9.2 UZR and -12.1 UZR/150.

With these two moves, the Yankees have improved their lineup but they’ve also improved their defense, a concept that has been lost in some of the talk.  Last season, the Yankees didn’t feature the greatest outfield with Nick Swisher in right, Melky Cabrera in center, nad Johnny Damon in left.  Melky and Swish are both adequate, but Damon was horrible.  By shifting Melky and Gardner to left and depositing Granderson in center, their defense should benefit greatly which only adds to the upgrade in offense.

Everyone says this is the end of Johnny Damon in New York and that’s probably true.  It isn’t out of the realm of possibility that Damon could still return under the right terms.  I don’t understand speculation that Matt Holliday and Jason Bay are still possibilities and not Damon.  I find Damon to be a much better risk at two years around $20 million than four years for Bay or possibly six for Holliday.  Holliday is a very good player with very good defense, but his stats while playing at Coors Field were greatly inflated.

Here’s Holliday’s home and road splits during his tenure in Colorado:

Split G GS PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO
2004 Home 63 56 229 204 43 69 18 3 10 36 20 29
Away 58 53 210 196 22 47 13 0 4 21 11 57
2005 Home 63 60 264 241 43 86 13 4 12 52 19 45
Away 62 61 262 238 25 61 11 3 7 35 17 34
2006 Home 78 78 334 295 70 110 24 2 22 78 26 44
Away 77 76 333 307 49 86 21 3 12 36 21 66
2007 Home 82 82 363 327 67 123 28 5 25 82 28 58
Away 76 76 350 309 53 93 22 1 11 55 35 68
2008 Home 73 73 327 286 62 95 23 2 15 59 36 54
Away 66 66 296 253 45 78 15 0 10 29 38 50
Split BA OBP SLG OPS BAbip tOPS+ sOPS+
2004 Home .338 .406 .603 1.009 .355 140 158
Away .240 .287 .367 .654 .319 57 74
2005 Home .357 .409 .593 1.002 .400 131 160
Away .256 .313 .416 .729 .270 69 98
2006 Home .373 .440 .692 1.132 .381 132 185
Away .280 .333 .485 .819 .322 69 116
2007 Home .376 .435 .722 1.157 .400 126 195
Away .301 .374 .485 .860 .352 72 130
2008 Home .332 .413 .584 .997 .367 110 158
Away .308 .405 .486 .892 .351 89 145

Holliday’s road numbers steadily improved towards the end of his stay in Colorado, but look at that BAbip!  That type of consistency goes a bit beyond luck and seems to indicate that Holliday hits the ball hard. Can that type of high BAbip continue?  It has to this point but if it dropped anywhere close to .300, his numbers would take a steep hit.  I don’t know that Holliday warrants the supposed six years he’s hoping to get.

Could the Yankees benefit from Matt Holliday?  Of course they could.  But right now, the Yankees have built a lineup that is probably better than last year’s while improving their outfield defense.  That team scored 915 runs, took the AL East by 8 games and won the World Series.  Adding Holliday is probably not necessary and a bit greedy.

Year Age G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+
Nick 2009 30 133 574 457 71 133 24 2 8 99 84 .291 .426 .405 .831 122
Matsui 2009 35 142 526 456 62 125 21 1 28 64 75 .274 .367 .509 .876 131
Tags: Alex Rodriguez, Bobby Abreu, Brian Cashman, Curtis Granderson, Jason Bay, Johnny Damon, Jorge Posada, Juan Rivera, Mark Teixeira, Matt Holliday, Melky Cabrera, Nick Johnson, Nick Swisher

7 Comments

  1. nick blasioli says:

    why not sign holliday….then they would be set for a while….forget next years free agents…this team with holliday is tops and practically unbeatable…

  2. Scott Ham says:

    Because the backend of Holliday’s deal could be risky. Cashman viewed Teixeira as a more sure thing than Holliday and I agree with him. He’s the type of contract the Yankees are trying to avoid.

  3. Blame Damon and Boras for failure of the Yankees to sign Matsui. The greed of Damon and Boras has stalled negotiations with the Yankees forcing Matsui to look elsewhere.

    The Yankees are just lucky that Nick Johnson is still available at the right price. Nick is not a superstar but he has decent numbers, one that the Yankees will benefit from.

    That’s the way the ball rolls. You win some, you lose some.

    • Scott Ham says:

      I don’t think you’re giving Cashman enough credit. I would have liked to have seen the Yankees re-sign Matsui, but there is a good possibility his knees (or other ailments) will get worse at his age. The Yankees lived with it more than anyone and know the maintenance it took to keep him on the field.

      That’s not to say that Nick doesn’t have his issues, but he hasn’t had any chronic issues. Most of his injuries have been one-off injuries that are not related to each other, save an injury to his right wrist and later his right hand.

      I think Cashman had Matsui at a certain price point but Matsui expressed interest in playing the field. Cashman said no and Matsui sniffed around. If Cashman wanted Matsui back, Matsui would have been back.

  4. Ian says:

    I know people will look at Nick’s SLG and HR totals from last year and think we’ve essentially installed a singles hitter at the top of the lineup, but I don’t necessarily agree. Smart guys like Will Carroll seem to think wrist injuries sap power, and last year was Nick’s first following wrist surgery. He has a career .447 SLG and in his last season before the wrist injury, he hit 23 HR and slugged .520.

    I think it’d be wild to expect him to fully return to those levels, but I think he can improve upon and possibly even double his HR total of 8 from last season, especially in his new home park which appears to be a boon for left-handed power. Combine that with his extraordinary patience, and I think he’s a more than suitable replacement for Damon’s bat. Then you’ve got the power-hitting lefty Granderson replacing Matsui’s bat and (hopefully) providing above average defense, and – call me crazy – this team could be nearly as good offensively as they were last year.

    I say nearly because Tex, Swisher, Jeter, and even Posada have tough acts to follow. Let’s add a starter and head to Spring Training already.

  5. pon says:

    Your logic (age) must tell that the Yankees should let Jeter walk next year toghether with A-Rod, Mo, Posada.

    Your logic (Matsui will decline just in a year) has no reason.

  6. Scott Ham says:

    Pon,
    That’s incorrect. I never said Matsui “will” decline in one year; I said he “could” decline. I also said I would have re-signed Matsui for a year so the conclusion you have drawn doesn’t match what I wrote.

    Cashman had to judge risk against cost in this situation and he didn’t feel Matsui could repeat last year’s performance based on what the Yankees knew about his health. Matsui is certainly a capable hitter who can put up good numbers which is why I wanted him re-signed. But if he can’t stay healthy or effective, he isn’t very helpful.

    Johnson is a risk as well but he’s a lower risk because he doesn’t have a chronic injury, he’s younger and cheaper. And he can play defense which Matsui can not.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.